Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Biopolitical nature of conservation spills over to control of other peoples

Biermann and Anderson ‘17

(Biermann, C. Associate Professor Geography and Environmental Studies Department at u colorado springs , & Anderson, R. M. Postdoctoral researcher at Boston university. Conservation, biopolitics, and the governance of life and death. Geography Compass, October 2017, 11(10), e12329. doi:10.1111/gec3.12329) //OC

Amidst radical changes in conservation, geographic scholarship has sought to make sense of how nature is known, protected, and produced. By contextualizing conservation within Foucauldian biopower and biopolitics, this work has emphasized that the imperative to “make live and let die” extends not only to the governance of human life but also to non‐humans as well. At its core, conservation affirms various kinds of life—endangered species, wildlife with the “right” genetics, forms of life that make more life—while diminishing others. But neither are efforts at calculation and management successful in controlling life nor are their effects confined to the particular bodies that they target. Even as conservation practices and discourses affirm particular lives, they also contribute, along with broader global economic and environmental changes, to the marginalization and “letting die” of some bodies and populations; the lives of rural people in the Global South, for example, have been often made more precarious through the establishment of protected areas. This occurs even as conservation is increasingly justified as a project of affirming human life by protecting nature for the benefit of people. Importantly, however, there is not a single conservation biopolitics but instead a multiplicity of competing and overlapping forms of power/knowledge. Whereas endangered species management tends to essentialize life as it currently exists, aiming to preserve the particular life present on earth today, rewilding focuses not on composition but on promoting processes that will generate new and diverse life in the future. And while protected areas and rewilding both focus on the landscape milieu, breeding and conservation genetics emphasize the strands of DNA that comprise the genetic species body. Each strategy involves different valuations of life and selections of which forms to foster and which to let die or kill. These biopolitical decisions are made through sets of scientific practices and discourses that work to bound life and render it knowable and thus governable. Consequently, a key contribution of the scholarship discussed here has been to track the rendering technical (Li, 2007) of conservation and to bring to light the assumptions, spatial practices, and value‐ laden judgments that constitute it. This notion that conservation is biopolitical—that its foundational understandings and assumptions produce valuations of life that foster some lives while diminishing others—is most effective as a starting point rather than an endpoint for research. The most significant questions that arise from this literature center not on if conservation is biopolitical, or even how, but rather on what the biopolitical stakes are of various conservation discourses and practices. At its best, the Foucauldian biopolitical approach we review here works to expand the possibilities of what conservation involves and who is authorized to take part in debates and decisions about what life should be protected, how, why, and for whom. We envision this potential expansion to be in line with calls from within science and technology studies to enact a science that actively acknowledges the limitations of expert‐led technical analytic frameworks that seek objective, value‐neutral knowledge to inform decision‐making (e.g., Jasanoff, 2007). Indeed, showing conservation to be a biopolitical endeavor may help to normalize debate and uncertainty in science, thus countering recent calls for the excision of values and norms from the ecological sciences (Davis et al., 2011).

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.