Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

A job guarantee wrecks enlistment—high vs low unemployment trends

Crow 19

Mark J., Academy Professor in the Department of Social Sciences at the U.S. Military Academy at West Point, New York and the Director of the Office of Economic and Manpower Analysis. “Economic and Social Determinants of Military Labor Supply: Essays on the Effects of Local Labor Market Conditions and the Opioid Crisis and Service in the U.S. Army.” University of Michigan. 2019. Pp 103-105. LJS

Overall, my results suggest that the employment-to-population ratio is strongly related to the number of individuals expressing interest in enlisting in the military. Specifically, my findings show a decreasing employment-to-population ratio results in more individuals applying to the military which directly results in more individuals entering onto active duty (accessions). However, there is also a concomitant increase in the rate of those disqualified. This implies the individuals being influenced to apply for military service by worsening labor market conditions are relatively less qualified to serve on active duty. When examining my results by applicant quality, the differential impact of the employment-to-population ratio on enlistment behavior becomes clearer: the overall increase in applicants and accessions is driven by increases in both high and low-quality individuals with low-quality responding at higher rates. These results suggest that the sensitivity of low-quality individuals to labor market conditions, previously uninvestigated, is larger than for high quality individuals. Specifically, decreases in the employment-to-population ratio increase the rate of low-quality applicants and accessions more than the rate of high-quality applicants and accessions by factors of six and two, respectively. This is consistent with the notion that low-quality individuals might be the most vulnerable in periods of increasing unemployment and likely have the fewest civilian labor market options. This, however, does not comport with a “crowding out” story where the ability of low-quality recruits to enlist during periods of economic contraction is impacted by the number of high-quality individuals expressing interest in the military (Ellwood and Wise 1987).84 The causal estimates in my findings, while similar in sign, are larger than the OLS estimates I report and that have been found in previous studies. This indicates that existing literature that neglected the correlation between changes in labor supply and economic conditions likely underestimated the effect of labor demand shocks on the enlistment response of both high and low-quality individuals.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.