The pursuit of hegemony is unsustainable – lack of funding and overstretch destroy American primacy
Metz 18 (Steven, Senior Research Professor of National Security Affairs at the U.S. Army War College Strategic Studies Institute, 5-9-2018, "America’s Increasingly Unsustainable Pursuit of Global Primacy," No Publication, https://www.worldpoliticsreview.com/articles/26874/america-s-increasingly-unsustainable-pursuit-of-global-primacy)//EAW
The United States obsesses about its global strategy more than any nation on earth. This fixation is reflected in the fact that Congress requires the executive branch to produce regular reports on its security strategy. A year ago, the Trump administration published its inaugural National Security Strategy. A few months later, the Pentagon released its National Defense Strategy to explain how U.S. military power would be used to implement the National Security Strategy. As it has in the past, Congress then created a bipartisan National Defense Strategy Commission to assess the Pentagon’s strategy. This included an august team of top policy experts and former officials from the Pentagon, the uniformed military, Congress, the intelligence community and the diplomatic corps. A few weeks ago, this commission released its latest report. Unsurprisingly, and despite the appearance of constant and vigorous policy debate in Washington, the report didn’t offer any alternatives to the strategy that the United States has pursued for the past few decades, instead recommending an even more vigorous pursuit of global primacy and military dominance. It looked like the mainstream position on American strategy on steroids. America’s fixation with primacy and military dominance, while now the orthodoxy, is a relatively recent thing. It was initially intended as a temporary expedient to help stave off the Soviet Union as Europe and other regions rebuilt after World War II and dozens of new nations emerged out of the former European colonial empires. But during the course of the Cold War, the United States somehow became addicted to primacy, no longer seeing it as a temporary expedient but as the new normal. It didn’t have to be this way. When the Soviet Union collapsed in 1991, the United States might have considered its global mission complete, disengaged from all but the most vital parts of the world, and undertaken a major military demobilization. Instead, political leaders opted for a smaller but even more advanced and adept military, seeking to “overmatch” any potential adversary. Along the way, the use of armed force became the tool of first resort in American statecraft, supplanting the balanced mix of military, diplomatic and economic power that characterized America’s Cold War strategy. Although a few policy experts and political leaders have advocated a more restrained approach to national security, most of them, both Republicans and Democrats, remain committed to global primacy and military dominance. Making the case for this requires convincing the public that the alternatives are dangerous, even frightening. The National Defense Strategy Commission report hits this theme hard. “The security and wellbeing of the United States are at greater risk than at any time in decades,” it warns. “America’s military superiority—the hard-power backbone of its global influence and national security—has eroded to a dangerous degree. Rivals and adversaries are challenging the United States on many fronts and in many domains. America’s ability to defend its allies, its partners, and its own vital interests is increasingly in doubt. If the nation does not act promptly to remedy these circumstances, the consequences will be grave and lasting.” Americans are so accustomed to global primacy and military dominance that they have difficulty imagining other options or seriously weighing the costs against the benefits. The implication of this dark perspective is that the U.S. defense budget, which is already the largest on earth by far, needs to be increased. Just this week, the Senate Armed Services Committee heard testimony from the commission and used it to call for even more Pentagon funding. But what the National Defense Strategy Commission or any equivalent group hasn’t done is seriously examine or reckon with the underlying assumptions of this orthodox strategy. For instance, advocates assume that without U.S. military dominance, the global system—or at least some parts of it—will devolve into conflict or fall under the control of hostile nations that might keep the United States out of the regions they monopolize. That was a valid concern during the Cold War when America faced an expansionistic Soviet Union bent on world domination. But it no longer is. The idea that China, Russia, Iran or some other adversary might shut out American businesses for political reasons is farfetched in today’s interconnected global economy. Yet the idea that America’s economic health depends on primacy and military dominance has been repeated so often that it is an article of faith among mainstream policy experts and political leaders. Another questionable assumption is that the United States must be capable of militarily overmatching any potential adversary. While military dominance is certainly nice to have, the only way to sustain it is by increased deficit spending, cutting entitlements like Social Security and Medicare, diminishing investment in health care, infrastructure and education, or increasing taxes. Making the Department of Defense more efficient, which is often touted as a magic bullet, is a good idea, but even the National Defense Strategy Commission admitted that it will not be enough to sustain, much less increase, America’s military dominance. Today though, Americans are so accustomed to global primacy and military dominance that they have difficulty imagining other options or seriously weighing the costs against the benefits. As Patrick Porter, a professor of strategic studies at the University of Exeter, puts it, “Alternative grand strategies based on restraint and retrenchment are hardly entertained, and debate is narrowed into questions of execution and implementation.” So long as this continues, the United States will remain stubbornly committed to its quest for global primacy and military dominance, hoping against hope that some elixir of Pentagon reform and increased support from U.S. allies will make it work. Eventually, though, this myth will collapse, and then a serious debate about America’s role in the world will really begin.