Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Vote negative to refuse work – our alternative embraces a ‘worthwhile ethic’ and promotes research strategies that resist alienation and work dogma. Debate is a unique site for utopian thinking and your ballot can be a radical act of autonomy.

Frayne ’15 (David, lecturer and social researcher based at Cardiff University, The Refusal of Work: The Theory and Practice of Resistance to Work, 2015, pg. 230-237, https://sabrinasoyer.files.wordpress.com/2016/05/the-refusal-of-work.pdf)

The vocabulary of my own book has not been a vocabulary of responsibility and duty, but a vocabulary of freedom. My main focus has been on our troubled desire to escape the realities of working life, and my belief is that the most crucial advantage of less work is its promise to allow us to live more varied and convivial lives. For my part, the call for less work is at its most compelling as a celebration of the human capacity for autonomy: ‘the capacity to represent and recreate oneself and one’s relationships, the freedom to design, within obvious bounds, our own lives’ (Weeks, 2011: 168) – a capacity that the work-centred society has blocked through processes of alienation and colonisation. Ultimately, however, if we want to build a strong case against work, we should take a moment to recognise the breadth of today’s critical contributions. Activists would do well to stress that a resistance to the work dogma can simultaneously be a resistance for the environment, for health, for gender equality, for the family, for personal autonomy, and, let us also not forget, for fun

2. Take an active interest in society’s outsiders A research intervention into the work dogma would require researchers to take an active interest in the values and practices of people on the margins of society. The role I imagine for the researcher here is a person who uses her skills and insight to work in solidarity with movements for the refusal of work. Max Haiven and Alex Khasnabish have argued that today’s monopolisation of social research by academic institutions has too often seen researchers working on rather than with social movements. Too often the role of the researcher is to ‘swoop in’ from above, applying a disciplinary perspective and generating grist for the academic mill (Haiven and Khasnabish, 2014: 13). As Michael Billig argues, the publications tied to these research endeavours are often unintelligible and highly self-referential (and, in any case, often fail to see the light of day outside the academy) (Billig, 2013). Like Haiven and Khasnabish, I would like to see a confident defence of the researcher who works in solidarity with social movements for the purposes of transformative social change, as opposed to working on social movements for the purposes of generating academic capital.

In order to foster a longer-term research project on the refusal of work, researchers would need the good mind to approach people on the margins of society not merely as excluded individuals, in need of reintegration, but as potential sources of inspiration for a case against work. An emancipatory social science would resist normalising lifestyles based on work and consumerism, and avoid the suggestion that deviation from this norm always necessarily entails an experience of deprivation and shame. What we might hope to see are more research projects that think through those exemplary experiences and practices that explore ways of living, co-operating, expressing and creating, outside the de-skilled and micro-managed sphere of employment. What we might hope to see are more research projects that remain open to the possibility of meeting needs in less conventional ways, outside the ambit of economic exchange relations. Through their investigations, perhaps researchers will be able to shed more light on the unsung inventiveness of people who are already developing their own conceptions of pleasure, sufficiency, wealth and well-being, fit for a less work-centred society. And if researchers are willing to communicate their findings in clear style, perhaps readers will draw inspiration from these examples, with once disparate or fragmented groups of refusers and outsiders achieving a greater sense of unity and collective purpose.

3. Join the battle of words. And turn up armed The battle against the work dogma is to some extent a battle over language. Throughout this book, we have seen several examples of society’s ability to chew up and swallow resistance, either by taking possession of radical language, or by closing off critical communications prematurely. If it was once thought that capitalist ideologies could be challenged by asserting a right to ‘be ourselves’, Chapter 2 showed how this idea has been co-opted by today’s managerial cultures of fun. If many have spoken out against work, Chapter 4 showed how dissenting voices have been suppressed and humiliated by the media’s tendency to discuss acts of resistance in a language of deviance and individual pathology. If critics of the work dogma want to join this linguistic battle, they had better turn up armed. For example, how about responding to the moral panic around today’s so-called ‘culture of entitlement’ by developing a critique of today’s more prevalent ‘culture of gratitude’? It is the culture of gratitude that thrives when, buckling under the pressure to survive, people begin to hurl themselves into any form of work that promises to boost their career profile, whether the work in question is paid or unpaid, suitable or unsuitable. The culture of gratitude flourishes in my own field of academia, where fierce job competition leaves junior academics with little choice but to dive headfirst into any possible work openings. In this hyper-competitive context, it has almost become a matter of bad taste to fuss about issues like contracts, payment, and working conditions. You should just be grateful to have an opportunity in the first place (see Brunning, 2014). Instead of frowning upon people who resist work for their supposed sense of entitlement, how about we all get a little more entitled, and build a bold new critique of today’s culture of gratitude?

Overall, it seems we need to become more creative with our language and steer the discussion in ways which expose the outdated nature of the work ethic. We need to challenge economic rationality by finding ways of talking about the intrinsic, cultural and societal value of non-work activities. We need to reinvent the term work to describe a far wider range of activities than paid employment, and we need to dispel the false dichotomy which says that a person is either working or doing nothing of any value. The question of what we might choose to call a movement against work seems quite important, too. At several points in this book, I have referred to my interviewees’ motivations using David Cannon’s notion of a ‘worthwhile ethic’. Adopting a ‘worthwhile ethic’ means questioning the sanctity of paid work and insisting that there are other, potentially more worthwhile, activities around which life might be organised. I borrowed this term because it seemed to have certain benefits as a way of describing resistance to work. The most obvious is its deliberate mirroring of the concept it hopes to replace – the work ethic – but it also has several other strengths. First of all, the notion of a movement based on the ‘worthwhile ethic’ avoids the pitfall of trying to unite people on the basis of existing social categories such as class or gender. A range of people stand to benefit from the shift to a less work-centred society, and the desire for a more self-determined life does not belong to any single demographic. The desire to transcend a work-centred existence germinates wherever people experience a gap between their ideals and realities, and wherever people sense a rift between their socially prescribed roles and their sense of self. This is true whether these people are old or young, male or female, with or without families, working or not working, rich or poor. As a banner under which people could potentially unite, an advantage of the ‘worthwhile ethic’ is that it is broad, and does not confine the struggle to any particular cultural group. What counts as ‘worthwhile’ is up to each person to decide.

Another conceptual advantage of the ‘worthwhile ethic’ is that it stresses a point I have been making throughout this book: that those who resist the work ethic are not necessarily without morals, as the stereotypes often suggest. The reference to an ethic insists that there are principles other than dedication to work that might allow people to give their lives meaning and a sense of direction. In this sense, the notion of a worthwhile ethic could be considered an improvement over the concept of ‘idling’, as a rallying cry against the work dogma. Even though the latter is intended to be humorous (and, in the case of the Idler’s Alliance, had succeeded in capturing the imaginations of a diverse range of people), it is counterintuitive if it ends up reinforcing the belief that resisting work is always about leading a lazy life. Several interviewees in my study who were not affiliated with the Idler’s Alliance were actually somewhat dismayed to be participating in the same study as people calling themselves ‘idlers’, because they felt this to be a misrepresentation of their active lifestyles. Where possible, we should try to show that a life without work is not necessarily empty and morally rudderless.

4. Defend the importance of imagination To finish, I would also like to stress the importance of an ongoing commitment to a utopian style of thinking and analysis. Ruth Levitas defines utopia as ‘the expression of the desire for a better way of living’ (Levitas, 1990: 9). Instead of extrapolating from the present, utopian thinking prompts us to think first about where we might want to be, and then about how we might get there. Imagining an alternative and more desirable future helps us to reflect upon the desires which our present social conditions have generated but left unfulfilled. If this sounds like a worthwhile project, however, the adjective ‘utopian’ is just as commonly used in a pejorative sense, to refer to a person who advocates unrealistic reforms, or nurses an absurd desire for societal perfection. As Levitas points out, this dismissal ranges from the good-humoured to the deadly serious. At one end of the scale, the utopian is labelled a dreamer, whereas at the other end, the utopian is seen as a tyrant, having forgotten the historical links between utopianism and totalitarianism (Levitas, 1990: 3). In my own experience, it is in the derogative sense that the word utopian is usually heard.

Against this trend, I would like us to defend the value of a more utopian mode of thinking and talking. If the recent economic crises have shown us anything, it is that crisis alone is not enough to bring about genuine social change. No matter how much crises escalate, positive changes cannot occur unless we as a society remain open to the idea that an alternative might actually be possible. The point of utopian thinking is to remind us that there are always ways of doing things differently; it prompts us to assemble something new out of a crisis instead of seeking ever more absurd ways of accommodating social problems within the present system. It seems to me that no matter how broken the work-centred society becomes – no matter how bad the rates of unemployment and underemployment get, no matter how stressed and downtrodden today’s workers feel, no matter how much this stress bleeds out in the form of racism, violence and addiction, and no matter how much strain economic growth places on the environment – a positive social change cannot occur unless we begin actively to entertain and explore the possibility of alternatives. To once again borrow a phrase from Kathi Weeks, the importance of utopian thinking is in ‘neutralising the hold of the present’ (Weeks, 2011: 205). It is designed to help us think beyond our all-too-familiar horizons of possibility.

This does not mean providing and enforcing a prescriptive blueprint for social change, and nor is there any suggestion here that less work could be a cure for all societal ills. What I have wanted to do in this book is simply present an opportunity to raise questions about aspects of the social world that might otherwise be taken for granted or seem unalterable. Developing a new imaginative attitude does not entail denying the present necessities and gratifications of work, but it does mean creating some healthy critical distance between ourselves and the work-centred society. Utopian commentary should attempt to provoke, incite and inspire, to educate the reader’s sense of desire and, without succumbing to bland optimism, appeal to a feeling of hope. If others would point out the unrealistic nature of utopian thinking, the critic should retort by pointing out that our notions of what is realistic are socially structured, as well as the deluded nature of believing that things could comfortably go on as they are.

Ultimately, it is undeniable that working grants access to a range of vital pleasures – if not always in the production process itself, then in the form of social interaction, monetary rewards, a sense of status, or the opportunity to have a public existence. The question I pose, however, is why must our entitlement to these things depend on our submission to work – an activity that is often exploitative and environmentally harmful, not to mention scarce? Why can’t we begin a political discussion by thinking about other ways in which the need for income, rights, and a sense of belonging could be satisfied? To any who would suggest that there is no alternative to the work-centred society, I submit that it is a profoundly sad society that cannot envisage a future where a sense of social solidarity and purpose are achieved through anything other than commodity relations.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.