Refusal of the social factory wherein work consumes our entire society is key to rights and resistance
Carmichael ’19 (Patrick Carmichael, Managing Director of Camtree: The Cambridge Teacher Research Exchange. Camtree is creating a global platform for educators who wish to reflect on their practice and conduct research to improve learning in their classrooms and institution, “Refusal of Work, Liberation of Time and the Convivial University”, Education and Technological Unemployment, 30 April 2019, https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-981-13-6225-5_17) //OC
Operaismo also explored the idea of the ‘social factory’ whereby society as a¶ whole was organized according to the same principles of domination, production¶ and consumption as the workplace, although its critics have argued that while attention was paid to domestic labour, for example, this was still explored through a¶ theoretical lens that ascribed a central role to the industrial ‘mass worker’. According to this perspective, education can be seen not as a separate domain, but as a¶ particular form of work, and teachers and students are not separated from workers¶ as ‘intellectuals’. Students are workers in formation: already linked to the productive cycles of capitalism, not only by virtue of the marketization of education, and¶ employer input into curriculum and pedagogy, but through the need to work to fund¶ their studies, or by having opportunities to study constrained by their involvement¶ in other forms of labour (often gender-specific) in the social factory. The everyday¶ life of academic workers (students, teachers, researchers and others) blurs the spatial¶ and temporal distinctions between home; school, college or university; and work,¶ making educational settings both social factories in their own right (Selwyn 2014:¶ 71) and part of a broader social factory tied to capitalist production.¶ Alquati’s accounts of work at Fiat and Olivetti presaged developments that have¶ affected not only industrial settings but other sectors of the economy including education. Already, in the 1960s, automation was not simply replacing mundane manual¶ labour, but, as Alquati described, highly trained and supposedly highly invested¶ technicians were already becoming regarded as dispensable, with their roles being¶ reduced to piecework or replaced entirely (Alquati 1975: 37–38). Aspects of traditionally manual labour were becoming ‘intellectualised’ and demanding of new¶ techno-literacies, while at the same time skilled and intellectually demanding work¶ was becoming proletarianized and precarious. Contemporary patterns of automation¶ are continuing this pattern of not simply replacing manual labour but also making¶ inroads into middle-class jobs, compounding the ‘professional precarity’ already¶ enabled by marketization and neoliberalism. So, while the specifics may differ from¶ the situations about which Alquati and Panzieri were writing, there remains the¶ potential for self-elucidating workers’ inquiry and co-research as a basis for radical¶ refusal of work. Alquati’s ‘model’ question regarding FIAT could easily be reframed¶ to ask student workers in formation to consider ‘What different things can I hope for¶ in a society dominated by businesses like Amazon or Uber’ or, alternatively, ‘What¶ different things can I hope for in a society where automation has led to widespread¶ technological unemployment, including my own?’¶ Summarizing the operaist position on refusal, Thoburn argues that ‘the refusal of¶ work can… be seen as… a propulsive force towards inventive practice within and¶ against the productive regimes of the social factory’ (Thoburn 2003: 111). Rather¶ than the abolition of labour as an aspect of an idealized future communist society,¶ in operaismo, the refusal of work, together with workers’ inquiry and co-research,¶ represent a radical praxis; an active means of exploring alternative ways of being¶ outside capitalist cycles of production and consumption. Before discussing in more¶ detail what this might involve in the context of higher education, it is important to¶ examine the rather different perspectives on work, refusal and education of André¶ Gorz.