Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Automation escapes the link between work and goods

Danaher 16 (John Danaher, 3-11-2016, "Will Life Be Worth Living in a World Without Work? Technological Unemployment and the Meaning of Life," SpringerLink, https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11948-016-9770-5, 14-16) @HA?

These ‘work is bad’ arguments can be complemented by a set of ‘opportunity cost’ arguments. These arguments accept that work might have many good-making properties but insist that non-work is better. The opportunity cost arguments have been implicit in the discussion thus far. They can now be made explicit. For starters, it is worth pointing out that one’s choice of work is always limited by what kinds of activities are economically viable. And the kinds of activities that are economically viable are dependent on where wealth is located and how that wealth is disposed (Graeber 2011). There is no guarantee that distribution via the labour market allow workers to spend their lives in the pursuits they find most fulfilling. If we could break the link between income and how we choose to spend our time, then we could spend our time in the manner that best suits our skills, desires and aptitudes. Thus, the biased nature of the market gives us some reason to think that non-work is preferable to work. There are other instrumental and intrinsic reasons for thinking that non-work is better. Russell (2004), for instance, argues that the leisure classes (i.e. those free from 15 the necessity of work) have always been responsible for the scientific, cultural, and political developments that form the backbone of our civilisation. Consequently, he believes that freeing up more people into the leisure class will make for a better world. Bob Black takes a slightly different tack. He argues that the ‘ludic life’ (i.e. the playful life, free from work) is intrinsically better than the working one, and believes that it could lead to “a collective adventure in generalized joy and freely interdependent exuberance” (Black 1986). These ‘opportunity cost’ arguments can be resisted on the grounds that even if the ludic, leisurely life is better than the working one, work itself is necessary in order to secure greater goods (e.g. supply of food and healthcare for all, money to pay for leisure activities). Or, alternatively, on the grounds that they ignore the opportunity costs of non-work itself. Income is not the only good we derive from work in the modern world. As Gheaus and Herzog (forthcoming) have recently argued, there are at least four nonmonetary goods associated with paid work: (i) excellence in the cultivation of our skills; (ii) contribution to society; (iii) a sense of community and (iv) social status. People want to be good at what they do; they want to make a difference to the world in which they live; they want to engage in collective enterprises; and they want to be recognised and validated in the eyes of their social peers. Paid work is the main forum in which they attain these four goods. Are we going to be cutting people off from these sources of meaning and flourishing in a post-work world? I would argue that both forms of resistance are much less compelling if we are living through an era of technological unemployment. The prospect of near ubiquitous automating technologies seems to break the allegedly necessary link between work and these goods. Gheaus and Herzog themselves acknowledge that paid work is a privileged context for the attainment of the four goods they identify partly because we have to spend so much of our time doing it. It thus becomes the only real outlet we have for achieving excellence, social contribution, community and social status. But there is nothing intrinsic to work as I define it in this paper (performance of a skill for economic reward) that makes it the only forum for achieving those goods. People can, and do, achieve excellence, social contribution, community and status in leisure activities, voluntary charitable activities and hobbies. They tend not to because they are forced to spend their time in economically productive forms of work. If technology can take over 16 the economically productive activities, then the instrumental and intrinsic virtues of these non-work contexts can flourish.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.