Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The workplace presupposes a neoliberal form of subjectivity that is superimposed upon the world in order to justify mass violence and homogenization. This also makes transition wars and economic collapse inevitable as it fails to understand how the crucial problem of today is one of symbolic exchange. Against this, we should withdraw from necroeconomics.

Bifo 2011 (Franco Berardi, Professor of Social history of communication at the Accademia di belle Arit in Milan and Founder of A/traverse, After the Future, p. 141-147)

More than ever, economic rationality is at odds with social rationality. Economic science is not part of the solution to the crisis: it is the source of the problem. The lead article in The Economist of July 18, 2009, was: "What went wrong with economics?" The text is an attempt to downplay the crisis of economic knowledge and the profession of economics. For neoliberal economists, the central dogma of growth, profit, and competition cannot be questioned, because it is identified with the perfect mathematical rationality of the market. And belief in the intrinsic rationality of the market is crucial in the economic theology of neoliberalism. But the reduction of social life to the rational exchange of economic values is an obsession that has nothing to do with science. It's a political strategy aimed at identifying humans as calculating machines, at shaping behavior and perception in such a way that money becomes the only motivation for social action. But it's not an accurate description of social dynamics, the conflicts, pathologies, and irrationality of human relationships. It's an attempt to create the anthropological form of homo calculans that Foucault (2008) has described in his 1979/80 seminar, The Birth of Biopolitics. This attempt to see human beings as calculating devices has produced cultural devastation, and has finally shown itself to be based upon flawed assumptions. Human beings do calculate, but their calculation isn't perfectly rational, because the value of goods is not determined by objective reasons, and because decisions are influenced by what Keynes called "animal spirits:' In their book of the same name, Akerlof and Shiller (2009, 1) note, "We will never really understand important economic events unless we confront the fact that their causes are largely mental in nature," echoing Keynes's assumption that the rationality of the market is not perfect in itself. Akerlof and Shiner are acknowledging the crisis of neoliberal thought, but their critique is not radical enough, and does not touch the legitimary of the economic episteme. Animal Spirits is also the title of a book by Matteo Pasquinelli (2008). Pasquinelli deals with bodies, numbers, and parasites, and goes much deeper in his understanding of the roots of the crisis than Akerlof and Shiner: "Cognitive capitalism emerges later in the form of a pazasite: it subjects social knowledge and inhibits its emancipatory potential" (93). "Beyond the computer screen, precarious workers and freelancers experience how Free Labor and competition are increasingly devouring their everyday life" (15). Pasquinelli goes to the core of the problem: the virtualization of social production has caused the proliferation of a parasite, destroying the prerequisites of living relationships, absorbing and neutralizing the living energies of cognitive workers. The economic recession is not only the effect of financial craziness, but also the effect of the devitalization of the social field. This is why the collapse of the economic system is also the collapse of an economic epistemology that has guided politics for the last two centuries. Economics cannot understand the depth of the crisis, because below the crisis of financial exchange there is the crisis of symbolic exchange. I mean the psychotic boom of panic, depression, and suicide, the general decline of desire and social empathy. The question that rises from the collapse is so radical that its answer cannot be found in an economic conceptual framework. Furthermore, one must ask if economics really is a science? If the word "science" means the creation of concepts in order to understand and describe an object, economics is not a science. Its object does not exist. The objects of economics (scarcity, wage labor, and profit) do not exist before and outside the performative action of the economic episteme. Production, consumption, and daily life become part of the economic discourse when labor is detached and opposed to human activity, when it falls under the domination of capitalist rule. The economic object does not pre-exist conceptual activity, and economic description is in fact normative. In this sense, economics is a technique, a semiotization of the world, and also a mythology, a narration. Economics is a suggestion and a categorical imperative: Money makes things happen. It is the source of action in the world and perhaps the only power we invest in. Life seems to depend on it. Everything within us would like to say that it does not, that this cannot be. But the Almighty Dollar has taken command. The more it is denied the more it shows itself as Almighty. Perhaps in every other respect, in every other value, bankruptcy has been declared, giving money the power of some sacred deity, demanding to be recognized. Economics no longer persuades money to behave. Numbers cannot make the beast lie down and be quiet or sit up and do tricks. At best, economics is a neurosis of money, a symptom contrived to hold the beast in abeyance.... Thus economics shares the language of psychopathology—inflation, depression, lows and highs, slumps and peaks, investments and losses. (Bordello 1983). From the age of the enclosures in England, the economic process has been a process that produces scarcity (scarcification). The enclosures were intended to scarcify the land, the basic means of survival, so that people who so far had been able to cultivate food for their family were forced to become proletarians, then waged industrial workers. Capitalism is based on the artificial creation of need, and economic science is essentially a technique of scarcification of time, life, and food. Under conditions of scarcity, human beings are subjected to exploitation and to the domain of profit-oriented activity. After scarcifying the land (enclosures) capitalism has scarcified time itself, forcing people who don't have property beyond their own life and body, to lend their life-time to capital. Now the capitalist obsession for growth is making both water and air scarce. Economic science is not the science of prediction: it is the technique of producing, implementing, and exacerbating scarcity and need. This is why Maw did not speak of economy, but of political economy. The technique of economic scarcification is based on a mythology, a narration that identifies wealth as property and acquisition, and subjugates the possibility of living to the lending of time and the transformation of human activity into wage labor. In recent decades, technological change has slowly eroded the very foundations of economic science. Shifting from the sphere of production of material objects to the semiocapitalist production of immaterial goods, the economic concepts are losing their foundation and legitimacy. The basic categories of economics are becoming totally artificial. The theoretical justification of private property, as one can read in the writings of John Locke, is based on the need for exclusive consumption. An apple must be privatized, if you want to avoid the danger that someone else might eat your apple. But what happens when goods are immaterial, infinitely replicable without cost? Thanks to digitalization and immaterialization of the production process, the economic nomos of private property loses its ground, its raison d'etre, and it can be imposed only by force. Furthermore, the very foundation of wages, the relationship between time needed for production and value of the product, is vanishing. The immaterialization and cognitivization of production makes it almost impossible to quantify the average time needed to produce value. Time and value become incommensurable, and violence becomes the only law able to determine price and wage. The neoliberal school, which has opened the way to the worldwide deregulation of social production, has fostered the mythology of rational expectations in economic exchange, and has touted the idea of a self-regulated market, primarily the labor market. But self-regulation is a lie. In order to increase exploitation, and to destroy social welfare, global capitalism has used political institutions like the International Monetary Fund and the World Trade Organization, not to mention the military enforcement of the political decisions of these institutions. Far from being self-regulated, the market is militarily regulated. The mythology of free individuals loyally competing on the basis of perfect knowledge of the market is a lie, too. Real human beings are not perfect, rational calculating machines. And the myth of rational expectations has finally crashed after the explosion of the real estate mortgage bubble. The theory of rational expectation is crucial in neoliberal thought: the economic agents are supposed to be free to choose in a perfectly rational way the best deal in selling and buying. The fraud perpetrated by the investment agencies has destroyed the lives of millions of Americans, and has exposed the theoretical swindle. Economic exchange cannot be described as a rational game, because irrational factors play a crucial role in social life in general. Trickery, misleading information, and psychic manipulation are not exceptions, but the professional tools of advertisers, financial agents, and economic consultants. The idea that social relationships can be described in mathematical terms has the force of myth, but it is not science, and it has nothing to do with natural law. Notwithstanding the failure of the theory, neoliberal politics are still in control of the global machine, because the criminal class that has seized power has no intention of stepping down, and because the social brain is unable to recompose and find the way to self-organization. I read in the New York Times on September 6, 2009: After the mortgage business imploded last year, Wall Street investment banks began searching for another big idea to make money. They think they may have found one. 'The bankers plan to buy "life settlements," life insurance policies that ill and elderly people sell for cash—$400,000 fora $1 million polity, say, depending on the life expectancy of the insured person. Then they plan to "securitize" these policies, in Wall Street jargon, by packaging hundreds or thousands together into bonds. They will then resell those bonds to investors, like big pension funds, who will receive the payouts when people with the insurance die. The earlier the policyholder dies, the bigger the return—though if people live longer than expected, investors could get poor returns or even lose money. Imagine that I buy an insurance policy on my life (something I would absolutely not do). My insurer, of course, will wish me a long life, so I'll pay the premiums for a long time, rather than him paying lots of money to my family if I die. But some enlightened finance guru has the brilliant idea of insuring the insurer. He buys the risk, and he invests in the hope that I die soon. You don't need the imagination of Philip K. Dick to guess how the story ends: financial agents will be motivated to kill me overnight. The talk of recovery is based on necronomy, the economy of death. It's not new, as capitalism has always profited from wars, slaughters, and genocides. But now the equation becomes unequivocal. Death is the promise, death is the investment and the hope. Death is the best future that capitalism may secure. The logic of speculation is different from the logic of spectacle that was dominant in late-modern times. Spectacle is the mirrorization of life, the transfer of life in the mirror of spectacular accumulation. Speculation is the subjugation of the future to its financial mirror, the substitution of present life with future money that will never come, because death will come first. The lesson that we must learn from the first year of the global recession is sad: neoliberal folly is not going away, the financial high rollers will not stop their speculation, corporations will not stop their exploitation, and the political class, largely controlled by the corporate lobbies, is unwilling or unable to protect society from the final assault. In 1996 J. G. Ballard (188) wrote: "the most perfect crime of all—when the victims are either willing, or aren't aware that they are victims." Democracy seems unable to stop the criminal class that has seized control of the economy, because the decisions are no longer made in the sphere of political opinion, but in the inaccessible sphere of economic automatism. The economy has been declared the basic standard around which decisions are made, and the economists have systematically identified the economy with the capitalist obsession of growth. No room for political choice is left, as corporate principles have become embedded in the technical fabric of language and imagination.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.