Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The colonizing power of work ensnares individuals in a relentless cycle of labor. The ostensible free-time never detaches from the essence of work, dehumanizing workers into mere cogs in the labor machine.

Frayne ’15 [David, PhD, a sociologist taking a critical perspective on the future of work and welfare. “The Refusal of Work: The Theory and Practice of Resistance to Work”; 2015, Bloomsbury Academic; p. 60-70. https://sabrinasoyer.files.wordpress.com/2016/05/the-refusal-of-work.pdf; JFan]

Economic rationality has no room for authentically free time which neither produces nor consumes commercial wealth.

André Gorz - Critique of Economic Reason (1989: 115)

In her study The Outsourced Self (Hochschild, 2012), Arlie Hochs-child interviewed a range of people who were catering to their needs not by spending time or co-operating with friends and family, but by spending money on commercial services. Rich in money but short on time, the people she met were relying on dating services, wedding planners, eldercare managers and birthday party organisers to meet their personal and familial needs. With her signature empathy and eye for detail, Hochschild explored the appeal of these services from the perspective of the people who used them, but also the potential drawbacks involved, as life becomes increasingly impersonal and commercialised. Reflecting on her study at a speaking event, Hochschild expressed her particular surprise at how many of the people she met had invested in pristine kitchen fittings or brand-new, hi-tech ovens. This seemed ironic to her, given the busyness of these people's lives, and their evident lack of time to use these facilities. Why upgrade your oven if you haven't got time to cook? Hochschild speculated that the new kitchen appliances acted like totems for the people who bought them: the brand-new oven, sparkling and unused, is a gesture towards the leisurely lifestyle people wished they had. We could interpret the clutter of the young professional's apartment in much the same way. The shelves full of half-read novels, the racks full of dusty CDs, and the cupboards full of mouldering camping equipment become symbols of the leisurely life that workers hoped they would have, before their jobs took over.

The topic of this chapter is leisure or, more precisely, why we seem to have so little leisure, and why the leisure time that we do have is so often suffused with a sense of responsibility and anxiety.

The current popularity of self-help books coaching their readers to slow down and enjoy life (e.g., Honoré, 2004; Hodgkinson, 2004), as well as the weekly appearance of discussions on 'work-life balance in broadsheet newspapers, are testaments to the extent to which people are feeling hurried and squeezed in their free-time. According to the International Labour Organisation, in 2013 the UK workforce (including part-time, as well as full-time workers) put in an average of 35.8 hours per week, compared with a 38.6 hour average in the USA. This is a far cry from Keynes's predictions of a radically shorter working week. Figures published by the Trade Union Congress for 2014 suggested that around 20% of the UK workforce regularly work overtime without pay. Within this 20%, the average unpaid hours per week was 7.7 (or an estimated £32bn in unpaid wages), but hundreds of thousands of workers (particularly those in education, hospitality, and mining) reported working nine to ten unpaid hours per week (Trade Union Congress, 2015). The statistics on working hours give a fair assessment of the quantitative impact of work, but in this chapter I argue that the experienced shortage of and anxiety over leisure time is a widespread cultural phenomenon with an important qualitative dimension, and not therefore the preserve of the people with the longest working hours. The degradation of leisure needs to be understood as a symptom of the broader tendency of economic demands to colonise everyday life. At a time when education risks becoming little more than a joyless pursuit of certification for work, when our interactions with others are often shaped by a need for career advancement, and when unemployment has been turned into 'jobseeking' - itself a form of work - how much of our time can we confidently call our own? When, precisely, are we genuinely released from the demand to either produce or consume economic wealth, to become truly free to experience the world and its culture?

“Free-time”

I begin with a simple-sounding question: at what point does a day's work truly end? Whilst our jobs might contractually oblige us to work a certain amount of hours per day, it is clear that we do not simply step out of our workplaces and into a world of freedom. This was brought to light by Theodor Adorno in a short but poignant essay from the 1970s called 'Free Time' (Adorno, 2001). Adorno questioned the extent to which workers are truly autonomous in their time outside work, arguing that the covert aim of non-work time is simply to prepare people for the recommencement of work: free-time is not free at all, but a mere continuation of the forms of profit-oriented social life' (Adorno, 2001: 189). This is because it involves activities which often have a similar quality to work (looking at screens, doing chores), but also because more alienating or exhausting forms of work produce a powerful need for recuperation. By draining people's physical and mental energies, work that is alienating ensures that much of the worker's non-work time is spent winding down, retreating to escapist forms of entertainment, or consuming treats which compensate for the day's travails.

If the recuperative or compensatory activities we undertake in our free-time are often enjoyable, Adorno would ultimately argue that they are expressions of a superficial liberty. He argues that free-time is not really free at all, so long as it remains guided by the forces that people are trying to escape. He insists on the need for a distinction between free-time and the more auspicious category of true leisure. If free-time represents a mere continuation of work, then it is true leisure which represents that sweet oasis of unmediated life in which people detach from economic demands and become genuinely free for the world and its culture. Adorno argues that it is the degraded form - free-time, rather than true leisure - which prevails in affluent societies.' In this degraded free-time, the self-defined activities performed outside employment tend to be restricted to 'hobbies: trifling activities performed in order to pass the meagre time which is our own. Adorno passionately rejected the term hobby, believing that it trivialises the value of unpaid activities.

In one memorable passage, he remarked proudly:

I have no hobby. Not that I am the kind of workaholic, who is incapable of doing anything with his time but applying himself industriously to the required task. But, as far as my activities beyond the bounds of my recognised profession are concerned, I take them all, without exception, very seriously ... Making music, listening to music, reading with all my attention, these activities are part and parcel of my life; to call them hobbies would make a mockery of them. (Adorno, 2001: 188-9)

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.