The structure of the workplace most closely resembles a cult – its benign control is what diffuses opposition and enables itself to wrap around every aspect of our lives
Alliger 22 – (GEORGE M. ALLIGER has had over 60 articles published in journals such as Journal of Management, Journal of Applied Psychology, Personnel Psychology, Psychological Science, and Times Higher Education. He is an editor of The Handbook of Work Analysis. A fellow of the Society for Industrial/Organizational Psychology, Alliger is now a Consulting Psychologist in the Houston Area “Anti-Work: Phycological Investigations Into Its Truths, Problems, and Solutions” 2022) - MP
When we once begin to imagine the work organizations that we encounter on a daily basis as captors, it is not a far jump to conceive them as cults. Cults are known for exerting strong psychological control over their members, whose wills are submerged as a consequence. Might there then be serious similarities between work organizations and actual cults, such as that known as Jonestown? We should preface the immediately following thoughts with a general note on the nature of a “cult.” First, cults are everywhere, are for the most part benign, and are simply profoundly human expressions of admiration and/or religiosity. A cult can be holding a person or persons in such high regard that it can be almost be considered a devotion; this would be an informal cult, as in the “cult of Elvis.” It can be a more formal devotion, sometimes but not always religious, as in the “cult of St. Anthony,” the “cult of Krishna,” but also the “cult of Stalin” as it existed in the erstwhile Soviet Union. Often, however, we use “cult” in the sense of a group of adherents with specific leader(s) and beliefs, but with the additional wash or tint of danger and damage. The most unsafe cults, for example, try to separate members from society and family, requiring virtually total obedience. It is in this final sense that we look at cults and work; in the following, for the word “cult,” the phrase “dangerous cult” could be used without loss of the desired connotations. There are presumably a number of ways to think about work and cults in the sense we are using the word. Two briefly addressed below are (a) how does work figure within cults, and (b) are at least some traditional, mainstream organizations like cults, and if so, how? A cult begins with a single person or a small group of people who form the core of its identity. A desire to extend its beliefs, plus a concomitant desire of the founder(s) for power, leads the group to recruit others into the cult; these latter members are not part of the inner group, though they might possibly attain this with sufficient zeal and obedience. This inner/outer membership of course leads to competition among the out-members for the attention and approval of the inner circle. The promise of potentially advanced status, dependent upon loyalty and performance, is virtually universal and often overt. Many cults require members to accept as fact things that seem unlikely on the surface (e.g., deity of the founder, utter uniqueness of the group, availability of supernatural powers to the most advanced initiates). Specific beliefs can be quite unusual, such as salvation by UFOs, or personal possession by aliens. These kinds of ideas can be attractive to initiates, but they are fragile in the sense that they can appear absurd when exposed to mainstream thought. Hence the cult needs to control the information available to members, as well as occupying their minds and time. So members need to be controlled: isolated and kept busy. One way to keep them busy is work. The “O” (“The Organization”) was a Communist-inspired group that had its origins among the cooperative markets that sprung up in the 1970s in the Minneapolis–St. Paul region and was remarkably successful in being secretive. Constructed in cells, communication within it was so controlled that members might live on the same block without being aware of each other. Dictates often came in the form of memos, and some members never met the leader Theophilus Smith. Members worked at one of the group businesses (for example a bakery or a grocery), as well as at day jobs not associated with the group. Long and difficult work hours meant little sleep and living in a kind of continuous haze. Regardless of the site of work, communication regarding the group was prohibited. One member after ten years (and a memo-commanded marriage with another member) began to finally question her membership. One important growing doubt related to how it was that the revolution was being served by comrades all earning minimum wage at “O” businesses.3 In some cases, work in a cult serves a double purpose – not only keeping members busy and distracted, but to actually provide money to cult leaders. Traduzindo o Verbo in Brazil required followers first to donate all possessions, then to work in “slavery-like conditions” in businesses associated with the organization, wages going to group leaders. Interestingly, during a mammoth government raid in 2018, over 500 members were identified to be living in deplorable circumstances; none asked to be rescued by the government agents, so strong was their group identification (and perhaps fear of the outer world).4 Work, then, is often central to cults; it is one method of control. It not only keeps members busy and trains them in submission, but psychologically unifies them in a setting where they are pulling together in the same direction. Further, it can serve to create an usagainst-the-world identity. Work serves cults’ purposes of entraining and control. It can be risky for cults to allow their members to work in jobs outside the cult. The stories, which are legion, of members gradually becoming aware of, and painfully beginning to credit, the possible falseness of a cult’s beliefs often are centered on initial tentative forbidden communications with those within and without the organization. Sometimes these communications occur with nonmembers in a work environment “on the outside.” * * * It is one thing to understand how work is used by cults; it is much more difficult to see the typical organization as a cult. But, if we think of some of the dimensions that define cults, we can ask whether modern organizations share them. Let’s focus on just four common characteristics of cults: isolation, emotional abuse, control, and charismatic (and dogmatic) leadership. ISOLATION Cults often wish to cut members off from family and other social connections, since these “others” do not share the beliefs of the cult nor acknowledge its leader. The others are dangerous, threatening to absorb member time, energy, and resources due the group, and potentially actively countering the information the group is inculcating in its members. Business organizations typically only isolate via contracted demands on workers’ time, and this time is often communication-permeable, so that (for example) texting a friend or family member during work time may easily be possible. Still, the taking of time that might otherwise be available for family, friends, or other associations can greatly exceed what might be expected. If to the contracted-for hours we add time for commutes and preparation for and completion of work done during off-hours, whether in the office or at home, the sum can be quite large. So although workers are not “isolated” for the controlling reasons motivating cult leaders, a loss of communion may be a real effect of job demands. The “salaryman” who emerged in 20th-century Japan is one of the most famous figures symbolizing the work-bred isolation from family life. But no one could successfully mold themselves to Jack Ma’s vision of 996 (see Chapter 1) without limiting outside engagements typically considered normal. Enron, which some have argued had strong cultic qualities, hired mostly young people from whom it could demand massive amounts of work, perhaps up to 80 hours a week.5 If a person needs to hold two or even three jobs to make ends meet, no one of the organizations for which she works needs to be an isolator in themselves. The jobs cooperate, so to speak, to minimize free time and associations. EMOTIONAL ABUSE The cutoff on defining emotional abuse versus standard guidance on jobs and job performance provided to workers is perhaps a fine line. Micromanaging can drain all flavor of autonomy from a job, which is unpleasant but does not seem exactly emotionally abusive. If accompanied with sufficient condescension and/or actual bullying then the picture quickly changes. And, of course, micromanagement or no, requiring an employee to do something they do not think is morally right might be abusive if the employee does not feel free to refuse the order. One might even question whether “motivating” people to work harder might be abusive if it entails setting up a work climate that might be damaging in the long run. For example, some management researchers recommend that leaders try to attain a work atmosphere that can be characterized by the “optimal range of distress” – this can lead workers to be adaptive in how they approach their tasks: If the [distress] level is too low, people will be inclined to complacently maintain their current way of working, but if it is too high, people are likely to be overwhelmed and may start to panic or engage in severe forms of work avoidance, like scapegoating or assassination [that is, blaming lack of achievement on co-workers].6 Now, while distress here might simply conjure up a motivational tension between goals and performance and thus be considered to act purely via cognitive perceptions and judgments rather than emotions, if it can drive active undercutting of co-workers, then its emotional force must be admitted. Some researchers have examined bullying at work and found that while classic interpersonal bullying may be rare, organizational bullying is not. When asked, employees may say something like this: If your overtime’s cut because your manager’s got to make his [payroll] targets, they say, you know, 10 per cent reduction in overtime. So he’s telling you there’s no overtime but your customers are saying, ‘I need this and need it now.’ You’re then getting – effectively getting bullied in two directions.7 CONTROL As mentioned earlier, company-as-family is a current trope for organizations. It is also perhaps an increasingly prevalent one. As organizations seek to organize in ever flatter ways and to treat their employees to elaborate benefits in the workplace, as owners and the highest executives try to realize their desires to be liked, the family metaphor may prove irresistible to leaders. It is irresistible, perhaps, precisely because of the desire on the part of some owners and executives not only to be liked but to avoid the feeling that they are in any way taking advantage of their workers. The “we’re all in this together” atmosphere is a comfortable one, where power tends to be less visible. Teams prevail, collaboration is intense. So, from the owner/executive point of view, this seems ideal because productivity is high and bad feeling throughout the organization is minimized. In a case like this, the fact that I as CEO am getting a (perhaps much) higher salary than the average employee doesn’t bother so much, and justifying or ignoring that differential is easier. However, one of the dangers in nurturing this family metaphor is developing a cult-like atmosphere. Hard boundaries that perhaps allowed workers to keep their jobs compartmentalized from their emotional life are now fuzzy. Are they now, in addition to working well, supposed to like working? Are they under some obligation to like co-workers, even like the boss? It can be strongly argued that a clear-cut job situation, where one works under clear-cut, nonemotional rules and expectations is more easily handled than one that begins to subtly require family feelings and obligations. We discuss later how unions may provide this kind of non-emotional clarity. Of course, it is likely that in company-as-family bad feelings are being controlled and marginalized rather than actually minimized. Examples are common of modern companies squelching chatrooms and other venues for open employee comments on the state of the company. CHARISMATIC LEADERSHIP Cults don’t exist without leaders. In the business world, charismatic but narcissistic leaders may create an organizational “vision” that is touted as unique from all other such visions. They may use a carrotand-stick approach to developing employees that makes those employees feel part of a very special group indeed, while at the same time wary of expressing any dissent or disagreement for fear of running into the ever-threatening shoals of disapproval. The argument has been cogently made that the Enron débâcle was due in part to a cult-like empowerment of manipulative, charismatic leaders. As in many true cults, in this abusive and controlling environment common norms (such as those in accounting) were ignored or twisted, with eventual catastrophic effects.8 * * * Enron is one of those exceptions that prove the rule. In general, modern organizations do not make the cutoff for being considered cults. In some of these normal cases particular managers may create local emotionally abusive atmospheres. This is a problem, but does not justify any full-blown narrative of organizations as cults. It is true, though, that anti-work thinkers suggest that something dark and potentially damaging is going on in every organization. Most centrally, as we have seen, this relates to the required submission of the will and attendant depredations on the human spirit. But most organizations would not recognize themselves in this depiction; the organization’s sense of identity, as it were, is one of guiltlessness. This I would say is the ordinary state of affairs. This unexamined sense of organizational harmlessness and even virtuousness is met with some disbelief by anti-work thinkers. Lordon, for example, indicates his surprise at the extent to which organizational training videos are straightforward and devoid of any sense of awareness of a problem. They seem to reflect a “perfectly innocent good conscience, whose source is management’s own straightforward assent to what they do – unaware of any blatant affective instrumentalisation or mental manipulation, thus seeing no reason to dissimulate.”9 One unappreciated value of a workplace may be precisely its normality. People who have been indoctrinated into a cult sometimes experience dissonance between the cult’s statements on how dangerous and unenlightened life is outside the cult, on the one hand, and the general sensibleness that they encounter in their outside-the-cult working lives. Indeed, research has found that highly performing organizations, in contradistinction to cults, are more transparent, accountable, and feature much more dialog among employees.10 Some people may even find such a “normal” corporate atmosphere to be absolutely therapeutic. We can think of someone who comes from a home where she experiences belittlement, while at work she thrives in the respect of her co-workers.