Work is part of the system of neoliberal punishment and forces us to submit to the necropolitics of capitalism
Mumby ‘19
(Dennis K, Dennis K. Mumby is the Cary C. Boshamer Distinguished Professor of Communication at The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, USA, Work: What is it good for? (Absolutely nothing)—a critical theorist’s perspective, Industrial and Organizational Psychology, 30 October 2019, https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Dennis-Mumby/publication/338177026_Work_What_is_it_good_for_Absolutely_nothing-a_critical_theorist%27s_perspective/links/5e5bd8d892851cefa1d489bc/Work-What-is-it-good-for-Absolutely-nothing-a-critical-theorists-perspective.pdf)
For most of recorded human history, work was an activity in which only slaves, serfs, cloistered¶ monks, or prisoners engaged. It was, as De Botton indicates above, viewed largely as punishment¶ or penance. Work was performed out of necessity, or through coercion, but (almost) never as a matter¶ of choice and rarely with alacrity. Indeed, early industrial capitalism’s biggest (and most difficult) task¶ was to transform the human orientation to work rooted in the organic rhythms of the seasons to one¶ rooted in the temporal discipline of the factory regime. Andrew Ure (one of the earliest chroniclers of¶ the factory system in industrial capitalism) argued that Richard Arkwright’s “most noble achievement” was not the invention of a machine capable of mass-producing cotton but rather “training¶ human beings to renounce their desultory habits of work, and to identify themselves with the¶ unvarying regularity of the complex automaton. To devise and administer a successful code of factory¶ discipline, suited to the necessities of factory diligence” (Ure, 1835, p. 15).¶ If Richard Arkwright was, for all intents and purposes, the first manager of workers under¶ industrial capitalism (his first cotton mill was built in 1771 in Cromford, Derbyshire,¶ England), it is perhaps not too hyperbolic to argue that the entire history of management thought¶ since then has involved efforts to develop increasingly effective and sophisticated ways to train¶ humans to “denounce their desultory habits” and submit to the rhythms of work. From the¶ coercive practices of 19th century factories and the 20th century Fordist assembly line, through¶ the motivational efforts of the human relations school, to the identity management practices of¶ the corporate culture movement and beyond, management efforts have focused on reconciling¶ individuals with work. The success of this reconciliation effort is reflected in the degree to¶ which—today—the definition of a fulfilling life is closely tied to one’s work.¶ How, then, did we get to this point? How did we go from seeing work as a marginal, rather¶ distasteful activity not discussed in polite society to something intrinsic to our self-definition¶ as fully rounded human beings? I will address this question from the perspective of a critical¶ organizational communication scholar (more on that below) who has spent the last 35 years writing about how work organizations, communication processes, power, and capitalism intersect.¶ In the remainder of this focal article, I will do the following: (a) lay out what it means to examine¶ work and organizations from a critical communication perspective; (b) provide an overview of two¶ of the major theoretical and philosophical traditions that underpin this critical approach to work;¶ and (c) discuss some of the contemporary issues on which critical research focuses, particularly¶ those pertaining to the emergence of post-Fordist work under neoliberalism