The aff only upholds the workist notion of needing productivity and continues the neoliberal notion of the never-ending work for the purpose of work
Mumby ‘19
(Dennis K, Dennis K. Mumby is the Cary C. Boshamer Distinguished Professor of Communication at The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, USA, Work: What is it good for? (Absolutely nothing)—a critical theorist’s perspective, Industrial and Organizational Psychology, 30 October 2019, https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Dennis-Mumby/publication/338177026_Work_What_is_it_good_for_Absolutely_nothing-a_critical_theorist%27s_perspective/links/5e5bd8d892851cefa1d489bc/Work-What-is-it-good-for-Absolutely-nothing-a-critical-theorists-perspective.pdf)
Zuboff’s quote above rather pithily captures the argument I have been trying to make in this essay, framed through the lens of critical conceptions of work and organization. Work is the place where the rubber hits the road for capitalism, but in the course of the 20th and 21st centuries what counts as work—and thus its relationship to the capitalist accumulation process—has been transformed. For all of its problems, one of the principal virtues of Fordist capitalism and the Keynesian economic model that underwrote it was the creation of a system of social democracy that mitigated the worst excesses of capitalism. As I discuss above, Fordism and Keynesianism “cooked” capitalism by creating a WATT system of individual and collective autonomy within a social democratic welfare model. This included a social contract between workers and employers that enabled stable employment, relatively distinct spheres of work and life, and a high degree of individual and collective security through defined benefit plans, social security, and so forth. Neoliberal, post-Fordist capitalism put in place a YOYO system that invokes the market as a guide to all human activity, makes insecure, precarious employment the norm, and insists that we all view ourselves as individual, separate units of human capital, defined by our ability to create economic value. Everyone is expected to be “venture labor” (Neff, 2012), and any failure to add to the value of one’s human capital is framed as an individual shortcoming. In this sense, capitalism is, indeed, antisocial. As management scholar Peter Fleming has suggested, “Neoliberal capitalism wants you to be alone. Undocumented sociality is its enemy” (Fleming, 2019, p. 39) and, I would add, unprofitable. However, this sense of isolation and the attendant structural insecurity promoted by neoliberalism is accompanied by a contradictory injunction to love the work we do. Work “gurus” like Gary Vaynerchuk promote the idea that work should be a passion that consumes us, and if we’re not“killing it” while loving what we’re doing, it’s our own fault (Vaynerchuk 2008). Our students are continually told that they must find their passion (or better yet, monetize a passion that they already have), and if they do what they love, they will never work a day in their lives. Finding such a passion must be accompanied by an incessant self-branding process. If we are not working, then we must be working at working. Who needs a tyrannical manager telling us to work harder, when we have our own internal manager demanding more and more from ourselves? As Byung-Chul Han states, “The subject of today’s world is an entrepreneur of the self practising self-exploitation—and, by the same token, self-surveillance. The auto-exploiting subject carries around its own labour camp; here, it is perpetrator and victim at one and the same time” (2017, p. 61). In one of his most important works—written in the mid-20th century—economist and social theorist Joseph Schumpeter argued that, “The capitalist process, not by coincidence but by virtue of its mechanisms, progressively raises the standard of life of the masses” (2008, p. 68). An important mechanism within capitalism, he argued, was the process of “creative destruction” that resulted in mutations within capitalism. One such mutation occurred in the early 20th century with the shift from the “gilded age” of robber barons and mass inequalities between rich and poor, to a system characterized by employment security and fair labor practices (a product, in good part, of labor movement struggle). In the last 40 years we have experienced another period of creative destruction, but this mutation has reintroduced many of the inequalities of that earlier 20th century period, threatening to undermine Schumpeter’s claim that capitalism “progressively raises the standard of life of the masses.” Today, insecurity and precarity have again been normalized (even used as an explicit instrument of government), and capitalism has remade itself by expanding the possibilities for the creation of surplus value. The “social factory” has broken down the traditional barriers between work and life, as capitalism seeks to mediate (and hence monetize) every dimension of human experience, every form of sociality, including our friendships. In this latest neoliberal mutation, capitalism has systematically undermined the institutional forms that, over the course of the 20th century, were developed to protect us from its worst excesses. We are now, for all intents and purposes, eating capitalism raw.