Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Refusal of labor is key to solve cap—anything else terminally fails to dismantle the logic of private property—Marx agrees

Hardt and Negri 17 (Michael Hardt is a renowned intellectual and a former solar panel installer. Antonio Negri is an acclaimed critical theorist and a former Italian communist militant. “Assembly,” Oxford University Press. 2017 ) @ehatt

In capitalist society the possession of private property is legitimated (at least, in principle) by labor. If one were to follow the logic of capitalist ideology, then, contemporary forms of production should undermine private property. As labor and economic production are increasingly socialized, following this logic, the individual nature of ownership should gradually be undermined. The social nature of production should imply an equally social scope of the use of, access to, and decision-making over wealth. Capitalist legal structures do not follow this path, of course, but the transformations of labor create a constant tension and provide a resource for change, pointing toward the common. John Locke expresses the argument for the legitimation of property based on labor in its classic and perhaps clearest form: what was common becomes private when individuals add their labor to it: “The labour of his body, and the work of his hands, we may say, are properly his. Whatsoever then he removes out of the state that nature hath provided, and left it in, he hath mixed his labour with, and joined to it something that is his own, and thereby makes it his property.” One key precondition for this claim is that in the state of nature individuals encounter vacant lands (terra nullius---devoid of sovereignty) that are open for ownership. Locke regarded the Americas with a colonialist im- aginary, for instance, as being in such a state. The second assumption is that all (or, at least, all free male citizens) own their own bodies and, specifically, their own laboring capacity. Ownership of one’s own labor is the building block. When it engages with and mixes with the common, then the common too becomes property through a logic of contagion. Labor sets in motion expan- sive waves of possession and property. The logic of property based on labor undergoes a series of modifications and qualifications (already in subsequent passages of Locke’s treatise and then through the ensuing centuries of capital- ist thought), but it remains a basic element of capitalist common sense. If you build a house, then it should be yours. Consider, for example, how labor logic also continues to animate portions of property law: one is eligible to apply for patents when one invents or discovers a new and useful process, machine, manufacture, or composition of matter.'? Intellectual labor, at least in princi- ple or rather at the level of ideology, legitimates intellectual property. Despite the enduring capitalist ideology of individual property based on labor, capitalist property does not, of course, belong to those who produce it. Karl Marx was fond of remarking, especially in light of the propaganda that communism would take away what rightly belongs to people, that capital in its industrial form has already negated “individual private property, as founded on the labor of its proprietor.” Capitalist property accrues not to those who produce but to those who own the means of production. He takes seriously and adopts the equation between labor and property pro- moted by capitalist ideology, in other words, to show that capital undermines its own assumptions. We should note in passing that whereas one could imagine on the basis of this recognition seeking to establish, beyond the limits of capital, the real foundation of property in labor, Marx moves in the opposite direction: the abolition of private property requires also the refusal of work. “Labour” is the living basis of private property, it is private property as the creative source of itself. Private property is nothing but objectified labour. If it is desired to strike a mortal blow at private property, one must attack it not only as a material state of affairs, but also as activity, as labour. It is one of the greatest misapprehensions to speak of free, human, social labour, of labour without private property. “Labour” by its very nature is unfree, unhuman, unsocial activity, determined by private property and creating private property. Hence the abolition of private property will become a reality only when it is conceived as the abolition of “labour” (an abolition which, of course, has become possible only as a result of labour itself, that is to say, has become possible as a result of the material activity of society and which should on no account be conceived as the replacement of one category by another) The equation between private property and labor, in Marx’s vision, eftec- tively doubles the challenge: we must imagine and invent not only social bonds and social cohesion without property but also systems of cooperative social activity and creativity beyond work, that is, beyond the regime of waged labor. Today, however, the nature and conditions of labor have changed radically from the industrial forms that Marx analyzed and even more so from the agricultural and colonial imagination of Locke. In order to investigate con- temporary property relations we need first to look to today’s forms of social production and reproduction. For now let us mention only two primary as- pects. First, people work in ever more flexible, mobile, and precarious ar- rangements. Even Wall Street bankers have to be ready every day to clean out their desks by 5 p.m., but more important the vast majority work under the constant threat of unemployment and poverty. Second, labor is increasingly social and based on cooperation with others, embedded in a world of com- municative networks and digital connections, which run throughout indus- trial arrangements, agricultural systems, and all other economic forms. Capital is valorized through cooperative flows in which language, affects, code, and images are subsumed in the material processes of production. The fact that production in contemporary capitalist society is ever more cooperative and socialized strains to the breaking point the link between in- dividual labor and private property promoted by capitalist ideology. It no longer makes sense to isolate the one whose labor created some thing or, as patent law imagines, some idea. The one never produces. We only produce together, socially. Wealth continues to be produced by labor, in other words, in increasingly social networks of laboring cooperation, but the concept of private property based on labor becomes merely an ideological remnant---and the modern conceptions of property (along with, in part, Marx’s own) become obsolete. This rupture leads to two radically different developments. First, as prop- erty seems to be “freed” from any even ideological grounding in labor, the logic of private property becomes all the more absolute, a power of pure command. We will analyze in part III the ways in which finance and money have come to redefine property and how, in the era of neoliberalism, private property in its financial and monetary forms rules ever more completely over production and society as a whole. But even at such extreme points, capitalist property and value still carry the sign of labor like a birthmark. Jean-Marie Harribey, in his dialogue with André Orléan, is right to insist that even when value no longer appears in substantial, material form it is not merely a fantasy of accounting. It is the sign of a productive social network, mystified but effective, that is continually developed more intensively and extensively. Second, the ever more cooperative and socialized nature of production opens toward an understanding of the common. Rather than speaking of the social function of property, which seems to have flowed toward capital to the point of residing completely in finance, it would be better to speak of the social properties of labor. We are immersed in the common, cooperative circuits of production and reproduction that are both sustaining and chaotic. Try a thought experiment to follow the Lockean strain of capitalist ideology that bases property rights in production to its conclusion: if wealth today tends to be produced not by individuals but only in expansive cooperative social net- works, then the results should be the property of the productive network as a whole, the entire society, which is to say the property of no one; that is, prop- erty should become nonproperty and wealth must become common. We arrive at the same point--of the need today for a notion of right rooted in the common--if we go back and trace the developments of labor rights with respect to the state. It is sometimes difficult to remember today, when labor organizing is so brutally attacked in countries throughout the world, that in the twentieth century institutionalized labor movements, espe- cially in the dominant countries, played a central role in stabilizing the func- tioning of capital and the state. The first article of Italy’s 1948 Constitution declares, for example, “Italy is a democratic republic founded on labor.” Labor is “constitutionalized‚” and made into a pillar of support. The creation and constitution of welfare policies not only served to tame markets and over- come the exclusive normative power of private property and contracts but also sought to domesticate radical labor militancy. The welfare state aimed to treat the causes of crisis, both the objective (economic) and subjective (worker). Wages thus came to be supplemented by various “indirect” incomes provided by the welfare system, including pensions, healthcare, and various other social programs. State action, especially monetary action, had to maintain “effective demand,” and economic development depended significantly on the devel- opment of the needs of workers and citizens. From these threads of public actions and social services through the course of the twentieth century was knit a tightly woven biopolitical fabric. In recent decades, however, neoliberalism has violently attacked the social conditions of labor, reimposing the norms of the market and negating the notion that labor can have any autonomous right as the basis of the public regulation of economic development. Public law is thus ever more explicitly subordinated to private law, pulverized into thousands of subjective rights. And, similarly, all fiscal and social legislation is swept into the whirlpool of privatization, where instruments of progressive taxation are drowned; the sav- aging of public services becomes the rule, virtually prohibiting acts of solidar- ity among social groups; and the public functions of the state are subordinated to the market. The “rights of labor,” which in the welfare state were raised up to the dignity of “public rights,” with labor union bargaining supported and recognized by the state, are now degraded and translated once again into pri- vate and patrimonial law. In response to the depredations of neoliberalism, several European legal scholars have engaged in pragmatic efforts to tether private property to the public interest and public needs. Stefano Rodota and Ugo Mattei, for ex- ample, seek tirelessly, in different ways, to use the means provided by the Italian Constitution and the Italian legal tradition to protect natural resources (such as the national water supply) against privatization and to defend popular occupations that seek to prevent national heritage sites, such as Teatro Valle in Rome, being handed over to private interests. Their primary aim is not just to reassert the powers of public law for the benefit of social solidarity, afirm- ing the “social functions” and general interests of law, and thus posing a defi- nition of the “common” that is really a form of the “public.” Their aim is also to promote, from within private law, a proliferation of subjective, socially pro- tected rights, wresting them away from a strict definition of property rights and casting them instead in the direction of social interests. Stefano Rodota, for example, has spearheaded the promotion of the “right to have rights,” and Ugo Mattei has insisted on the other aspect of the crisis of private law, devel- oping the social functions of the private toward a conception of “common goods,” conceived as new categories of the “right to the common.” These pragmatic legal projects are especially urgent as a line of defense in the context of global neoliberalism with its general ideological celebration of the rule of private property and the erosion of the powers of states. But those same conditions transform the conceptual and practical possibilities of these strategies. As the powers of states fade, in other words, efforts to pluralize and socialize the rights of property must look beyond the public to other means of support. In fact, when left legal theorists appeal to the public and state power as the centerpiece of strategies to combat the excessive rule of private property--when Rodota, for example, speaks of “making the public public again‚” (ripubblicizzazione del pubblico)--this sounds to us, in contemporary conditions, neither feasible nor desirable. Such state responses are even more prevalent in France and Germany, where the “institutionalist” line is still pre- eminent and the promotion of the “rights of the common” is generally con- ceived as an expansion and deepening of public law. Unfortunately, this spuri- ous demand remains foundational for large segments of the socialist Left in Europe, whose imagination is fixed on state action and state power as the sole plausible defender of society. his may be an instance, however, in which capitalist elites (or, really, their collective unconscious) have a more lucid analysis than “progressive” theo- rists. Above we noted that as part of the neoliberal project the institutional- ized social rights and labor rights that supported capitalist rule throughout the twentieth century have been dramatically undermined. It is as if the cap- italist political class, in its paranoia, were to have mistaken these “reasonable” rights, which in the past have protected it against crises, for a much more threatening right, the right of the common. This is something like the moment after the failed 1848 revolution when the French bourgeoisie saw in the rather tame calls for a “social republic” the specter of communism and went running in the opposite direction to embrace the empire of Louis Bonaparte. Perhaps today’s capitalist elites--in their hysteria--also divine the truth. The extravagant, excessive violence of the privatization of the welfare state, despite the dangers of crisis it risks, betrays the fact that, beyond the claims to restore the hegemony of the market and the primacy of private law, it is fundamen- tally driven by the fear that social rights are a slope that inevitably leads to an affirmation of the common. That is the possibility that capital must destroy! In short, the social properties of labor, on one side, unmask the illegitimate rights of individual property, affirming the social, shared right to socially pro- duced wealth, and, on the other, they illicit the terror of propertied classes, financial elites, and neoliberal governments because behind the assertion of social rights they perceive (correctly) the emergence of a right of the common.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.