Work is the inherent contradiction its very roots are what makes us feel the never-ending alienation
Carmichael ’19 (Patrick Carmichael, Managing Director of Camtree: The Cambridge Teacher Research Exchange. Camtree is creating a global platform for educators who wish to reflect on their practice and conduct research to improve learning in their classrooms and institution, “Refusal of Work, Liberation of Time and the Convivial University”, Education and Technological Unemployment, 30 April 2019, https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-981-13-6225-5_17) //OC
In one of their early works, subsequently published as part of the Economic and¶ Philosophical Manuscripts of 1844, Marx and Engels write of the essential tension¶ facing the worker under capitalism:¶ The less you eat, drink and buy books; the less you go to the theatre, the dance hall, the public¶ house; the less you think, love, theorise, sing, paint, fence, etc., the more you save, the greater¶ becomes your treasure which neither moths nor rust will devour: your capital. The less you¶ are, the less you express your own life, the more you have, the greater is your alienated life,¶ the greater is the store of your estranged being. (Marx and Engels 1959: xv) This alienation can be overcome, and human self-realization and free activity¶ achieved only through the replacement of capitalist relations and specifically by¶ the ‘abolition of labour’. Labour, in the sense that Marx and Engels define it, is so¶ intrinsically bound up with capitalist mode of production, with the definition of the¶ proletariat, and what of it is to be a worker, that liberation must be ‘directed against¶ the hitherto existing mode of activity, does away with labour (die Arbeit beseitigt)¶ (Marx and Engels 1968: 80); elsewhere they argue that labour is already ‘free’ under¶ capitalism, and revolutionary struggle is not a matter of freeing labour but rather of¶ abolishing it (sie aufzuheben) (1968: 80). As Marcuse says, according to Marx, ‘liberation of the individual is at once the negation of labour’, and the aim is the creation¶ of a society ‘wherein the material process of production no longer determines the¶ entire pattern of human life’ (1999: 293–294). The abolition of labour for Marx is¶ not an encouragement to idleness, despite Lafargue’s spirited critique of demands¶ for the ‘right to work’ in his 1883 polemic The Right to be Lazy (Lafargue 1989).¶ Rather, it allows the development of new modes of productive activity which Marx¶ variously refers to as ‘free activity,’ (Selbsttiitigkeit) or ‘self-activity’ (Selbstbetiitigung), and, in later writings, ‘self-purpose’ (Selbstzweck) as distinguished from¶ ‘purposeful activity’ (zweckmäßige Tatigkeit) which is performed in order to achieve¶ a purpose outside itself (Zilbersheid 2004: 119–120).¶ A number of authors have attempted to trace the history of the concept of the¶ abolition of labour, most of whom identify some form of retreat from the idea, either¶ on the part of Marx himself or of subsequent leftist theorists. Probably the best known¶ of these is Marcuse’s (1999) Reason and Revolution; while Thoburn (2003) discusses¶ the associations between abolition of labour and the work of, amongst others, Negri,¶ Virno, Guattari, and Deleuze. Franco Berardi in his The Soul at Work: from alienation¶ to autonomy (2009) also offers a distinctive reading of Marx on alienation and the¶ political praxis that might be developed in response to it. Zilbersheid discusses what¶ he calls the ‘viscissitudes’ of the idea of the abolition of labour, and explores how,¶ despite its importance in visions of future communist society, it came to be neglected,¶ or even negated, both in leftist political programmes and theoretical analyses. He¶ writes of its central role:¶ At the core of the highest phase of communist society, as described in Marx’s early writings,¶ is the abolition of labour. The more famous abolition of private property, the well-known abolition of the state, and the lesser- known abolition of the division of labour are all conditional¶ upon the abolition of labour itself. (Zilbersheid 2004: 117)