Work is absolute submission – branded into us at an early age, it degrades and contradicts human nature
Alliger 22 – (GEORGE M. ALLIGER has had over 60 articles published in journals such as Journal of Management, Journal of Applied Psychology, Personnel Psychology, Psychological Science, and Times Higher Education. He is an editor of The Handbook of Work Analysis. A fellow of the Society for Industrial/Organizational Psychology, Alliger is now a Consulting Psychologist in the Houston Area “Anti-Work: Phycological Investigations Into Its Truths, Problems, and Solutions” 2022) - MP
The central anti-work concept of worker submission is critically examined from several angles. One of the most important tenets of anti-work relates to the human will.1 Work, it is argued, requires submission to an organization. That central fount and mark of our human being-in-the-world, volition, is put under pressure and distorted by employment. It is significant that the motto of the Haymarket demonstrators in 1886 was “Eight hours for work, eight hours for rest, eight hours for what we will.” That is, when working, whatever it is that we are doing, we are not doing our will – what we choose. And if we accept that what is willed, or negatively, submission, is at the center of how humans experience meaning, work can quickly be seen as problematic. Consider that work often requires a person to do that which they would not wish to do in free circumstances, and also do not wish to do in the circumstances of the job. This can be as apparently harmless as a directive to a hotel clerk or salesperson to smile at customers. Perhaps even most of the time, most employees would smile whether asked or not; but there are times they do not wish to smile. They are thus in those particular times placed in a quandary. If they do not smile, they may be reprimanded or even “let go” should they be perceived as excessively serious or cool toward customers on too many occasions. If on the other hand they accede to instruction and smile, they may feel that they are carrying out a kind of degrading emotional labor. And why in the world would this be degrading? Because, due to the complex net of authorities into which they are immediately placed upon employment, from the influences of their co-workers to the expectations of the customers to the raw power of the supervisor, they are now in effect forced to act against the choices they would make in a constraint-less situation. Of course, it can be argued that there are few if any fully constraintless situations, so that for example a person may at times feel a kind of requirement to smile at a partner or friend when they would rather not. However, that is a personal affair and a marriage or friendship is not – at least are not necessarily in its very nature – a systematic applier of force against human will. Employment is. Oddly, perhaps, it can be understood that workers have been prepared for this kind of submission from early life onward (thinkers like Frédéric Lordon, Pierre Bourdieu, and Daniel Markovits strenuously argue for this). My own grade school principal would remind us students each morning over the intercom (and the message was probably for faculty too) that it takes fewer muscles to smile than to frown. And then too “smile for the camera” is one of the earliest injunctions we encounter. Thereafter, we are exposed to all kinds of regulations and requirements at home and school. Perhaps most of these do not involve smiling per se, but many children will internalize what is presented as a basic rule of human functioning: “It is important to please.” But why is it important for children to please? Presumably because (a) one may seem more likeable to others when acting agreeable, so heading off or reducing tension; (b) it is easier for parents when children comply; and perhaps (c) it will be instrumentally useful to children as they grow and, eventually, enter the workplace. Succeeding may involve smiling. Of course, it cannot be true that smiling is always a good gambit in particular situations. It may well be that gravitas will serve better in many cases. But society, I think, does not inculcate this awareness as much as it usefully might. Smiling is a kind of limiting case on the soft end of things, and could be considered unimportant in the context of will, for how hard is it to smile, whatever you are feeling? But it is, after all, an example of “emotional labor.” Such labor has real psychological costs – there can be a kind of internal dissonance that is wearing, which over time can even lead to that constellation of negative symptoms that we call job burnout. This is true particularly if not offset by intrinsic job rewards, as in the case of those teachers who feel the need to “fake” enthusiasm in jobs that they do not particularly enjoy.2 We should not underestimate the bitter and humiliating nature of having to act, speak, and even appear in ways that do not conform to our own most natural motivations