Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Work as a metric of value is inherently exclusionary of disabled bodies

Charlotte E. Blattner, 20 Jul 2020, (“Right to work or refusal to work: Disability rights at a crossroads, Disability & Society”, https://doi.org/10.1080/09687599.2020.1788511)

Work is often framed as a site of economic, social, and political emancipation where dreams are realized, goals accomplished, characters framed, and skills perfected. But this promise has remained unfulfilled for disabled persons, who are still at high risk of being unemployed and poor. Nations and societies that center a citizen’s right to work often assign responsibility for this ‘failure’ to the individual, instead of acknowledging broader exclusionary social and political structures. The disability movement has advocated for civil rights for people with disabilities, among others by demanding more access to and inclusion at work for people with a disability, and for equal treatment at work. A central belief underlying this call for a ‘right to work’ is that work is a lynchpin of income, rights, and social belonging, that the workplace, if carefully redesigned, can be accessible to all, and that work and the status, rights, and experiences it offers are central to liberation (Graby 2015, 140). In practice, however, and even after decades of advocacy, persons with disability are largely excluded from and within work, are still viewed as ‘welfare dependents’ and continue to be stigmatized. The argument that meaningful work is the pathway to full participation in society has been complicated by clear indications that jobs will grow much scarcer in late-stage capitalism, as robots and AI increasingly replace human workers. A growing movement for a post-work world is suggesting alternatives to centering the right to work, both for the general public, and for people with disabilities. It is questioning our society’s obsession with measuring the status and worthiness of ‘others’ through their work, asserting this 2 C. E. BLATTNER marginalizes those who do not exemplify the work ethic, whether they choose not to work or because they have a disability. Post-work scholars and advocates have argued that the work ethic has colonized ‘our lives by eco nomic demands—to work, to recover from work, to spend income, to cultivate employability’ (Frayne 2015, 9) and left a dwindling segment of life free for fulfilling and nourishing activities outside work. Here, I search for a way to move the discussion forward by critically examining right to work arguments from the perspectives of disability rights law, labor law, and post-work scholarship. I offer an overview of the promises made by right to work advocates and their manifestations in the law (2.). Then I examine the arguments and narratives disability rights activists deploy when they advocate for the right to work, and the political means they use to attain that right (3.). Using recent data on lack of access and equal treatment of people with disabilities at work, I demonstrate why the right to work has failed to materialize for people with disabilities and why it might never materialize even if society fully adopts to the social model of disability. There is thus a risk that the right to work will never deliver material security, meaningfully contribute to identity-building and self-realization, or guarantee social inclusion, especially for people with disabilities (4.). Work as it is now conceptualized results in harms like line-drawing, work-based measures of worthiness, the insistence on personal responsibility over systemic analysis, colonization of lives through work, pressure to consume, and devaluation of alternative ways of living and being (5.). I conclude by (6.) drawing on both post-work scholarship and critical disability rights theory to describe the most urgent changes needed to make the right to work work. These include addressing issues of time, valuing alternative ways of being, building social, economic, and political scaffolds to make visible people’s experiences at and expectations of work, and exercising a refusal to work. Before proceeding accordingly, a note on the limits of this article is due. This article examines the intersection of work and disability from a broader, theoretical angle, drawing on multiple disciplines and sub-fields. It offers examples of the problems this raises for persons with disabilities and sug gests changes that might solve them, but does not draw on interviews or analyze a specific case (for a more strictly practical approach, see, e.g. Yakas 2017, on work, purpose, and community in clubhouses).

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.