Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The inevitability of work is a internalized falsity – you only believe that because you’ve been convinced of it your whole life

Alliger 22 – (GEORGE M. ALLIGER has had over 60 articles published in journals such as Journal of Management, Journal of Applied Psychology, Personnel Psychology, Psychological Science, and Times Higher Education. He is an editor of The Handbook of Work Analysis. A fellow of the Society for Industrial/Organizational Psychology, Alliger is now a Consulting Psychologist in the Houston Area “Anti-Work: Phycological Investigations Into Its Truths, Problems, and Solutions” 2022) - MP

Anti-work theorists may use analogical thinking when they discuss work and will in order to present the limiting case on the other, stronger, end of things. For example, consider enslavement or human trafficking. In these cases, there is no doubt that goals ordinarily sought by human will are crushed. One reason that activities like enslaving or trafficking humans are wrong is because the person’s will, her desires – that which she wishes or would wish in free circumstances – are actively being ignored and overridden. This, we say, is criminal. And in fact, in these cases there is always some agent or agents who are causing this ignoring and active domination of a person’s will. These agents, we say, are criminals. Then, by analogy: what of employers who order people about no matter what those employees wish to do? There are many examples of the deformation of will within the work environment which fall in between being asked to smile at customers and outright, total bondage. An advertising designer is asked to exaggerate about a product’s good points to the extent of actual lying; a salesperson is required to “upsell” (e.g., unneeded warranties) to customers despite her recognition that this is asking the customer to cough up more money at a time when they are somewhat vulnerable (the retailer possessing the dominant status of presumably being “expert” in the product, including whether a warranty is really needed); an accountant is asked to be devious, to depart from ordinary practice in order to include certain items in revenue or exclude some from expenses; a research analyst is told to look at her data again and come up with more favorable results; plant supervisors ask workers to avoid mentioning or even hide certain problems from safety inspectors … the examples can be endlessly elaborated. Collusion, lying, glossing over known problems, bribery, slander, cheating, providing an unneeded or deceptively inferior product; these and many more may be asked of an employee. In each case the internal psychic impulse of an employee may be to resist, but such resistance could create any number of job-related problems for the employee, from a general chilling of management attention to dismissal. And so employees may choose to capitulate, to be submissive in the face of wrong requests. We’ll just note here what we discuss in more detail elsewhere, that it is not as if the employer and employee are on equal footing. The employer can apply sanctions; the employee has none in her repertoire, unless it be the truly significant step of whistle-blowing. An employee is often easily replaced, but another job may be hard to come by for the employee. Thus the suppression of an individual worker’s will in the world of work can occur via management requirements for actions on the part of the worker which she finds undesirable. This is of course a corrupting phenomenon, both for manager and employee. At the same time, the pure anti-work position goes farther; it is not only being asked to do something that goes against one’s grain that is problematic. Workers are entering a state of submission simply by entering any business at all where they are not the boss. Now, as Lordon states, “It is ultimately quite strange that people should so ‘accept’ to occupy themselves in the service of a desire that was not originally their own.”3 This puzzle of acceptance or consent to domination is one Lordon meditates extensively on. Any given worker may say precisely that they fully accept their choice to be a worker: their will is in not in any way undermined or contravened. To this Lordon suggests: The individual-subject imagines itself to be a free being, endowed with an autonomous will, whose actions are the effects of its sovereign volition: hence, had I wanted emancipation strongly enough, I would have been able to escape my condition of servitude; consequently, if I am in this condition, it must be the fault of my will, and my servitude has to be voluntary.4 Thus, Lordon maintains, because you are working, you will believe that you have chosen to work and that therefore the work itself, or capitalism, or big business or whatever cannot be to blame. The psychologist Leon Festinger, long before Lordon, pointed out that post-decision justification such as the kind Lordon imagines does in fact often happen; he called it “cognitive dissonance.” This idea posits that “if a person knows various things that are not psychologically consistent with one another, he will, in a variety of ways, try to make them more consistent.”5 Finding yourself working and in a “condition of servitude,” on the one hand, and believing you are in control of what you do, on the other, should create a dissonance. You are choosing your own situation, but you have chosen a bad one. To resolve the tension, you argue to yourself that the situation is in fact not bad. So, do we, can we, willingly choose to work? The most natural answer seems to be “Of course.” However, the statement “I work because I will to work, and that’s that” may discount the many forces outside ourselves that cause us to work, forces that are much bigger than ourselves and the bucking of which may be near impossible. From one point of view, it can be said that we discover ourselves working. This does not seem so far-fetched, when the usual path of life is rehearsed: you start out early childhood by going to kindergarten and elementary school. It is unlikely that most of us would look inside ourselves and declare that this had been a choice of ours. It may even be difficult to argue that it was the choice of our parent, parents, or guardian(s): what else were they to do but send us to school when the time arrived? Then at some point we started working, maybe after attempting college, maybe before. Was this a personal choice in a way that going to grade school was not? Or were the skids set in place and greased, so to speak, so that working was the only natural thing to do? Now it may be true that we exercise free will in choosing among available jobs at which to work. This exercise of choice may then lead us to feel that we are also freely working in general. Or it may be that we actually do will to work; that such a choice is in concert or aligned with what society expects need not undermine the sovereignty of that choice. But anti-work would, at the least, see that as true of only a sliver of the population of workers.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.