Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The alternative is role-distancing through the lens of cynicism. This preserves the structures of state and employment, but liberates the spirit from the metaphorical prison forged by the concept of “work.”

Frayne ’15 [David, PhD, a sociologist taking a critical perspective on the future of work and welfare. “The Refusal of Work: The Theory and Practice of Resistance to Work”; 2015, Bloomsbury Academic; p. 222-223. https://sabrinasoyer.files.wordpress.com/2016/05/the-refusal-of-work.pdf; JFan]

What other escape routes are available to us? Perhaps one of the more common modes of escape is the one that Goffman called the practice of ‘role-distancing’ (Goffman, 1972). Role-distancing involves an attempt to demonstrate to others that we are dissatisfied and uncomfortable in our role. Goffman gives the example of an older child who clowns around on a merry-go-round, openly flouting the ride’s safety rules in order to show others that, whilst he might be riding the merry-go-round, he is doing so flippantly, having outgrown the childish role of ‘merry-go-round rider’. In the working world, role-distancing might take the form of similarly petty acts of noncompliance: slouching in a team meeting, doing paperwork sloppily or wearing a measured expression of incredulity (as perfected by Martin Freeman’s character Tim in the British version of The Office).

Drawing on their research into modern organisational cultures, Fleming and Spicer discuss the related strategy of cynicism (Fleming and Spicer, 2003). Cynicism is perhaps one of the more common escape strategies in the context of today’s emotionally demanding workplaces. When opportunities to genuinely change the system seem to be beyond us, cynicism represents a last-ditch attempt to create a free space in which we can feel less confined by work demands. As we saw back in Chapter 2, in relation to Catherine Casey’s study of Hephaestus, managerial attempts to engineer identification with work sometimes produce the opposite feeling in the worker (Casey, 1995). Workers try to preserve their individuality with a sense of disbelief, cynically dis-identifying with the work culture. A study by David Collinson records manual workers referring to the push to build a culture of excellence as ‘Yankee propaganda’. The company newsletter became known as the ‘Goebells Gazette’ (Collinson, 1992). These cultures of cynicism can undoubtedly act as important weapons in labour struggles, though they will only be effective if workers are also committed to the idea that an alternative is really possible. Fleming and Spicer argue that, by itself, cynicism can actually represent a very conservative force:

… cynical employees are given (and give themselves) the impression that they are autonomous agents, but they still practice the corporate rituals nevertheless. When we dis-identify with our prescribed social roles we often still perform them – sometimes better, ironically, than if we did identify with them. (Fleming and Spicer, 2003: 160, emphasis in original)

Cynicism is a form of rebellion that often leaves the foundations of power intact. Much like the ‘culture of fun’ management styles mentioned earlier in this book, cynicism can accommodate workers to their subordinate position by allowing them to enjoy a modicum of superficial freedom. Fleming and Spicer give the memorable example of a McDonald’s worker who dis-identifies with the company values (of teamwork, cleanliness, customer service and so on) by secretly wearing a ‘McShit’ T-shirt underneath her uniform. The authors argue that whilst her transgressive taste in fashion may allow her to preserve a sense of individuality, her dis-identification is ultimately superficial, so long as she continues to act as if she believes in the company values (Fleming and Spicer, 2003: 166)

Escape attempts in the form of role-distancing, cynicism and dis-identification provide a valuable breathing space in which we can feel less trammelled by work demands and more like ourselves, yet they also allow us to go on tolerating the confines of our roles: ‘The fact that we can regard with amusement the conventions of university or office life and our roles as teachers or managers, actually ensures that we remain within those conventions and these roles’ (Cohen and Taylor, 1992: 56). Like watching a profitable anticapitalist film at the weekend, wearing a Che Guevara T-shirt, or ‘liking’ a political page on Facebook, cynicism often represents what Mark Fisher calls a ‘gestural’ type of rebellion – an act of resistance that provides an illusion of empowerment, whilst ultimately leaving the world unchanged (Fisher, 2009).

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.