Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Our alternative is to exhaust debate. Instead of seeking to energize debate with political activism and participation, we should choose to exhaust that energy, which disrupts the neoliberal drive to constantly be productive.

Bifo 2011 (Franco Berardi, Professor of Social history of communication at the Accademia di belle Arit in Milan and Founder of A/traverse, After the Future, p. 135-139 https://files.libcom.org/files/AfterFuture.pdf)

Time is in the mind. The essential limit to growth is the mental impossibility to extend time (crybertime) beyond a certain point. I think that we are here touching upon a crucial point. The process of recomposition, of conscious and collective subjectivation, finds here a new—paradoxical—path. Modern radical thought has always seen subjectivation as an energetic process: mobilization, social desire and political activism, expression, participation have been the modes of conscious collective subjectivation in the age of the revolutions. But in our age, energy is running out and desire, which has given modern social dynamics their soul, is absorbed in the black hole of virtualization and financial games, as Jean Baudrillard argues in his 1976 book, Symbolic Exchange and Death. In this book, Baudrillard analyzes the hyperrealistic stage of capitalism, and the instauration of the logic of simulation. The end of the spectacle brings with it the collapse of reality into hyperrealism, the meticulous reduplication of the real, preferably through another reproductive medium such as advertising or photography. Through reproduction from one medium into another the real becomes volatile, it becomes the allegory of death, but it also draws strength from its own destruction, becoming the real for its own sake, a fetishism of the lost object which is no longer the object of representation, but the ecstasy of denegation and its own ritual extermination: the hyperreal. The reality principle corresponds to a certain stage of the law of value. Today the whole system is swamped by indeterminacy, and every reality is absorbed by the hyperreality of the code and simulation. The principle of simulation governs us now, rather that the outdated reality principle. We feed on those forms whose finalities have disappeared. No more ideology, only simulacra. We must therefore reconstruct the entire genealogy of the law of value and its simulacra in order to grasp the hegemony and the enchantment of the current system. A structural revolution of value. This genealogy must cover political economy, where it will appear as a second-order simulacrum, just like all those that stake everything on the real: the real of production, the real of signification, whether conscious or unconscious. Capital no longer belongs to the order of political economy: it operates with political economy as its simulated model. 'Ihe entire apparatus of the commodity law of value is absorbed and recycled in the larger apparatus of the structural law of value, this becoming part of the third order of simulacra. Political economy is thus assured a second life, an eternity, within the confines of an apparatus in which it has lost all its strict determinacy, but maintains an effective presence as a system of reference for simulation. (Baudrillard 1993a: 71-72, 2). Simulation is the new plane of consistency of capitalist growth: financial speculation, for instance, has displaced exploitation from the sphere of material production to the sphere of expectations, desire, and immaterial labor. The simulation process (cyberspace) is proliferating without limits, irradiating signs that go everywhere in the attention market. In semiocapitalist hyperreality, the brain is the market. And the brain is not limitless, the brain cannot expand and accelerate indefinitely. Collective subjectivation (i.e. social recomposition) implies the development of a common language-affection, which must happen in the temporal dimension. The semiocapitalist acceleration of time has destroyed the social possibility of sensitive elaboration of the semioflow The proliferation of simulacra in the infosphere has saturated the space of attention and imagination. Advertising and stimulated hyperexpression ("just do it"), have submitted the energies of the social psyche to permanent mobilization. Exhaustion follows, and exhaustion is the only escape: Nothing, not even the system, can avoid the symbolic obligation, and it is in this trap that the only chance of a catastrophe for capital remains. The system turns on itself, as a scorpion does when encircled by the challenge of death. For it is summoned to answer, if it is not to lose face, to what can only be death. The system must itself commit suicide in response to the multiplied challenge of death and suicide. So hostages are taken. On the symbolic or sacrificial plane, from which every moral consideration of the innocence of the victims is ruled out, the hostage is the substitute, the alter-ego of the terrorist—the hostage's death for the terrorist's. Hostage and terrorist may thereafter become confused in the same sacrificial act. (Baudrillard 1993a: 37). In these impressive pages, Baudrillard outlines the end of the modern dialectics of revolution against power, of the labor movement against capitalist domination, and predicts the advent of a new form of action that will be marked by the sacrificial gift of death (and self-annihilation). After the destruction of the World Trade Center in the most important terrorist act ever, Baudrillard wrote a short text titled 7yie Spirit of Terrorism, in which he goes back to his own predictions and recognizes the emergence of a catastrophic age. When the code becomes the enemy, the only strategy can be catastrophic: all the counterphobic ravings about exorcizing evil: it is because it is there, everywhere, like an obscure object of desire. Without this deep-seated complicity, the event would not have had the resonance it has, and in their symbolic strategy the terrorists doubtless know that they can count on this unavowable complicity. (Baudrillazd 2003, 6). This goes much further than hatred for the dominant global power by the disinherited and the exploited, those who fell on the wrong side of global order. this malignant desire is in the very heart of those who share this order's benefits. An allergy to all definitive order, to all definitive power is happily universal, and the two towers of the World Trade Center embodied perfectly, in their very double-ness (literally twin-ness), this definitive order: No need, then, for a death drive or a destructive instinct, or even for perverse, unintended effects. Very logically—and inexorably— the increase in the power of power heightens the will to destroy it. And it was party to its own destruction. When the two towers collapsed, you had the impression that they were responding to the suicide of the suicide-planes with their own suicides. It has been said that "Even God cannot declare war on Himself." Well, He can. The West, in position of God (divine omnipotence and absolute moral legitimary) has become suicidal, and declared war on itself. (Baudrillard 2003, 6-7). In Baudrillard's catastrophic vision I see a new way of thinking subjectivity: a reversal of the energetic subjectivation that animates the revolutionary theories of the twentieth century, and the opening of an implosive theory of subversion, based on depression and exhaustion. In the activist view, exhaustion is seen as the inability of the social body to escape the vicious destiny that capitalism has prepared: deactivation of the social energies that once upon a time animated democracy and political struggle. But exhaustion could also become the beginning of a slow movement toward a "wu wei" civilization, based on the withdrawal, and frugal expectations for life and consumption. Radicalism could abandon the mode of activism, and adopt the mode of passivity. A radical passivity would definitely threaten the ethos of relentless productivity that neoliberal politics has imposed. The mother of all the bubbles, the work bubble, would finally deflate. We have been working too much during the last three or four centuries, and outrageously too much during the last thirty years. The current depression could be the beginning of a massive abandonment of competition, consumerist drive, and dependence on work. Actually, if we think of the geopolitical struggle of the first decade of the twenty first century—the struggle between western domination and jihadist Islam—we recognize that the most powerful weapon has been suicide. September 11 was the most impressive act of this suicidal war, but thousands of people have killed themselves in order to destroy American military hegemony. And they've won, forcing the western world into the bunker of paranoid security, defeating the hypertechnological armies of the West both in Iraq, and in Afghanistan. The suicidal implosion has not been confined to the Islamists. Suicide has became a form of political action everywhere. Against neoliberal politics, Indian farmers have killed themselves. Against exploitation, hundreds of workers and employees have killed themselves in the French factories of Peugeot, and in the offices of France Telecom. In Italy, when the 2009 recession destroyed one million jobs, many workers, haunted by the fear of unemployment, climbed on the roofs of the factories, threatening to kill themselves. Is it possible to divert this implosive trend from the direction of death, murder, and suicide, toward a new kind of autonomy, social creativity and of life? I think that it is possible only if we start from exhaustion, if we emphasize the creative side of withdrawal. The exchange between life and money could be abandoned, and exhaustion could give way to a huge wave of withdrawal from the sphere of economic exchange. A new refrain could emerge in that moment and wipe out the law of economic growth. The self-organization of the general intellect could abandon the law of accumulation and growth, and start a new concatenation, where collective intelligence is only subjected to the common good.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.