Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The social brain of debate is overwhelmed with work – the imperative to labor in our thought is a virus that latches onto the field of desire and breaks down our sense of social reality –the pathos of productivity suppresses the cognitive dissonance of debate’s frantic need to do something – refuse the teleological speed of cognitive capitalism

Smith 9 (Jason, preface to Bifo’s The Soul at Work: From Alienation to Autonomy, [CL])

The soul is the clinamen of the body. It is how it falls, and what makes it fall in with other bodies. The soul is its gravity. This tendency for certain bodies to fall in with others is what constitutes a world. The materialist tradition represented by Epicurus and Lucretius proposed a worldless time in which bodies rain down through the plumbless void, straight down and side-by-side, until a sudden, unpredictable deviation or swerve-clinamen-leans bodies toward one another, so that they come together in a lasting way The soul does not lie beneath the skin. It is the angle of this swerve and what then holds these bodies together. It spaces bodies, rather than hiding within them; it is among them, their consistency the affinity they have for one another. It is what they share in common: neither a form, nor some thing, but a rhythm, a certain way of vibrating, a resonance. Frequency, tuning or tone. To speak of a soul at work is to move the center of gravity in contemporary debates about cognitive capitalism. The soul is not simply the capacity for abstraction, for the subsumption of the particular. It is an aesthetic organ as well, the exposure of thought to the contractions and dilations of space, to the quickening and lapsing of time. To say the soul is put to work is to affirm that the social brain or general intellect (to use two of Marx's, phrases that have some currency in these debates) is not the primary source of value in the production process. Rather the soul as a web of attachments and tastes, attractions and* inclinations. The soul is not simply the seat of intellectual operations, but the affective and libidinal forces that weave together a world: attentiveness, the ability to address, care for and appeal to others. The contemporary subject of cognitive capitalism-Bifo speaks of the cognitariat, but perhaps there are other names-is not simply a producer of knowledge and a manager of symbols. Capitalism is the mobilization of a pathos and the organization of a mood; its subject, a field of desire, a point of inflexion for an impersonal affect that circulates like a rumor. The cognitariat carries a virus. The Soul at Work calls itself an experiment in "psychopathology," and it describes how something in the collective soul has seized up. The world has become heavy, thick, opaque, intransigent. A little, dark light shines through, though. Something opens up with this extinction of the possible. We no longer feel compelled to act, that is, to be effective. Our passivity almost seems like a release, a refusal, a de-activation of a system of possibles that are not ours. The possible is seen for what it is: an imposition, smothering with the eclipse of the possible, at the point zero of depressive lapse, we are at times seized by our own potentiality: a potency that, no longer invested in vectors of realization, washes back over us. Depression occurs, Franco "Bifo" Berardi argues, when the speed and complexity of the flows of information overwhelm the capacities of the "social brain" to manage these flows, inducing a panic that concludes, shortly thereafter, with a depressive plunge. Depression is so widespread today, Bifo argues, because the contemporary organization of production of surplus-value is founded on the phenomenon-the accumulation-of speed. In well-known pages from the Grundrisse, Marx spoke of a tendency, a limit point in the process of the valorization of capital: the impossible possibility that capital might circulate "without circulation time," at an infinite velocity, such that the passage from one moment in the circulation of capital to the next would take place at the "speed of thought." Such a capital would return to itself even before taking leave of itself passing through all of its phases in a process encountering no obstacles, in an ideal time without time-in the blinding flash of an instant without duration, a cycle contracting into a point. No less an authority than Bill Gates restages this fantasy-a limit point of capital, toward which it strains, its vanishing point-in his Business @ the Speed of Thought, cited by Bifo as a contemporary formalization of this threshold, summoning the possibility of the circulation of information that would, Gates fantasizes, occur as "quickly and naturally as thought in a human being." There is speed and there is speed. It is not simply the phenomenon of speed as such that plays the pathogenic role here. The social factory is just as much governed by the destabilizing experience of changes in rhythms, differences in speeds, whiplash-like reorientations imposed on a workforce that is flexible, precarious and permanently on-call-and equipped with the latest iPhone. This organization of work, in which just-in-time production is overseen by a permanently temporary labor force, is mirrored in the form of governance characteristic of democratic imperialism, sustained as it is by appeals to urgency, permanent mobilization, suspensions of norms: governance by crisis, rule by exception. It is impossible to separate the spheres of the economy and the political these days. In each case, a managed disorder, the administration of chaos. The social pacts and productive truces of the old welfare states are gone. Instability is now the order of the day. Disorder, a technique of government. Depression starts to look less like a drying up of desire than a stubborn, if painful, libidinal slowdown or sabotage, a demobilization. The soul on strike. The Soul at Work wants to answer this question: How did we get from the particular forms of workers' struggle in the 1960s, characterized by widespread "estrangement" of workers from the capitalist organization of production, to the situation today, in which work has become the central locus of psychic and emotional investment, even as this new libidinal economy induces an entire range of collective pathologies, from disorders of attention to new forms of dyslexia, from sudden panics to mass depression? How, in other words, have we passed from the social antagonisms of the 1960s and 1970s, when worker power was paradoxically defined by a refusal of work, its autonomy from the capitalist valorization process, and its own forms of organization-its defection from factory discipline-to the experience of the last two decades, where work has become the core of our identity, no longer economically necessary, yet vital to the constitution of the self? In short, from fleeing work to identifying with it? Something happened in 1977. Bifo hangs his story on this mutation. Its the year when refusal of work reaches a fever pitch in the Italian autonomia movement, the year that the logic of antagonism and worker needs-what Mario Tronti called the "antagonistic will" of the proletariat-gives way to a logic of desire, in which social productivity can no longer be accounted for in strictly economic categories, and in which the insurrectionary vectors no longer map onto the old imaginary of social war. The centrality of the category of worker needs in the struggles of the 1960s primarily took two forms. In the sphere of consumption, there was the form of direct democracy known as "political" pricing, in which neighborhoods and entire sections of cities unilaterally reduced the costs of goods and services such as housing, transportation and electricity, on the basis of a collective decision that refused any economic rationality in the determination of prices. At the point of production, the primary lever of antagonism was the wage struggle, in which worker power was exercised in a refusal to link wage levels to productivity, insisting the wage be treated as an "independent variable." The mutation represented by the events of 1977, in which the logic of needs and antagonism gives way to desire and flight, is where The Soul at Work really begins. For what is at stake in its story is the aftermath of this mass defection from factory discipline, this unilateral withdrawal from the social pact drawn up by capital and its partners, the unions and the worker parties, in view of "saving" the Italian economy after the war. It asks: how has the sphere of desire, the field of the imaginary and the affective, whose affirmation as the fundamental field of the political once led to a collective abandonment of the sphere of work, been transformed into the privileged force in the contemporary order of work, the privileged moment in the production of value? Desire braids together emotional, linguistic, cognitive and imaginary energies that affirmed themselves against the regime of work in the 1960s and 1970s, a refusal that is then paradoxically put to work by capital itself. This colonization of the soul and its desire-the entry of the soul itself into the production process- spawns paradoxical effects. It transforms labor-power into what managerial theories call human capital, harnessing and putting to work not an abstract, general force of labor, but the particularity, the unique combination of psychic, cognitive and affective powers I bring to the labor process. Because this contemporary reformatting functions through the incitement of my specific creative and intellectual powers, I experience work as the segment of social life in which I am most free, most capable of realizing my desires: most myself

Robinson 12 (Andrew, political theorist and activist based in the UK, “Jean Baudrillard: Critique of Alienation – Draft 1,” April 14th, 2012,

, DS)

Baudrillard uses the word ambience for capitalism’s control of society through its incorporation into consumption. It produces a kind of diffuse, mobile experience of life. The lack of situatedness is partly compensated by the role of objects. In consumer society, we are surrounded by objects – often objects split from their place and function. We become object-like from living among objects, much as wolf-children become wolf-like. The code is substituted for the referential dimension of language. People are caught in a world much of which is merely an internal, technical product of the code. The system destroys direct personal ties and social relations. It then systematically creates simulated relations which can be consumed, instead of those it has destroyed. It also eliminates the singular, radically different content of each person, putting in its place differential signs. And it eliminates real conflict, putting abstract competition in its place. Everyday life is constructed through a split between the everyday and the abstract or transcendent sphere of the social, political, historical or cultural. The closure of the everyday sphere, the exclusion from history, is tolerable only because it is accompanied by alibis or simulations of participation. The exclusion from history is also given value, because it is identified with security – in contrast to the scary historical events shown on TV. Alienation impacts especially on how we relate to our bodies. The body in capitalism is both capital and fetish, object of investment and consumption. Its many uses include fashion, adverts, mass culture, discourses of hygiene, diet and therapy, cults of youth and femininity, and sacrificial practices such as slimming. It is exploited in a managed narcissism, perfected externally so as to exploit it to produce socially valued signs – to appear as happy, healthy, young, spontaneous, beautiful and so on. The various uses of the body are replaced by a single signifying function. Appearances such as fitness are deemed near-necessities in environments such as management. They express hostility to the body, seen as a menacing object which needs to be watched over by the self. The body is turned into a package, like clothes, and consumed like an object. One’s relationship to it thus becomes neurotic and repressive. The body is socially encoded so as to meet normative demands to produce and consume. This is even more alienating than the use of the body as source of labour-power. It is only after the body is reinvested in this way that the demand for objects as signs occurs. People will only pursue objects as signs once their body is seen as an object. Similarly, sexuality is turned into an instrumental code of signs instead of individual desires. Especially in downturn periods, sexuality becomes frenetic but anxious. The profound contradictions of sexual problems and desires are covered-up. External censorship is replaced with an internalised censorship prohibiting liberation. A private, narcissistic, personalised sexuality protects the status quo from the effects of sexual liberation. Sex is everywhere but in the sex-act itself. It is overwhelmed by signs. There is also a new kind of imaginary “subject” or self generated by consumerism. Consumer society portrays all its objects for sale as carefully formulated for an impersonal “you” to whom they are addressed. It is a kind of myth which presents consumption as common sense, consuming the spectacle of consumption itself. Without the myth of consumption, it would not exist as an integrative social function. It would simply be a set of differentiated needs and desires. The word ‘consumption’ actually expresses a restructuring of social ideology. It is not in fact a victory of objects, or of earthly pleasures. Rather, it is a set of reified social and productive relations and forces. In this world, revolutions are replaced by fashion cycles. Even the retraining of workers is little more than a fashion cycle. It’s a way of imposing “low-intensity” constraints and a threat of exclusion so as to ensure conformity. Baudrillard is highly critical of the view that consumerism amounts to liberation. It is true that certain older regimes of authoritarianism have decayed. But the new regime is also a system of control. Repression persists, but it moves sideways. The image of a sterile, hygienic body and fear of contamination establishes an inner control which removes desire from the body. The ranking of bodies in terms of status leads to a re-racialisation. Puritanism becomes mixed-up with hedonism in this ranking process. The body as locus of desire remains censored and silenced, even when it appears to undergo hedonistic release. Sexuality is expressed in consumption so it can’t disrupt the status quo. What is now censored is the symbolic structure and the possibility of deep meaning. Living representations are turned into empty signs. Because of this change, the old resistances to repression no longer work. Similarly, groups supposedly liberated – such as women, black people, and young people – are denied the effects of liberation by being re-encoded in terms of myths. Once labelled as irresponsible, people’s liberation is attached to a coded meaning which demands and bars responsibility and social power. Real liberation is avoided by giving people an image of themselves to consume – women are given the image of Woman, the young an image of Youth, technological change by Technology (gadgets), and so on. Liberation is thus nullified, and re-encoded as a role and as narcissism. Concrete gains for liberation movements are side-effects of this immense strategic operation to disempower oppressed groups through their reduction to a function or role. We are drip-fed little bits of democracy and progress to ensure the system’s survival. They operate as its alibis. Even if income equality is encouraged, the system can survive by moving inequality elsewhere, to status, style, power and so on.

‘

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.