Work is the base of a responsible society – the unemployed are more likely to engage in unrest and riots
Chamberlin 13 (Dr. James Chamberlain is an Associate Professor of Political Science, specializing in political theory, “The Unstable Meaning and Value of Work: An Exploration of the Refusal of Work through the 2011 UK Riots and Public Sector Strikes,” APSA 2013 Annual Meeting Paper American Political Science Association, 8/22/2013, https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2300892) -MP
Although these responses display a reticence to understanding the causes of the riots in general, or seeing them as political protests more specifically, politicians, media commentators, and other researchers nonetheless developed various explanations of the disturbances, the most interesting of which for our purposes will be what I call the embrace of work as a panacea for personal and social ills. The riots thus set the stage for a flurry of discursive production around the importance of employment to individuals and their communities, which in turn functioned to shore up the ideology of work. One fairly simple connection between (un)employment and the riots, given the widespread occurrence of looting, concerns the ability of people to acquire the things that they need or want. For example, the National Centre for Social Research (NatCen) report quotes one person who thought that fewer young people would resort to a life of street crime if there were more employment opportunities available to them. According to this view, unemployment and poor job prospects stimulate criminal behavior like looting, because it offers a way to “get what you really want.”13 It is worth noting, however, that the opportunity to acquire material goods was not the only motivation of rioters, since many also engaged in confrontations with the police and the destruction of property. The final report of the Riots Communities and Victims Panel (RCVP) offers a more complex, if not more ambiguous, statement of the relationship between work and the riots. 14 Here we learn that “neighbourhoods that suffered from riots are more pessimistic about their local areas and the opportunities for local people than those areas that did not suffer from riots.”15 The report identifies rising unemployment as a particular source of stress, and goes on to claim that “if we are to avoid further riots, we have a responsibility to ensure young people receive an education which stimulates and inspires them, and prepares them for future work.”16 The panel found that “hopes and dreams” were low among young people, and recommends a series of measures to reduce youth unemployment as part of the broader goal of building “social and economic resilience.”17 These measures would reduce the number of “young people falling through the net and ending up NEET [not in education, employment, or training] and at risk of rioting.”18 While the report finds a strong correlation between coming from a deprived neighborhood, ‘being NEET’ and taking part in the riots, 19 it appears less confident about making causal claims. Almost in passing, the panel claims that “having a job is key to people feeling that they have a stake in society,”20 and that when people have a stake in society there is a lower likelihood of unrest and disorder. 21 This conclusion also coincides with NatCen’s finding that “poor job prospects” and long-term unemployment meant that some young people felt they had little to lose by taking part in the riots.22 The implication is that employment incentivizes moral and law-abiding behavior, a virtue whose popular appeal cannot be overestimated in the climate of fears about the ‘breakdown of morality’ and ‘law and order.’ Although he does not explicitly refer to jobs, Nick Clegg (the Deputy Prime Minister and Leader of the Liberal Democrats), expressed a similar view when he told party members just days after the riots (and months before the publication of the panel’s final report) that “the best defence against this kind of nihilistic behaviour is to ensure that everyone has a stake in society.”23 For this to happen, according to Mr. Clegg, people must have “opportunities” (presumably related to education and employment), which in turn “gives them the drive, discipline and responsibility to do the right thing.” Within days of this speech, David Cameron echoed its sentiment when he suggested that “work is at the heart of a responsible society. So getting more of our young people into jobs, or up and running in their own businesses is a critical part of how we strengthen responsibility in our society. …it’s only by getting our young people into work that we can build an ownership society in which everyone feels they have a stake.”24 Although the RCVP identifies other factors besides unemployment to explain the disturbances, it is striking that their findings in this area so neatly match the pronouncements made within days of the riots by the very same politicians who set up the panel. Perhaps unsurprisingly, the report has drawn criticism for being “a superficial glossy brochure” that “tells us nothing new about the riots.”25 The notion that unemployment can account, at least in part, for the outbreak of urban unrest has thus received support from government commissioned inquiries as well as politicians of liberal and conservative persuasions, but one can find a broadly complementary narrative on employment and social inclusion in academic work too. Geographer Tom Slater, for example, argues that we must connect the riots “to urban marginality in British society and pay attention not only to material deprivation but to the denial of dignity it implies”26 Both politicians and state institutions have essentially failed young people, according to Slater, leaving them in poverty and unemployment. The riots, then, were a “response that should have been expected” to what Loic Wacquant has called the “massive structural violence” visited upon urban youth. 27 In an interview with The Guardian, Simon Hallsworth, director of the Centre for Social and Evaluation Research at London Metropolitan University, complements this analysis by criticizing the shift away from a commitment to full employment and toward labor market flexibility. In his view this has excluded young people from the jobs that would allow them to buy consumer items, like clothes and phones, which are so central to social respect in contemporary society. 28 As Slater goes on to note, the denial of dignity to young people has fuelled “collective rage” in France and Greece, to name just two recent examples. The coalition government’s swingeing budget cuts in the climate of austerity have heightened the British youth’s sense of being “abandoned and betrayed,” while many who took part in the riots must daily endure the dishonor of living in a stigmatized neighborhood, with all the social and economic costs that this imposes on them. 29 Similarly, youth charity founder Camila Batmanghelidjh draws attention to the “repeated humiliation” that disadvantaged young people experience in London, and suggests that, while we are all capable of “savagery,” “some of us have been lucky enough not to have to call upon it for survival; others, exhausted from failure, can justify resorting to it.”30 While this account of the rioters’ behavior expresses empathy and understanding for their plight, its invocation of ‘savagery’ conjures up the threatening figure of an undomesticated and unruly beast, an image to which we will return shortly. These various reports, speeches, and articles express the belief that unemployment creates a sense of marginality, hopelessness, and indignity that will almost inevitably produce violent disturbances among young people. Yet a common theme in these texts concerns the fact that not everyone in challenging socio-economic circumstances took part in the riots. In the speech quoted above, Nick Clegg, for example, stressed that the “rioters were the exception, not the rule,”31 while the RCVP undertook to discern why some young people engaged in the disturbances while others shied away. In its final report, we learn that ‘character’ is a key factor both in determining whether or not young people took part in the riots, and in shaping their employment prospects. These explanations qualify the almost deterministic accounts of the riots that focus on socio-structural factors by introducing the theme of agency. While this move is to be welcomed by those seeking rigorous empirical understanding of the riots, it is worth noting that it also helps legitimize the status quo by pointing to those who, despite adversity, did not feel compelled to ‘act out.’ According to the panel, young people with ‘character’ display “self-discipline, application, the ability to defer gratification and resilience in recovering from setbacks.”32 Although the panel notes that “it is difficult to gather quantitative evidence on whether a lack of character in the rioters led to their criminal actions,” it claims that “rioters chose not to resist the temptations and excitement that the riots offered them while many of their peers, experiencing similar disadvantage, made a positive choice not to go on to the streets and damage their communities” (emphases added). The logical inconsistency of the assertion that the rioters effectively chose to take part in the disturbances with the claim that a lack of selfdiscipline and the ability to defer gratification were at the root of their involvement deserves closer scrutiny. If one lacks self-discipline, how could one choose to resist temptation? The panel’s insistence on the ‘choice’ of the rioters, even as it defies logic, supports Nikolas Rose’s claim that contemporary liberal society governs “autonomous individuals through their freedom,” where freedom includes determining “the course of one’s own existence through acts of choice.”33 While the panel isolates the moment of ‘choice’ on the part of the rioters, thus holding them accountable for their actions, by contrasting it with the “positive choice” of those in similar circumstances who did not take part in the riots, it implies that the rioters’ choice was ‘flawed.’ Of course, this choice was ‘negative’ in terms of its impact on those whose property was stolen or destroyed, but I use the word ‘flawed’ to convey the sense that, from the panel’s perspective, the rioters’ lack of self-discipline tarnished the process by which they made that choice. Moreover, given that liberal subjects operate within in a “space of action” which leaves them free to choose among a range of options, Rose shows how “well-regulated liberty” in the nineteenth century required the cultivation of “normality, rationality and sensibility.” As Rose puts it, “these practices governed through liberty, to the extent they sought to invent the conditions in which subjects themselves would shape their conduct.”34 He goes on to note that riots were a particular concern in the nineteenth century, because they were “not the exercise of freedom but its antithesis: the greatest challenge to a public order of liberty.”35 These same concerns are highly visible within the responses to the 2011 riots: those who took part in them were presumed devoid of self-discipline and, we will see below, rationality, and thus fell short of the standards of conduct befitting a liberal subject. In this sense, the rioters provoked such anxiety precisely because they posed a threat to “well-regulated liberty.”