Planned failure is the perfection of anti-instrumentality which forgoes practical commitments to collective continuance – turns case.
Levine, 21 – David and Kathleen Ryan Professor of Humanities at Cornell University. (Caroline Levine, "The Long Lure of Anti-Instrumentality: Politics, Aesthetics, and Sustainability", Modern Fiction Studies, Volume 67, Number 2, Summer 2021, pg. 225-246, DOI: 10.1353/mfs.2021.0010, ILake-MO)
I argue here that it is particularly urgent for the Left to reconsider our longstanding attachment to anti-instrumentality at this moment of rapid and destabilizing climate change. Ecocritics have argued especially strenuously against all instrumentalizing programs, insisting that any teleological thinking is in cahoots with capitalism and colonialism, and only re-entrenches the destructive ideologies that caused the climate crisis in the first place. Refusing to coerce others into exploitative use or service, they take a principled stand in favor of passivity and deliberate political withdrawal. Anne-Lise François, for example, turns toward “recessive action” (xvii)—the “nonappropriative” (xxiv), minor gesture that rejects any illusion of human mastery or conquest. And Anahid Nersessian argues, “For better or worse, works of art resist practical application or problem-solving” (2), which means that the task of the aesthetic disciplines is to face the “traumatic knowledge that climate catastrophe is certain and unfathomable.”
There is something attractively pure about refusing all complicity with capitalism and colonialism. But there is also a strange logic to the argument that any attempt to slow or stop global warming would be so much in keeping with instrumental reason that we have no choice but to surrender to the climate catastrophe to come. Can it be true that our only ethical option is to accede to our own extinction—not to mention the extinction of many human and nonhuman others in the process? Or, to put this another way, acquiescing to forces of massive, global destruction that will intensify the suffering of the world’s poorest is not a recognizably leftist position, if by the Left we mean a political commitment to collective, egalitarian flourishing.
Thus, it is my central argument here that our own historical moment demands a reconsideration of aesthetic and political anti-instrumentality on the Left. As neoliberal economics undoes hopes of secure work and as fossil fuels radically disrupt longstanding ecosystems, the most urgent threat facing people around the world is not oppressive stasis but radical instability—intensifying poverty and food insecurity, flooding, forest fires, violent conflicts over water, and the rapid extinction of species. In literary studies, we have been so focused on refusing to serve ends that we have not often developed resources for working for reliable food, for example, or safe and stable shelter. With the rapid onrush of climate catastrophes, these basic conditions are increasingly under threat for the world’s poor. Open-endedness is not primarily a source of pleasure and excitement for those who are anxious about finding their next meal or a safe place to sleep. I claim that justice demands a focus on the mundane work of sustaining living bodies over time, which requires adequate nutrition, breathable air, clean water, and stable shelter. Anti-instrumentality turns our attention away from solving these problems to focus instead on withdrawal, inaction, and mourning. The usual logic of literary studies is, in short, a logic of antisustainability. So, what is the alternative? I propose an affirmative instrumentality in literary studies. While humanists have been fully justified in resisting pressures to put bodies and ideas to work in the service of violent and inequitable systems, I do not believe that it follows that we should avoid all ends. Not only has this insistence lent itself to an indiscriminate politics of undoing, but it has also left the tasks of designing and building social life to the social and natural sciences, government, and business. As long as literary studies imagines its role as refusing and negating all practical plans and projects, it will continue to yield the power to shape the world to other disciplines. What if, instead, we saw it as the central political task of literary studies to figure out how to sustain collective life over time with some degree of justice and mutual care?
To be sure, a number of scholars, including Leerom Medovoi and Timothy Morton, have roundly critiqued the term sustainability. As often embraced by businesses and environmental activists, sustainability implies the continuation of life as we know it, which for many in the business world includes expectations of ongoing economic growth, competition, and accumulation. It is certainly true that if we work to sustain current systems—including global markets and extractive industries—we become complicit with the most rapacious forces on earth. And yet, our dominant systems are in fact dramatically unsustainable. The current pace of extraction and emission is making the planet uninhabitable for humans and vast numbers of other species.
From this perspective, sustainability is in fact a neutral term. It refers to the capacity to keep any state of affairs going over time. It can include both just and unjust conditions. What climate change has made suddenly clear is that sustaining must be a goal on the Left as well as the Right. We are now faced with a struggle to keep collective life going at all. A more appropriate focus than rupture and openendedness, then, would be the goal of a genuine sustainability—the vast and urgent project of sustaining collective life over generations.
A revaluing of sustainability will mean a turn to the ordinary work of maintenance, a celebration of the work that keeps life going every day. I draw inspiration here from feminist thinkers such as Mierle Laderman Ukeles, Luce Giard, bell hooks, and Susan Fraiman, who have argued for decades that the artistic emphasis on negations and revolutionary ruptures have meant too little respect for the tasks and values that are crucial to keeping bodies alive, including maintenance and caretaking. And it is true that Leftists and artists have often ignored or devalued certain necessary labor, such as the reproduction and maintenance of daily survival, which is so often women’s work—from literal reproduction to the ongoing care of bodies through the preparation of food, care for the sick, and the daily upkeep of environments. This kind of labor is not necessarily creative, heroic, or radically emancipatory. It is practical and repetitive. It has to happen in many of the same ways every day. But no human sociality has ever taken shape without it.