Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The aff is the first step in reorganizing the social system by granting people opportunities to work for an ethical and sustainable environment

Arenas 03 – [Alberto, PhD from UC Berkeley, “In Defense of Good Work: Jobs, Violence, and the Ethical Dimension,” vol 30, no 3, “The Intersection of Ideologies of Violence,” 2003, pgs 94-107, https://www.jstor.org/stable/29768211] /jsam

I have emphasized the idea that a basic first step in reclaiming the ethics of work is to seriously engage the notion of respect, understood here in terms of (1) dignity toward the self and (2) the ultimate purpose of the product or service. In the first sense, respect is an acknowledgement that a strong element of pride and self-esteem is derived from doing excellent work. As Studs Terkel (1975: xiii) wrote, work "is about a search for daily meaning as well as daily bread, for recognition as well as cash, for astonishment rather than torpor; in short, for a sort of life rather than a Monday through Friday sort of dying." In the second sense, respect is related to a wider commitment to the public good, including the environment. The highly individuated person in the name of self-interest and rationality has led to an unparalleled assault on society's welfare. It is imperative to leave behind the mistaken view of economics as a value-free science and to redirect economic forces in ways that leave room for individuals to fulfill their need for adequate economic compensation and craft while safeguarding an ethical dimension. A job enrichment process is one mechanism used by employers to transform jobs into less mind-numbing and sterile activities. In some lines of work, changes have ranged from the cosmetic and trivial (e.g., casual dress and gourmet coffee bars) to the substantial (e.g., decent salaries and job rotation). Both the trite and meaningful are important for improving any workplace. As Roszak forcefully wrote, no matter what improvements a job undergoes, if the product or service is useless, dishonest, or degrading, the second form of respect is violated: Work that produces unnecessary consumer junk or weapons of war is wrong and wasteful. Work that is built upon false needs or unbecoming appetites is wrong and wasteful. Work that deceives or manipulates, that exploits or degrades is wrong and wasteful. Work that wounds the environment or makes the world ugly is wrong and wasteful. There is no way to redeem such work by enriching it or restructuring it, by socializing it or nationalizing it, by making it "small" or decentralized or democratic (Roszak, 1979: 220). Within the logic of capitalism, both forms of respect are seriously undermined. Capitalism creates conditions that compel most individuals to concentrate on the first two motivations for work (and on the third, or craft motivation, for a lucky few). The fourth motivation, a larger moral concern, is denied to most individuals. Due to real (and perceived) economic pressures, little space is left for finding employment that people can genuinely deem a vocation. A key task, then, for employees and employers alike is to perceive work as an inherently valuable activity in itself, regardless of extrinsic economic benefits such as productivity quotas or efficiency rates. Equally necessary, though a more daunting task, is to reorganize our economic and social system so that more people have opportunities to choose work that is imbued with a new spirit of self-discovery and ethical commitment.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.