Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The perm solves best – the workplace is vital as a breeding ground for collective organization – shared subjectivities and social cooperation create the most effective resistance.

Deranty 21

Jean-Philippe Deranty is an associate professor of philosophy at Macquarie University; April 27, 2021; Post-work society as an oxymoron: Why we cannot, and should not, wish work away; ; //[TMS—GK]

Work collectives One of the most original conclusions of Dejours’ inquiries has been the importance of cohesive work collectives from a psychological point of view. Work collectives bring together individuals through the technical division of labour: people working in the same space or involved in delivering a complex output that requires a coordination of their individual contributions. Even though work today can be performed in all kinds of arrangements, including isolated care situations, gig-, project- and ‘distributed work’, many people continue to work alongside others. From a technical point of view, the gap noted earlier for an individual worker between the prescriptions surrounding the task and how they deliver the output, such a gap is repeated at a higher level when several workers are involved. In that case, the gap lies between the formal organisation of the work process and the actual coordination of working activities among the individual workers. Just as each worker needs to find their own way of implementing work prescriptions, the working team needs to coordinate itself, across the individuals involved, to achieve true cooperation and be able to deliver a complex output. Following Dejours’ analyses, there are specific goods attached to stable, well-functioning work collectives. These goods would be difficult to find in other associations, precisely because of the specific constraints of work. Individuals belonging to a work collective, say a team of nurses in a hospital ward, share the same ‘niche’ within the world that their activity has opened up for them. They rely on and must abide by the same technical tools and organisational processes and collectively experience the latter’s potentialities, limitations and constraints. They develop modes of perception, attention and action along similar lines and mobilise their subjective capacities in parallel ways. For all these reasons, work collectives are social spaces in which individual experiences overlap significantly. Furthermore, the rigid frame imposed by work makes the sharing of experience highly specific. Workers share experiences because they face the same challenge of having to bridge the gap between prescription and the actual completion of tasks. Even if they do not get on, they have to coordinate their actions to bridge the gap between formal organisation and effective cooperation. This forces them to confront their own ways of doing things, to find reasons to defend their own perspective and potentially change their views. When a work collective functions well, the recognition it enables is highly specific, since only those who have faced the same challenge can truly judge what it took, in terms of personal resources and professional skills, to achieve a task. In this case, the person knows they are recognised authentically, for something they have truly achieved, based on standards only experts know about. This is the place where ‘a job well done’ can find its true recognition (Dejours, 2012, p. 257), which provides a special vindication of individual achievements. Solidarities built in work collectives have proven throughout history that they can be particularly strong. Many national worker movements had their roots in local workplaces, for instance, labour revolts in France and Italy in the late 1960s, with particular factories as their epicentres. A strategic dimension of the ongoing struggle between capital and labour has been the extent to which organisation on the shop floor is possible or not, as it is the soil where the roots of collective organisation can grow, not just to apply industry-level demands but even to formulate such demands (Burawoy, 1985 on the changing history of these antagonistic relations). Indeed, one aspect of class struggle is that it is often a struggle between collectives, between the collectives of workers and the collectives of managers (Bidet & Duménil, 2007). Theorists of democracy identify workplaces as a locus where democratic capacities are developed and practiced (Pateman, 1970). Dejours (1998) also demonstrates the political significance of work collectives in negative fashion when he shows the deleterious effects of aggressive forms of management on the general social ethos beyond workplaces. Post-work theorists might not deny the existence of workplace solidarity, or its psychological or political significance. Yet the call to de-emphasise work must mean that they think these goods are worth overlooking for the sake of non-work activities and relationships. Yet it is difficult to imagine other social relations that would have the specificity and the psychological depth delivering the goods just mentioned. Working cultures A second type of social relation implied in the work of social reproduction is occupational culture. This is the body of theoretical and practical knowledges and the typical skills a group of working people share as they face similar difficulties, within similar constraints, because of the occupation they have in common. These groups and the cultures they build are more or less formally structured. Arguably, homemakers whose work is not captured in the labour market make up such an occupational group on the basis of the similar tasks they share. More formal occupational cultures are organised in professions and trades whose working cultures are part of their public institutional existence. As Hegel showed, the place that an occupational group takes in the general work of social production in fact grounds more than a repertoire of knowledges and know-hows. It becomes the social anchor point for a whole lifeworld, what he called the ‘corporation’, with its specific ethos, belief system and vision of the world. These working cultures can be observed throughout human history, fleshed out in all kinds of institutional settings, framed by the most diverse cultural representations. In these historical examples, and not just in modern, capitalistic society, two remarkable features can be consistently observed. The first is that working cultures often are social spaces where the solidarity experienced at ground level in a work collective is organised and institutionalised. This was true already in the collegia of the ancient Roman world (Tran, 2019) and medieval corporations (Rosser, 2015). As the modern welfare state began to emerge towards the end of the nineteenth century, and economic and social rights became institutionalised on the basis of social-professional membership, Hegel’s early vision of the occupational roots of welfare and educational provisions (1991, p. 271) became remarkably prescient. Arguably, it is precisely the sharing of a specific kind of occupational necessity and the sharing of the technical knowledge and cultural resources that are developed to respond to it, which provides the ground for such institutionalised practices of solidarity. A second, persistent feature of work cultures is their significance for personal identity. Contrary to assumptions widely shared among social and political theorists, we find in non-Western and premodern societies many examples where the social status of the individual was influenced, more or less directly, depending more or less on the whims of a master or sheer luck, by personal achievements in an occupation. Social fate was not exclusively determined by general social markers, being a free citizen or born of unfree parents, of a noble or plebeian family, being identified as a man or a woman and so on. A Roman slave could hope to achieve freedom and some form of social recognition after manumission through hard and diligent work (Joshel, 1992). An Achuar man of the Amazonian forest owes his social standing to a large extent to his prowess as a hunter and an Achuar woman to her skills as a gardener (Descola, 1994). Even though cultural frames vary enormously across history, it is difficult to imagine that the significant social benefit an individual accrues from doing well in their occupation does not have an effect on their self-representations, even if it is impossible for outsiders to know exactly how this plays out. Given that society needs to be reproduced, all types of work need to be performed. The sharing of working knowledges and practices founds work cultures that can become the framework in which the identity of their members is constructed, as well institutional networks protecting their interests and their welfare. Advocating a post-work society ignores this important layer of social life. We might bemoan the place work has taken in societies dominated by the modern work ethic and think that there could be other ways to socialise than through work. Even if that is a valid concern, it does not have to lead to the conclusion that we should ignore work cultures. Instead, we should advocate social and economic systems that leave room for vibrant work cultures in which equality and solidarity can thrive and promote the flourishing of their members. The cooperative scheme as foundation of the social contract The occupational backbone of society also ensures that the social contract has solid foundations, namely the reciprocal contributions the individuals exchange among each other, which reproduce their lives and the life of the community. If reciprocity in fact exists and working conditions are not alienating or deleterious, this work of social reproduction provides a particularly firm basis for the polis. Work contributions matter deeply to the individuals involved as they mobilise their subjective capacities, impact on their identities and by definition serve social needs. Individuals engage in those activities not just on their own but also through work collectives and occupational groups. And by working, they interact with proximate others (co-workers, real or anonymous addressees of work) as well as the whole of society. A political community based on the exchange of reproductive activities is thus nourished by the life and blood of its members, as it were, and their many, proximate and more distant interactions underneath civic relations. This view of the political community as grounded in the division of labour is a classical one in social and political theory, articulated in different ways by Hegel, Dewey and Rawls, to name just three most eminent representatives. Focusing on the technical, ‘poietic’ aspects of the division of labour, on work as a kind of activity, provides extra conceptual ballast to this view. By contrast, let us imagine a ‘post-work society’. Even if some work still needs to be done, and some might even enjoy it, it no longer has central value. Against the background of the arguments put forward in this section, what does such a society look like? If ‘work’ in ‘post-work society’ just means capitalistic work, abstract labour, many more details need to be provided, to know exactly what the new economic and political organisation would look like. If we use Gorz’s last writings (2018) as paradigm example, it might in fact be a society in which work still matters a lot, to promote autonomy for individuals and indeed at the heart of community organisation, just not in its capitalistic form. Let us assume that more is meant by ‘work’ than just abstract labour. ‘Post-work society’ now means a society in which the exchange of reproductive contributions itself is no longer central. From what has just been said, the question immediately arises of what grounds the social contract. Post-work theorists assure us that moving beyond work is the best way to experience, and experiment with, new ways of being in the world, including new ways of being with others, notably to establish more inclusive forms of citizenship. But what would the bond with anonymous others consist of then? What would bind everyone to other individuals and give them a sense that are not just a collection of isolated atoms, each pursuing their own self-interest? Exactly what would give weight to ‘citizenship’? A realist view of human history, the consideration for example of the political shifts in regions that have undergone rapid deindustrialisation, makes us fear that, absent the exchange of working activities, what unites human beings beyond small communities of kinship or specialised interest, are factors by which they resemble each other, or think they do: the same religion, the same ‘race’, the same ‘culture’, the same imagined national narrative. The question then for ‘post-work’ society is whether it remains a society through a shared factor that is in fact more exclusionary than work is accused of being. It is only by stipulation that post-work theorists can be sure that when the exchange of work outputs is no longer the backbone of society, the outcome will be a freer and fairer social organisation. By contrast, there are many reasons to think that the implicit social contract binding a collective together is all the stronger if it relies on the cooperative scheme. Indeed, if the main consideration for participation in the collective is just the actual contributions individuals make to it, then this de facto undercuts discriminations. Undeniably, race and gender discriminations have intersected and continue to do so, with social representations of occupations and activities. But this is not to be attributed to the logic of work but rather to social logics of hierarchy and discriminatory cultural representations. Cooperation by contrast entails that only the actual contribution, what it took to deliver an output and how useful that output is to individual and collective life, matters. From this technical, ‘poietic’ point of view, neither race, nor gender, nor age, nor any other factor, should matter. Arguably therefore, a social bond that is solely based on effective cooperation has greater chances of undercutting discriminations and ideologically based inequalities. Conclusion The ills of contemporary work that post-work theorists highlight only prove that the current organisation of work should be changed, not that we should ‘abolish work’ (Ford, 2016). Indeed, correcting the injustices and pathologies linked to the contemporary organisation of work and employment can be formulated precisely in reference to the goods work can deliver. Against inequality, all contributors to the cooperative scheme should receive adequate reward for their contributions. That demand is compatible with arguments in favour of a universal basic income. If contribution to cooperation is to be a central aspect of individual and social life, then proper institutional and legal mechanisms need to be in place so that individuals are protected from the precarious features of contemporary working conditions. Indeed, insisting on the goods of work is even compatible with a demand that work take less place in our lives. Post-work theorists might raise a final objection. It is all well and good, they might say, to ask that work be organised differently. But what would that new organisation look like, and how would we get there? How likely is such a social organisation in the current circumstances? The answer to this objection can be very modest: these are tricky questions indeed, but it is not as if post-work models themselves are able to show how we would achieve a post-work society. Post-work theorists claim that, if only everyone else realised it, we could easily move to such a society, that we are already in it in a sense. The problem with this claim is that many people still seem to believe that there is tight link between justice, welfare and work. Rather than telling everyone they are wrong, it might be a better strategy to try and understand why there might indeed be a link between fair work, flourishing and a just society and to set to work to make this link effective.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.