The alternative is to explore the positionality and subjective experiences of workers and understand our collective alienation
Carmichael ’19 (Patrick Carmichael, Managing Director of Camtree: The Cambridge Teacher Research Exchange. Camtree is creating a global platform for educators who wish to reflect on their practice and conduct research to improve learning in their classrooms and institution, “Refusal of Work, Liberation of Time and the Convivial University”, Education and Technological Unemployment, 30 April 2019, https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-981-13-6225-5_17)
The intention was not to be drawn into a minute re-examination of original texts,¶ but rather to explore the realities of everyday working life, particularly in new industries in which precarity and fragmentation were the norm, and in contexts where¶ automation was changing workers’ lives both within and beyond their workplaces.¶ This in turn informed new self-organized social formations, and forms of activism¶ more militant than those organized through established employer–worker committees. Operaist analyses characterized the latter as part of ‘neo-capitalism’ which¶ involved close coordination of capital, industry and trades unions in cycles of mass¶ production and mass consumption (Tronti 2010: 186).¶ A key figure in Quaderni Rossi was Raniero Panzieri, for whom reinvigoration¶ of Marxist theory would accompany the political renovation of the labour movement in ways that were specific to the Italian context. Central to this was a notion of¶ workers’ inquiry (l’inchiesta operaia), that began not in social or political theory or¶ methodology, but was instead ‘hot inquiry’ (inchiesta a caldo) stemming from the¶ situated, subjective experiences of workers who found themselves facing, for example, worsening working conditions; personal precarity caused by automation; or the¶ intrusions of work into other aspects of their social lives (Panzieri 1994: 126). Workers’ inquiry typically involved detailed empirical investigations into the division of¶ labour within workplaces; mapping of the ways in which time was spent both in¶ and out of work; critical reading of organizational documents and data; and autobiographical accounts and diaries. Some later forms of workers’ inquiry involved highly¶ innovative approaches, the ‘interview to the double’ being an example that used the¶ premise of going undercover into a participant’s workplace (as their ‘double’) in¶ order to explore tacit knowledge, workplace micropolitics and subjective experience¶ (Nicolini 2009).¶ Perhaps the most influential of such inquiries were instances of co-research (conricerca) carried out by Romano Alquati, who focused on workplaces such as the¶ factories of Fiat and Olivetti as they underwent cycles of automation (Alquati 1975).¶ For Alquati, co-research was not merely a form of social inquiry undertaken to understand these changes: it represented instead a critically important form of activism¶ which developed workers’ abilities to understand the mechanisms of their alienation,¶ challenge these, and ultimately to extricate themselves from the constraints of capitalist labour (Alquati 1993). This involved supporting workers in reframing their¶ concerns beyond working conditions to explore more expansive political and social¶ questions, Alquati writing:¶ There develops and clarifies for them a correspondence between conditions of labour and¶ the social system… when the demand of today: “fundamentally, what does FIAT give me?”¶ transforms… into another: “What different things can I hope for in a society dominated by¶ businesses like FIAT? (Alquati 1975: 38)