UBI is built on working class needs – It separates income from work, contesting the structures of capital
Feltrin and Sachetto 21 (Lorenzo Feltrin is Leverhulme Early Career Research Fellow at the Department of Political Science and International Studies (POLSIS) of the University of Birmingham, Devi Sacchetto is a full Professor of Sociology of work at the Department of Philosophy, Sociology, Education and Applied Psychology, “The work-technology nexus and working-class environmentalism: Workerism versus capitalist noxiousness in Italy’s Long 1968,” Theory and Society, 3/5/2021, https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11186-021-09441-5#Sec2) - MP
Under the supervision of former fascist officials, the “production inferno” of the post-WWII decades featured appalling toxicities and hazards, where exposure to heat, smokes, and powders and the lack of health and safety measures resulted in widespread accidents and occupational diseases such as cancers, silicosis, asbestosis, hepatic and dermatological pathologies, etc. (see Zazzara 2009). Montedison’s Petrolchimico began producing polyvinyl chloride (PVC) using Monsanto patents that involved high levels of toxicity. The Montedison worker and then environmental activist Gabriele Bortolozzo wrote: “The chloralkali units were sadly disastrous for the workers, due not only to chlorine but also to mercury vapour. […] To calm things down, all the company did […] was distributing abundant doses of cow milk”Footnote4 (Bortolozzo 1998, 33). Up to the 1950s, Porto Marghera’s class composition was centred on the figure of the “peasant-factory worker”, employed in factories but living in the countryside and immersed in a rural lifestyle (Piva and Tattara 1983). Some of them, the so-called “metalmezzadri” (literally “metal-sharecroppers”) had access to small plots of land. Strong ties to the land would remain a characteristic of Veneto’s working-class culture even after their material severance. This was a time of labour weakness and relative social peace, as Veneto was a scarcely industrialised, conservative region, where the Left had limited influence. However, the situation began to change rapidly in the 1960s, when a new cohort of young workers showed their determination not to accept the hard fate endured by their parents, with the first major strike at Edison taking place in July 1963. Ties to the land proved not to necessarily be a factor of quiescence: “The Petrolchimico workers were peasants until the day before, and after taking off their blue overalls [some] went home to work their plot. […] The strike days were very expensive for the urban workers, and less for the others”.Footnote5 The Porto Marghera group originated in the early 1960s through the encounter between intellectuals and studentsFootnote6 – mostly based in Padua and Venice – led by Antonio Negri and militant workers disaffected with the line of the Italian Communist Party (PCI) and its associated union Italian General Confederation of Labour (CGIL) (Sacchetto and Sbrogiò 2009). By 1967, they had become an extra-parliamentary local organisation known as Potere Operaio, with an office in Marghera and a journal titled Il potere operaio: Giornale politico degli operai di Porto Marghera, leafletting regularly outside the factory gates. Over the 1960s, the Porto Marghera group developed its own perspective centred on the mastering of the productive cycle and radically egalitarian demands as an instrument for class recomposition: equal wage increases (in absolute value) for everyone or inversely proportional wage hikes, a guaranteed minimum wage for all workers, the reduction of the working week, and an abolition of differences in statutory conditions (holidays, social contributions, etc.) among the different categories of employees. The guaranteed wage was rapidly expanded to become a “guaranteed income” as a demand to unify all workers, waged and unwaged. This strategy built on immediate working-class needs to expand them quantitatively to the breaking point of incompatibility with capitalism. As the division of the working class through differential wages and conditions was a political instrument of class dominance, “egalitarianism was not merely making do in the warmth of equals”Footnote7 but a political platform to “make the wage an independent variable”, independent from productivity gains in line with Keynesian planning. This platform proved to be largely successful when the discontent of Petrolchimico’s workers exploded in the summer of 1968 (see Bortolozzo 1998; Chinello 1996; Sacchetto and Sbrogiò 2009; Sbrogiò 2016; Trevisan 2017; Zazzara 2009). By then, Potere Operaio’s influence had reached five out of seven members of the CGIL workplace executive committee (commissione interna) at Petrolchimico. This mobilisation was thus characterised by a “dual leadership” in which Potere Operaio conducted a hard rank-and-file campaign of wildcat strikes, active pickets, mass marches, and roadblocks – culminating in the occupation of the Venice-Mestre train station on 1 August 1968 – while the unions were pressured to endorse the egalitarian demands of the base and negotiate for them at the institutional level. Class conflict would remain extremely high throughout 1969, when it expanded countrywide with the “Hot Autumn” strike wave for the renewal of the national-sectorial collective agreements (see Wright 2002). In June 1969, however, CGIL expelled a number of prominent Potere Operaio shop stewards and activists. The already acrimonious relationship between Potere Operaio – which became a national organisation in that yearFootnote8 – and the unions deteriorated further as the Porto Marghera group adopted a line of frontal opposition against the traditional labour movement. The unions, meanwhile, developed a more base-oriented approach that would allow them to recover much of the credibility lost in the first stages of the strike wave (Trevisan 2017), “riding the tiger” of workers’ spontaneity. The Porto Marghera group’s theorising over noxiousness was spearheaded by the Petrolchimico technician Augusto Finzi, with the assistance of external intellectuals such as high school chemistry professor Lino Bassani, academic physicians Libero Battiston and Loriano Bonora, University of Padua’s occupational health professor Bruno Saia, and Claudio Sossai, a mathematician for Italy’s National Research Council. Born in 1941 from a well-off Jewish familyFootnote9 based in insular Venice, Finzi spent part of his early childhood in a refugee camp in Switzerland to escape the Shoah.Footnote10 In 1960, he received a high school diploma in chemistry from Mestre’s Istituto Pacinotti – “where the beginning and end of the classes were signalled by the sound of a [factory-like] siren”Footnote11 – and immediately began working in a Petrolchimico VCM-PVC unit, where he joined the Porto Marghera workerist group around 1965–66. In many ways, Finzi’s “factory intellectual” profile was the counterpart to Italo Sbrogiò’s practical and charismatic approach. The Porto Marghera group’s most prominent leader, Italo SbrogiòFootnote12 was a Petrolchimico maintenance worker hailing from a poor and numerous rural family.Footnote13 Having started working before finishing elementary school, he reached Porto Marghera aged sixteen as a precarious construction labourer and joined Potere Operaio through, and in spite of, his activism in PCI and CGIL, from which he was expelled in 1969. He remembered his early factory years in these terms: “Chemical technology crashed on us like an avalanche, so much so that many labourers and technicians paid for this experience with their lives” (Sbrogiò 2016, 13–14). Up to the 1960s, the routine policy regarding noxiousness was its “monetisation”: unions and management would agree a compensation for the health damage and risks that workers suffered. The first notable struggle over noxiousness in which the Porto Marghera group was involved took place in 1967, precisely when Montedison decided to withdraw the noxiousness allowances from some factory units. In a way, this was merely a reactive struggle to restore what could be called the “moral economy of noxiousness” that had held sway up to that point. Yet, it marked the beginnings of the Porto Marghera group’s reflections and actions around noxiousness (Potere operaio, 20 June 1967).