Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

A gendered lens is crucial to move feminist theory from the abstract into real world situations which is crucial to making it relevant

Robeyns, 2001 – Chair Ethics of Institutions at the Utrecht University, Netherlands [Ingrid. “Will a Basic Income Do Justice to Women?: A Contribution to the Symposium on P. Van Parijs ’s “Real Freedom for All” Analyse & Kritik, vol. 23, no. 1 https://doi-org.proxy.lib.umich.edu/10.1515/auk-2001-0108 AC]

Most of this research is gender blind in the sense that it does not tackle the question whether a basic income would differently affect men and women. However, a thorough gender analysis could be interesting for two reasons: there is a public interest to know more about this issue and currently there are opposite claims being made about the expected gender effects. Proponents of a basic income argue that unpaid work would get some recognition (Miller 1986; Walter 1989; Withorn 1990), that the autonomy of poor women (McKayfVanEvery 1995) or all women (Walter 1989) would increase, that it would help to achieve greater gender equality in the labour market by improving women’s bargaining position and by encouraging men to work part-time, thus allowing them to share more in domestic work (Standing 1992) and that it would be possible to choose for unpaid labour (Miller 1986; Walter 1989). Parker (1993) claims that a basic income holds more advantages for women than the current British social security system, not because a basic income favours women, but because the British social security system benefits men more. However, according to Parker a basic income is not enough to change the current situation, and equal opportunities and equal wages remain important. These positive evaluations stand in contrast with the belief among some fem-inists that a basic income will turn out to be some kind of housewives wage or hush money, sending women back home and tempering emancipation. According to Orloff (1990), a basic income is not a good strategy to reach gender equality and justice. She claims that the unequal division of household responsibilities is crucial in the explanation of the disadvantageous position of women in society and that other elements of social policy, which alter the structure of both paid and unpaid work, can be much more effective to reach gender justice. Although there are very few academic articles arguing for this point of view, it has often been raised by the audiences of academic or public debates on basic income. Some feminist pamphlets and articles in popular magazines also strongly oppose a basic income. However, it is important to stress that this belief is not shared py all feminists-there are also feminist advocates of a basic income. Authors on basic income proposals are not alone in neglecting the gender di-mension and its moral problems. Feminist philosophers and feminist theorists haven’t raised this question either. As Nussbaum (1999a, 278; 1999b, 38) argues, feminist philosophy has increasingly turned away from the material side of life, towards theories of verbal and symbolic politics. Similarly, Barrett (1992) de-scribes the “shift from things to words” in feminist theory. Recent handbooks in feminist theory, like Kemp and Squires (1997), hardly make any reference to economic subjects or material inequality, but instead focus on topics like the body, representation, sexuality, and race and ethnicity. In this article, I want to make a first step towards a better understanding of the moral questions and problems of gender justice that can arise with the implementation of a basic income. In her recent book on gender inequality and injustice against lesbians and gays, Nussbaum (1999a) has repeatedly argued that real-life political issues, especially those where deep disagreement exists, can only be solved if we approach them rationally and lay out the arguments to feed the civil public debate. In an attempt to take this route, I will use insights from social and economic research on basic income to introduce the gender-related normative questions into the philosophical discussion. Hence, this article will address the question whether a basic income does justice to women in the context of West-European welfare states. The article is structured as follows. The next section provides a descriptive gender analysis of a basic income. Section 3 analyses some of the normative arguments. Section 4 spells out the genuine moral issues underlying the tension between gender justice and basic income. The last section concludes. 2. A Descriptive Gender Analysis If we introduce a basic income, which effects relevant for a gender analysis can we expect? A basic income causes two kinds of effects: first order effects (visible, important and easily recognisable effects, taking place in the short run) and second order effects (less material effects, less visible, and with some effects only in the long run.) I will discuss three first order effects (2.1-2.3): changes in labour supply, changes in incomes, and changes in well-being derived from a change in (profes-sional) activities. I will also discuss six second order effects (2.4-2.9): a revaluation of unpaid work, psychological effects on housewives, a change in the bargaining position and power in the household, non-pecuniary advantages of paid labour, the decrease of human capital, and spill-over effects due to statistical discrimination.1

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.