US welfare programs perpetuate devaluation of women by disregarding caregiving labor as incompatible with wage earning
Karcher, 2018 – winner Best Undergraduate Paper in Labor Studies from the Bridges Center for Labor Studies at the Univ of Washington [Kathryn, Mar 4, 2018-2019 “Pursuing Social Justice: How Might a Universal Basic Income or Federal Jobs Guarantee Help Women? https://digital.lib.washington.edu/researchworks/handle/1773/43803?show=full AC]
To receive the federal block grant TANF established, states are required to mandate work participation rates.64 This is based on the idea that welfare undermines individual responsibility and recipients’ work ethic.65 Ending welfare, however, means ending poor, unmarried mothers’ ability to caregive.66 Unmarried women specifically are disadvantaged because PRWORA requires just one parent to engage in work activities. This makes interfamilial child care nearly impossible for unmarried women whom it forces to leave their homes to work. PRWORA fails to accommodate the needs of these women. This makes wage-earning and caregiving incompatible for many women, ensuring that successfully combining these aspects of life remains a privilege for women who are married or can afford to hire caregivers. Meanwhile, PRWORA forces married mothers into dependence on male wages and pressures them to sacrifice wage-earning because formal employment structures do not accommodate family needs.67 Work requirements also treat mothers as providers of goods, services, and care for any other children and families besides their own.68 Policies that force women to accept even low-paying and menial work send the message that, if a caregiver is unmarried, her labor is more valuable anywhere other than her own home and with her own children. Women of color disproportionately fulfill these caregiving roles and do so in White families. This perpetuates the devaluation of Black women’s intimate lives and domestic responsibilities. These requirements therefore harm White and Black women in different ways, and they harm poor women regardless of race. They reveal U.S. society’s disregard for the importance of caregiving labor and our readiness to force poor women into inadequate jobs even if it means that they and their families are worse off.