Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Domestic labor roles are key to the patriarchy – they create hierarchies that devalue women’s care work and maintain their dependence on men.

Robeyns, 2001 – Chair Ethics of Institutions at the Utrecht University, Netherlands [Ingrid. “Will a Basic Income Do Justice to Women?: A Contribution to the Symposium on P. Van Parijs ’s “Real Freedom for All” Analyse & Kritik, vol. 23, no. 1 https://doi-org.proxy.lib.umich.edu/10.1515/auk-2001-0108 AC]

Another indication why gender roles are at the disadvantage of women is that people who are not doing a substantial part of household work, or bear no respon-sibility for it, tend to underestimate this work. The results of a project in Iceland and occasional evidence from the media suggest that men taking parental leave or becoming househusband are surprised to see how demanding household work is, and start valuing the work much more once they (had to) do it for a while by themselves. Sticking to traditional gender roles will probably imply that house-hold work will continue to be underestimated by men who don't do a substantial part of it. Second, one has to recognise the importance of gender differences in power, or as Nussbaum (1999a, 286-287) calls them, gender hierarchies. In general, we can define gender differences in power as a general tendency in society that men have more power than women. As men occupy most of the powerful or influential jobs (politicians, bankers, religious leaders, publishers, investors, directors, profes-sors, media makers, ... ), they can claim more resources, influence public policy, determine public agenda setting and set social norms. Those men are typically also better integrated in networks of other men who can provide them with infor-mation, jobs and rare and cheap services and goods. Women are more likely to have less command over money, resources, (influential) jobs, networks of powerful people, etcetera. Women are also much more likely to bear either the day-to-day responsibility or at least the final responsibility for dependents. Some examples, like the earlier mentioned division of labour in heterosexual couples, give some indication how these gender power differences have some small seeds from the very. beginning of life, and are confirmed and intensified in an accumulating way through life. Gender roles and the gender division of labour are two of those fac-tors2 that help men gain their power, and prevent women from getting an equal distribution of power.3 Some authors, like Mill (1869) and Okin (1989; 1995) also discuss the role that the unequal division of labour within families has on public justice. They argue that families have to form the moral characters of children, and prepare them to be just democratic citizens. However, "families in which females are unequal to males serve those goals badly; for they raise males who are used to a feudal hierarchy within the household and who will therefore have a difficult time tolerating political equality outside the household. A more equal division of power between males and females, by contrast, better serves these larger human interests." (Nussbaum 1999a, 272) Research on the division of labour in lesbian couples is very revealing on how gender roles influence the division of labour. Empirical research shows that lesbian couples are far more egalitarian than heterosexual couples (Dunne 1998a; 1998b). This can be explained because the division of labour in those couples is less guided by gender roles. Moreover, in the public sphere the male gender role of fully committed employees is not expected from those women, so that both mothers can combine paid work with family commitments.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.