Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

A feminist lens is essential for the Basic Income debate because it reveals the gendered assumptions of the independent autonomous subject and the nature of care work

Zelleke, 2011 - The New School for General Studies, New York [Almaz, Policy & Politics vol 39 no 1, “Feminist political theory and the argument for an unconditional basic income” https://almazzelleke.files.wordpress.com/2015/08/zelleke-feminist-political-theory-and-ubi.pdf Acc 1/28/23 TA]

Contemporary debates on the merits of a basic income take place in the literatures of distributive justice, citizenship, equality and public policy. Liberal egalitarian theories of justice, including those of Rawls (1971), Dworkin (2000) and White (2003), defend the legitimacy of some redistribution of income and wealth, but differ about how much is justified, and under what conditions. An unconditional basic income is thought by some liberal egalitarians to represent exploitation of ‘crazies’ – those who have high earnings to which they are morally entitled – by ‘lazies’ – those who prefer not to work, or decline the jobs that are available to them (Elster ,1986). Related to this exploitation objection, but grounded in an ideal of citizenship rather than of distributive justice, is the claim that the reciprocity principle requires, if not a strictly proportional relationship between effort and income, at least a relatively proportional ‘productive’ contribution to be eligible for the benefits of redistribution (White, 2003). The concept of independence is used both by basic income advocates, who see the universal grant as providing all citizens with the independence akin to that bestowed by an inheritance (Meade, 1993) or by inalienable voting rights (Pateman, 2005), and by its opponents, who argue that those dependent on income benefits can never achieve the independence necessary for full citizenship (Mead, 1986). Full consideration of the arguments for basic income is beyond the scope of this article. Here I focus on examining the premises on which the most salient objections to an unconditional basic income are constructed. I argue that traditional theories of justice and citizenship posit an ostensibly gender-neutral but clearly androcentric subject – the autonomous, ‘independent’ and dependant-free adult faced with a choice between employment and leisure. Dominant theories of justice and citizenship make this problematic presumption without fully understanding how that subject embodies a gender bias that is inimical to women’s equality. The effect of this gender bias in the realm of distributive justice in general, and in the basic income debate in particular, is the reinforcement of economic inequalities between those with disproportionate responsibility for care work and those without, through the undervaluing of care work as a social contribution, and through misconceptions about the extent to which care work can be commodified and those who now provide it unburdened of it. Training a feminist lens on justice and citizenship, through which androcentric theories are tempered by recognition of these dependencies and of the importance of care work, suggests the broad outlines of a feminist theory of justice and citizenship that promotes the fullest conception of distributive justice – one that embodies a substantive equality of the genders. Despite the existence of many thoughtful critiques of male-centric political theory and theories of justice, as well as numerous policies and policy proposals meant to address specific instances of gender inequality, a comprehensive feminist theory of justice has yet to be articulated. In relation to the basic income debate, I argue that not only does a feminist perspective on justice require an unconditional basic income, but also that is the only basis on which to defend the principle of unconditionality against the gender-biased claims of universal work or participation duties. Therefore, the debates around an unconditional basic income constitute a fruitful arena for the development of a feminist theory of justice. I begin this article with a brief survey of the feminist critiques of political theory and theories of justice, and of androcentric models of citizenship. Together these critiques suggest a more gender-inclusive model of citizenship and the broad outlines of a feminist theory of justice, in which an unconditional basic income plays a crucial role.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.