Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Family patriarchy subordinate women - women’s activities are excluded from the idea of work - conceptions of work center on the production of commodities for the market ignoring the nature of household work

Mckay, 2001 – prof of economics at Glascow Univ. [Ailsa, “Rethinking Work And Income Maintenance Policy: Promoting Gender Equality Through A Citizens ’ Basic Income,” Feminist Economics, 3/1/01, http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1467-923X.2004.00611.x/abstract, TA]

Conceptually work is usually distinguished from leisure. The implication is that the cost of time spent engaging in activities clearly defined as work can be measured by the associated sacrifice of leisure time. This is not to say that all of those activities we deem enjoyable are categorized as “leisure” and activities involving pain, toil, or a sacrifice of enjoyment as “work.” Work may be something we enjoy, but it is distinct from leisure in that it is not done solely for its own sake but must also be purposeful. Any activity that displays “the characteristic of using up time and energy for an extrinsic purpose” can be defined as work, in that desirable end results are created through a process that involves an opportunity cost of lost leisure time (Susan Himmelweit 1995: 3). These end results are not only produced for the enjoyment or satisfaction of the individual carrying out the activity, but also have a use-value that can be shared by others. It is therefore the productive, purposeful aspect of any activity that defines it as work. For André Gorz (1994: 53), conceptualizing work in this way is a feature of modern industrial capitalism: So long as commodity production remained marginal and the great majority of needs were covered by domestic production and the village economy, the notion of “work” as such . . . could not take hold. People “produced”, “constructed” and “prepared” things; they “laboured”, “toiled”, “drudged” and “attended to” a wide variety of specific “occupations” which had no common measure between them within the framework of the domestic community. And responsibility for the various activities was assumed by the husband, the wife, the children or the older members of the family according to an immutable division of labour. These activities were gendered . . . and thus there was no common denominator between them. They were not interchangeable, and could not be compared and evaluated in terms of a single yardstick. The term “work” referred not to a creative or productive act but to the activity in so far as it entailed pain, annoyance and fatigue. The dominance of commodity production and consumption over subsistence production brought about by the development of capitalist modes of production results in the depersonalization of work activities. This leads Gorz to assert that the modern notion of work refers to: the name of an activity fundamentally different from the activities of subsistence, reproduction, maintenance and care performed within the household. This is not so much because “work” is a paid activity, but because it is done in the public domain and appears there as a measurable, exchangeable and interchangeable performance; as a performance which possesses a use-value for others, not simply for the members of the household community carrying it out; for others in general, without distinction or restriction, not for a particular, private person. (Ibid.: 53) This socialization of productive activities means that the worker becomes separable from the resulting output. Producing goods and services for exchange in the public domain renders irrelevant the direct relationship between the person carrying out the task and their economic output. Activities are interchangeable between workers, and outputs become measurable in terms of their use-value to others. In modern terms the concept of work is associated with any impersonal activity that results in output that can be measured and presented as a commodity, or service, for sale or exchange in an impersonal public marketplace. Many of the activities frequently performed by women are “invisible,” in the sense that there is either no tangible output, or the actual nature, and therefore value, of the output is not transparent. Consequently these activities do not meet the conventional criteria that would allow them to be labeled ‘“work.” Although much progress has been made in valuing domestic work to illustrate the signifi cance of women’s productive contribution to the economy (see, for example, the Human Development Report 1995) little has been done to quantify “provisioning” functions within the family. That is, the label domestic work is generally assigned to a range of “physical” tasks, considered essential ingredients in the effi cient functioning of the household economy. Such tasks can either be undertaken by a person(s) employed for that specifi c purpose or can be performed by an individual member of the household who receives no formal remuneration for doing so. The latter I refer to as “internalized unpaid domestic work,” which serves to draw the distinction between work done by the “hired help” and work done by wives and mothers themselves. As noted above, attempts at recognizing the value of internalized unpaid domestic work have at least got under way. However, in addition to internalized unpaid domestic work, many nonphysical exchanges or services performed in the household contribute positively to individual welfare, which prove even more difficult to quantify. Examples of “provisioning functions within the family” include the transfer of knowledge or skills, providing a safe and loving environment, expressing and acting from concern for the health and emotional needs of other family members, and organizing the distribution and allocation of resources within the family unit. Many of these activities are essential for human survival, particularly those concerned with the care of children ( Julie Nelson 1993: 32). Nonmaterial sources of human satisfaction influence intra-family power structures and directly affect the economic position of women. That they remain in the periphery of the economics discipline is possibly because quantifying them would be a technically difficult thing to do. However, it more likely stems from the fact that such activities are not viewed as “important” simply because they are performed by women; Humans are born of women, nurtured and cared for as dependent children, socialized into family and community groups, and are perpetually dependent on nourishment and shelter to sustain their lives. These aspects of human life, whose neglect is often justified by the argument that they are unimportant or intellectually uninteresting or merely “natural”, are, not just coincidentally, the areas of life thought of as “women’s work”. (Nelson 1996: 31)

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.