A UBI breaks down existing gender roles because it recognizes that reproductive labor in the home is as valuable as the male wage worker
Karcher, 2018 – winner Best Undergraduate Paper in Labor Studies from the Bridges Center for Labor Studies at the Univ of Washington [Kathryn, Mar 4, 2018-2019 “Pursuing Social Justice: How Might a Universal Basic Income or Federal Jobs Guarantee Help Women? https://digital.lib.washington.edu/researchworks/handle/1773/43803?show=full] EP
Some claim that we value certain types of labor less because they are worth less based on merit. The importance of reproductive labor undermines this claim. Few things are more important than birthing and “raising children, tending to the disabled and the sick, aiding the elderly, and giving succor to the dying: few things are of more societal importance.” Still, this labor goes unpaid, or is paid with low wages and few benefits, unrecognized, and unaccounted for even though unpaid “care workers provide the infrastructure that lets formal labor exist.” There is no productive labor without reproductive labor. But we also dismiss women’s productive labor. Women disproportionately enter lower-paid and female-dominated occupations, but they are directly influenced by societal norms, discrimination, and other forces which influence their decisions to enter these fields. To solve these problems, we need a policy that does not try to fit women into the mold of the male wage worker. Existing policies simply “add women and stir” when they try to be inclusive, treating them as “subjects without changing the tools of analysis.” If we are to undermine oppressive hierarchies of race and gender, we cannot maintain structures which devalue or erase some forms of labor because they do not fit with the dominant groups’ interpretations, experiences, and life patterns. Unlike potential reforms which try to incorporate women into existing systems of labor, UBI offers an alternative route that acknowledges that all people contribute to society through some form of participation. UBI would compensate women for their unpaid labor and reject the notion that those who perform it do not contribute to society. It would also recognize the value of and thereby bolster the wages of women of color who are most often paid caregivers, as well as compensate women for their “second shift.”