A basic income empowers women – it gives autonomy over financial decision making, valuing care work benefits women’s mental health, and it dispels the male breadwinner model by giving men the opportunity to enter caregiving.
Cantillon and McLean, 2016 - Glasgow Caledonian University and UC Berkeley [Sara and Caitlin, Sept 3, The Journal of Sociology & Social Welfare, Basic Income Guarantee: The Gender Impact within Households," Available at: https://scholarworks.wmich.edu/jssw/vol43/iss3/7 Acc 1/28/23 TA]
There is a large theoretical literature and accumulating empirical evidence to suggest that in addition to, or even regardless of, material welfare gains, independent income provides a source of economic autonomy which, in turn, impacts bargaining and power relations with the household. Differences between men and women in terms of their roles in household decision-making (particularly regarding income and large expenditures) have been linked to their differences in terms of income, status, education, and ethnicity (Cantillon & Nolan, 1998, 2001; Nyman & Reinikainen, 2007; Rake & Jayatilka, 2002). An important distinction has also been made between high-level decisions on the allocation of resources to each area (food, clothing, household bills, holidays, etc.) and instrumental decisions regarding the management of the budget within each of these areas (Pahl, 1989). Several studies suggest that the woman usually engages in the management of household resources, while the overall allocative control and decisionmaking power rests with the man (Lauer & Yodanis, 2011). Differences in control over household finances are therefore important in their own right, as an indicator of power, and for the role they may play in producing and explaining differences in living standards. Differences in management are also important insofar as they reflect respective roles in decision- making and identify who carries the burden of responsibility for stretching scarce resources. Several UK studies, using both small scale surveys and large nationally representative samples (Rake & Jayatilaka, 2002; Vogler, 1998; Vogler & Pahl, 1994), have explored different systems for managing household resources and their implications for the living standards of individual members. Rottman (1994), Cantillon, Gannon, and Nolan (2004) and Watson, Maître, & and Whelan (2013) used Irish data to examine this issue and also identified a number of distinct approaches to managing resources. The studies produced similar results: while joint financial decision-making is common among couples, in a significant proportion of couples the husband retains control in terms of major decisions, while the wife has the responsibility of managing resources on a week-to-week basis. Further, the responsibility for making resources stretch when money is tight falls disproportionately on women. A third possible effect is that, irrespective of any material benefit or even increased control over financial resources, a BIG could have a positive psychological impact on women's sense of self and well-being. Some of those studying BIG have pointed out that this could be a result of increased recognition or valuation of unremunerated work, in the sense that activities outside the paid labor market are formally recognised as worthwhile (Robeyns, 2001). Alternatively, it could arise in terms of measures of psychological health and well-being where independent income provides a greater sense of control, as empirical studies within the intra-household literature have demonstrated (Cantillon & Moran, 2016; Kan & Laurie 2010; Walters, McDonough, & Strohschein, 2002). The fourth effect relates to the issue of inequalities in leisure time and participation in unpaid work. There is now a vast literature documenting disparities in time use between men and women which has specifically highlighted the greater participation of women in unpaid domestic and care work and the inequality of leisure time which results from this (Bianchi, Sayer, Milkie, & Robinson, 2012; Latshaw, 2011). BIG advocates have argued that unconditional cash benefits can raise the status of work outside the labor market, as well as reduce economic pressure to create space for such activity. For example, McKay (2005) and Zelleke (2011) argue that a BIG does not prioritize labor market participation at the expense of productive activity outside the labor market and therefore does not penalize individuals for engaging in it. There is a tendency to assume that this would lead to continued gender specialization; however, an unconditional, steady cash payment could theoretically reduce pressure on men as breadwinners by providing a measure of financial security outside labor market income, allowing space for men to reduce their participation in the labor market and potentially to take on a greater share of traditionally feminine tasks (Bambrick, 2006). This could be heightened or strengthened via the psychological effect: e.g., greater societal value placed on these activities could shape men's willingness to engage in such work.