Our framework is best for discussing a UBI because it endorses an intersectional approach to addressing injustice.
Karcher, 2018 – winner Best Undergraduate Paper in Labor Studies from the Bridges Center for Labor Studies at the Univ of Washington [Kathryn, Mar 4, 2018-2019 “Pursuing Social Justice: How Might a Universal Basic Income or Federal Jobs Guarantee Help Women? https://digital.lib.washington.edu/researchworks/handle/1773/43803?show=full EO]
It is crucial to discuss the social, not just the economic, costs and consequences of these potential policies. Recognizing the relationship between the economic and the social, rather than prioritizing the former, is necessary for a proper discussion of UBI and FJG. I adopt the premise that economic injustice necessarily coexists with social injustice, and vice versa.1 It is essential to discuss these forms of injustices from an intersectional perspective which accounts for the ways in which multiple axes of oppression impact women—particularly those who are not heterosexual, White, or well-off. Due to their positionality within a society characterized by white supremacy, heteropatriarchy, and classism, these women will experience qualitatively different forms of oppression than do more privileged women.2 Those concerned with justice for all women must adopt an intersectional approach when addressing injustice and strive to ensure that policies’ material aspects are not considered separately from their social consequences. Based on this premise, this paper emphasizes the importance of centering vulnerable groups’ needs, with a particular focus on women due to their unique experiences under American welfare policies. I do not attempt to provide a detailed plan to implement UBI or FJG, which other writers and commentators have addressed. I instead ask how advocates and political figures should discuss and evaluate public policies. Which policy—FJG or UBI—would most effectively combat women’s oppression? Which is more likely to be implemented? Should those concerned with gender injustice advocate for UBI, FJG, or a combination of the two? Advocates for UBI and FJG fall into three camps—those emphasizing poverty, freedom, and democratic citizenship rights. Philippe Van Parijs has presented what has become the most popular argument for UBI. He argues for a “real libertarian” approach that focuses on “real freedom for all.”3 Real freedom requires security, individual self-ownership, and the opportunity to do whatever one wishes. He argues that if income is as important as we think, real freedom depends on both rights and one’s means. This includes the ability to purchase or consume and to live as one pleases. UBI would secure this freedom.4