A UBI is better than a jobs guarantee because it provides a more stable income and avoids disemployment in menial jobs.
Lawhon and McCreary, 2020 - profs of Geography at Universities of Oklahoma and Florida State [Mary and Tyler, March, Antipode – A Radical Journal of Geography “Beyond Jobs vs Environment: On the Potential of Universal Basic Income to Reconfigure Environmental Politics” https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/anti.12604 Acc 3/31/23 TA]
Recent public discussions about a Green New Deal (GND) in the US explicitly draw on ideas of a Just Transition and form a useful example for us here. While as yet a nascent platform, the GND broadly proposes that jobs will be created through investments in green infrastructure and includes provisions for worker training and a “Jobs Guarantee”.1 Our concern with a Jobs Guarantee is that it is disconnected from changes occurring to employment in North America and globally. As noted above, technological disemployment will change the types of jobs associated with new employment possibilities and many activities may well be done more safely and cheaply by robots. Those trained to work in high automated facilities are highly skilled; few can conceivably transfer into this type of work with a few months or even years of state-supported training programs (for a wider analysis of the limited success of retraining programs, see Selingo 2018). In this context, it is likely to be cheaper, safer, greener, and more socially beneficial to provide incomes rather than jobs for many workers (see Schuppert 2019). We are mindful that a UBI is unlikely to match the current incomes of workers in many extractive industries, particularly those in the global North. Frankly, we do not believe a truly sustainable transition can stabilise everyone’s incomes at those levels if we are to reduce overall global economic throughput. However, we are hopeful that new coalitions can be built around UBI, reorganising the economies of resource-dependent communities. Currently, within such communities, there is a broad consensus around the necessity of extractive industries as the primary source of community livelihoods, as families, service sector workers, and even local governments rely upon the recirculation of industrial workers wages. A UBI ruptures this dynamic of dependency, redistributing income to people who do socially reproductive work, both in the service sector and the home, and enhancing the relative autonomy of this population. The work of raising children, cleaning, and cooking food continues to be disproportionately done by women and racially marginalised people globally—a population that is rarely focal in the literature on Just Transitions. In currently resource-dependent regions, a UBI has the potential to delink local communities from their reliance on the recirculation of industrial workers wages, creating new alliances between people who do undervalued or unrecognised work, as well as those who have been abandoned by both the old industrial economy and its emergent automation (see Marais 2018). Thus, we suggest that the ultimate goals of a Just Transition (the provision of livelihoods for displaced workers and support for the economies that depend upon them) are likely to actually more effectively and efficiently be achieved through adoption of a UBI.