Monthly will not help poor families build wealth – regular payments would be consumed by day to day expenses.
Bhattacharya 2019 - director of programs and strategy at the Insight Center for Community Economic Development [Jhumpa “Exploring Guaranteed Income through a Racial and Gendered Justice Lens” https://rooseveltinstitute.org/publications/exploring-guaranteed-income-through-a-racial-and-gender-justice-lens/#:~:text=In%20%E2%80%9C%20Exploring%20Guaranteed%20Income%20Through%20a%20Racial,that%20is%20capable%20of%20redefining%20these%20wealth%20divides. June 2019. Accessed 23 June 2023 EO]
While the universality of the benefit is very attractive to many, the effects of the benefit greatly depend on where a family sits in the economic ladder. For single mothers and families of color who disproportionately live paycheck to paycheck (Bhattacharya and Price 2018) and struggle to make ends meet, a monthly installment allows them to use the cash benefit as a way to pay for basic household costs, such as rent, food, and utilities. It can serve as a buffer in times of income volatility due to circumstances out of their control like a change in shift hours or a cut in pay. It can also provide a sense of agency to low-income families—a feeling often reserved for those in higher income brackets. An unconditional cash benefit allows people to make the best decisions for themselves and/or their families on how to spend the money, rather than solely suffer through a paternalistic, means-tested public benefit that often strips dignity and aims to control behavior. Unconditional cash gives the message that we actually trust people and doesn’t restrict people’s behavior in the ways that many other public benefit programs do. These gains should not be taken lightly. However, expecting that these families could use the benefit towards wealth accumulation is a stretch, as the most likely scenario is that the benefit will help people meet a basic standard of living that their current incomes do not allow them to do. Low-income families are battling low wages that do not allow them to meet the actual costs of living, are in jobs that do not pay benefits, and bear the brunt of criminal justice fines and fees. Without addressing these factors, a monthly cash benefit can only go as far as meeting the basic human needs that our government currently fails to guarantee, and it will not help low income families build wealth.