Colour Blindness turns the case - The racial blindness in the discourse of a UBI will be reflected in the political implementation of the policy.
Nwogbo, 2021 – PhD Candidate in Philosophy at University of Sussex [Johnbosco, Dec 20, Doctoral Thesis “Racial Injustice And Philippe Van Parijs’ Distributive Justice Basis For The Universal Basic Income: Introducing The Filtered Leximinning Of Modified Real Freedom Theory Of Distributive Justice” https://philpapers.org/rec/NWORIA Acc 3/23/23 TA]
In chapter two, I argued that Van Parijs's theory of distributive justice is blind to institutional racism, which is a form of racial injustice. I demonstrated this by showing that given the choice between two societies that are similar in every respect except in terms of the distribution of people of different races across opportunity strata, i.e. sections of the population defined by having the same amount of opportunities, a person choosing between them using Van Parijs's leximin principle would not prefer a non-institutionally racist society to an institutionally racist one. This, I suggest, is a serious charge to be brought against a theory of justice. And insofar as Van Parijs's theory of distributive justice is the basis of his universal basic income offer, this blindness to racial injustice also implicates the basic income offer. If the theory of distributive justice that grounds the basic income offer is blind to institutional racism, it can be argued that it follows that the basic income offer itself that results is similarly problematic vis a vis institutional racism.