Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Turn - A carbon tax would decrease long-run inflation

Richhild Moessner, 2022, Center for Economic Studies and ifo Institute, “Effects of Carbon Pricing on Inflation,” Working Paper No. 9563, https://www.econstor.eu/bitstream/10419/252080/1/cesifo1_wp9563.pdf, mm

We study how carbon pricing has affected consumer price inflation ex-post, using dynamic panel estimation of New-Keynesian Phillips curves across countries for 35 OECD economies from 1995 to 2020. As carbon pricing we consider carbon taxes and prices of emissions trading systems (ETS). Carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions are a key driver of global warming and climate change, and have continued to increase globally in recent years. With current climate policies, standard climate change models predict an increase of 3°C in global temperatures compared with preindustrial levels by the end of the century (IPCC, 2014). Climate policies therefore need to be enhanced in order to reduce CO2 emissions (Stern, 2008). To limit an overshoot of the goal of the Paris agreement of 1.5°C global warming above pre-industrial levels, global net anthropogenic CO2 emissions need to decline by about 45% from their 2010 level by 2030, reaching net zero around 2050; however, total global greenhouse gas emission in 2030 are expected to be 16% above their 2010 level (United Nations, 2021). Carbon pricing can be an effective policy to reduce carbon dioxide emissions (Kohlscheen et al., 2021). Higher carbon prices make low-carbon energy more competitive, provide incentives to reduce emissions, and reduce demand for carbonintensive fuels (OECD, 2021; Martin et al., 2016). Climate change and climate policy are likely to affect inflation and the monetary policy transmission mechanism, and are therefore relevant for monetary policy (Smets, 2020; NGFS, 2020). Carbon pricing could lead to higher inflation via market-based emissions trading or new taxes on high carbon emissions, in particular from fossil fuels (Andersson et al., 2020; Batten et al., 2020). But such higher inflationary pressure could be more than offset by further innovation in renewable energy in response to carbon pricing, leading to lower electricity prices and increased energy efficiency, which could also reduce the weight of energy in the CPI consumption basket (Andersson et al., 2020). A shift in consumer preferences in response to carbon pricing towards climate-friendly products and services, which enter the CPI consumption basket when the consumer basket weights are updated, can also contribute to lower inflation (NGFS, 2020). The overall effect of carbon pricing on inflation is therefore unclear, and is an empirical question, on which there have been surprisingly few studies. Most of the research on the effects of climate change and climate policy on macroeconomic variables so far has focussed on the effects on growth.1 Monetary policy makers have discussed possible effects of climate policies on inflation. For example, ECB Governing Council member Schnabel (2021) mentioned that the direction of the effect of climate change on inflation was unclear; carbon prices could increase prices, but prices for sustainable energy sources could decline if more efficient technologies were developed, so that it could become cheaper to generate electricity from renewable energy sources. Climate change has been considered within the ECB’s monetary policy strategy review (Eurosystem work stream on climate change, 2021; Smets, 2020; ECB, 2021). Following the conclusion of this monetary policy strategy review, the ECB Governing Council stated its strong commitment to further incorporating climate change considerations into its monetary policy framework (ECB, 2021). The ECB Governing Council also decided to conduct theoretical and empirical analyses on the implications of climate change and related policies for the economy and the transmission of monetary policy (ECB, 2021). Konradt and Weder di Mauro (2021) find for Europe and Canada that higher carbon taxes do not have to be inflationary and may even be deflationary, with an increase in energy prices having been more than offset by a fall in the prices of services and other non-tradables.2 They mention that their study is the first to emphasize the impact of carbon taxes on inflation, so that more research on this topic is needed. Similarly, McKibbin et al. (2021) find for the euro area that the inflationary effects of carbon taxes on headline inflation have been contained, and that the impact on core inflation tended to be negative. They conclude that carbon taxes mainly affected relative prices rather than the overall price level. Kaenzig (2021) finds that surprises in carbon prices in the European ETS had a positive effect on energy and consumer prices. Using model simulations, McKibbin et al. (2021) find that carbon taxes only have a transitory effect on inflation.3 Our paper contributes to this literature by providing ex-post empirical analysis of the effects of both carbon taxes and prices of ETS on consumer price inflation and its food, energy and core subcomponents, for a broad sample of countries. In contrast to Konradt and Weder di Mauro (2021) and McKibbin et al. (2021), who only study carbon taxes, we also consider carbon ETS prices. In contrast to Kaenzig (2021), who only considers surprises in ETS prices, we also consider carbon taxes. Moreover, in contrast to Konradt and Weder di Mauro (2021) and McKibbin et al. (2021), whose empirical specification for inflation includes only carbon taxes, lagged inflation and fixed effects, we estimate New-Keynesian Phillips curves, which are commonly used for modelling inflation dynamics in monetary policy analysis, and which also control for output gaps, inflation expectations and exchange rate changes. Furthermore, we consider a wider range of countries globally (35 OECD economies), instead of just European countries and Canada. New-Keynesian Phillips curves are the standard way to model inflation dynamics in modern monetary policy analysis (Clarida et al., 1999; Smets, 2003; Woodford, 2003; Levin and Moessner, 2005). We choose cross-country panel estimation of New-Keynesian Phillips curves based on Jasova et al. (2019, 2020), in order to capture inflation dynamics well by including the effects of output gaps, exchange rate changes and inflation expectations. This approach allows to exploit cross-country variation to mitigate the difficulties of identification present for country-specific estimates, as discussed by Reichlin (2018) and Forbes (2019) in the case of the output gap. We find that an increase in prices of ETS by $10 per ton of CO2 equivalents increases energy CPI inflation by 0.8pp at the 1% significance level after one year, and headline inflation by 0.08pp at the 10% significance level, but has no significant effects on food and core CPI inflation. We also find that an increase in carbon taxes by $10 per ton of CO2 equivalents increases food CPI inflation by 0.1pp at the 5% significance level after one year, but has no significant effects on energy CPI inflation, headline and core inflation. Our findings are relevant for future climate policies. They suggest that higher carbon taxes and prices of permits in ETS have not led to large increases in headline inflation. Consequently, based on this evidence the use of carbon pricing to speed up the necessary transition to net zero carbon emissions need not be held back by concerns about large overall inflationary effects. This is relevant since these carbon pricing policies have been shown to be effective in reducing carbon emissions (Kohlscheen et al., 2021).4

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.