Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

UBI experiments prove that at worst, UBIs don’t cause inflation and at best, they decrease inflation

Miller 21 (Joshua Z. Miller; June 2021; “UNIVERSAL BASIC INCOME AND INFLATION: REVIEWING THEORY AND EVIDENCE,” UBI Center, URL: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3920748)//NTG

The most important studies done in the realm of measuring the price effects of universal basic income have been two general equilibrium studies, one looking at transfers from the NGO GiveDirectly in Kenya25 and the other studying the Mexican food assistance program “Programa de Apoyo Alimentario”.26 Both studies evaluated transfer programs to very impoverished places and the latter to a relatively closed economy, so obviously we can expect discrepancies between the evidence and what would happen in reality given a universal basic income in North America.

Egger et al. find that there was less than 1% price inflation on average as a result of the transfers. The greatest price effect is to housing, which the authors do not find statistically significant. There is a strong increase in consumption and firm profits, akin to an aggregate demand increase, with spillover effects, and little-to-positive labour hours change. The authors believe they found a transfer multiplier effect of over 2. Additionally, there was a formation of a strong potential growth effect in terms of permanent consumption and income as estimated by the authors. This overall aligns with my model; that is that is, cash transfers caused growth in both permanent output and output level and almost-nonexistent price change. This checks out intuitively: an increase in income resulted in more consumption and more output in an economy that has room to grow, so there will not be additional money-per-unit-of-output that ultimately underlies the Quantity Theory of Money.

The Cunha, Georgi, and Jayachandra study finds again a neglible price inflation effect. However, they do find that in-kind transfers provide deflation compared to cash transfers in isolated villages. Isolated villages likely suffer from imperfect competion and aren’t factored in to the monetary partial equilibrium. In the more-developed world with stronger market institutions, we would likely see different. Unfortunately, data for programs like these in the developed world is scarce.

A new general equilibrium study from The Phillippines,27 in the vein of the Mexico study, provides us further data to examine. It does initially appear to provide some contradictory evidence towards my findings, but further examinations prove otherwise. The study finds there was marginal price increases in certain foods in villages which received cash due to a demand effect. However, these villages were extremely remote, and these specific foodstuffs were goods with “relatively high transport and storage costs”. Given an opportunity for a more open market clearance, the demand effect may be subsided by a competition effect as shown elsewhere.

Some further evidence we can examine28 is Alaska’s inflation statistics. Alaska has had a universal basic income via the Alaska Permanent Fund Dividend, which has provided each resident between $500 and $3,000 per year funded by state oil assets, since 1982. Since implementing that program, Alaska has had lower inflation than the rest of the United States,29 whereas before it had equal. While no formal causal study has yet confirmed whether this supports the potential “deflation” effect of universal basic income I discussed earlier, it does provide suggestive evidence that it is possible and that a US-based universal basic income would not cause significant inflation. We can also appreciate the post-transfer deflation from Kuwait,30 where Kuwait granted a $3,500 transfer to all its citizens in 2011.31

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.