The Fed has an overwhelmingly leftist bias – means they would support the plan
Emre Kuvvet, Fall 2022, The Independent Review, “Political Affiliations of Federal Reserve Economists,” https://www.independent.org/pdf/tir/tir_27_2_01_kuvvet.pdf, mm
Overall, the Democrat to Republican ratio for the economists at the Federal Reserve System is 10.4 to 1. In other words, for every Republican economist at the Federal Reserve System, there are ten Democrats. Economists in the Federal Reserve System are considerably left-leaning. At the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, there are ninety-seven Democrat economists and only two Republican economists. Thus, the Democrat to Republican ratio for the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System is 48.5 to 1. Economists at the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System are overwhelmingly left-leaning. I also examine the political affiliations of the Federal Reserve banks. The Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco has twelve Democrat and one Republican economist. The Democrat to Republican ratio is 12 to 1. It is the most liberal Federal Reserve bank among all Federal Reserve districts. The role of leadership could explain why there is considerable variation in the partisan balance across the Federal Reserve banks. Leaders of some Federal Reserve banks such as the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco are more outspoken about politically charged issues such as climate change, gender, race, and inequality. A partisan leadership can encourage economists to conduct seminars and conferences and publish research on these politically charged topics. In fact, numerous types of conferences on these topics have taken place at the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco. If an economist does not share the outspoken political ideologies of the leadership of a Federal Reserve bank, he or she might refrain from working there. As a result, some Federal Reserve banks could become more partisan over time. The Dallas Bank has sixteen Democrat and two Republican economists, and its Democrat to Republican ratio for its economists is 8 to 1. It is the second most liberal Federal Reserve bank. The Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia has thirty-nine Democrat and five Republican economists. The Democrat to Republican ratio is 7.8 to 1. It is the third most liberal Federal Reserve bank. The fourth most liberal regional bank, the Federal Reserve Bank of Boston, has a Democrat to Republican ratio of 5 to 1. The Federal Reserve Bank of New York has a Democrat to Republican ratio of 4.6 to 1. The Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland has twelve Democrat and four Republican economists. Its Democrat to Republican ratio is 3 to 1. Even though it still leans to the left, it is the most politically diverse district among all Federal Reserve banks. Finally, the Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta has a Democrat to Republican ratio of 4 to 0 – a small sample, but an infinite ratio. In total, there are 111 Democrat and eighteen Republican economists at the regional Federal Reserve banks. Thus, the Democrat to Republican ratio for Federal Reserve banks is 6.17 to 1. Economists at regional Federal Reserve banks are also heavily left-leaning. Economists in leadership positions play prominent roles in the Federal Reserve System and oversee the work of other economists. They provide the research direction and establish research priorities for the economists in the Federal Reserve System. Table 3 shows the political affiliations of Fed economists in leadership and nonleadership positions. There are eighty-nine Democrat and four Republican economists in leadership positions in the Federal Reserve System. Thus, the Democrat to Republican ratio for the economists in leadership positions in the Federal Reserve System is 22.25 to 1. There are also 119 Democrat and sixteen Republican economists in nonleadership positions in the Federal Reserve System. The Democrat to Republican ratio for the economists in nonleadership position in the Federal Reserve System is 7.44 to 1. I find that economists in leadership positions in the Federal Reserve System are noticeably more left-leaning than economists in nonleadership positions. There are forty-four Democrat and only three Republican economists in leadership positions at all regional Federal Reserve banks. Thus, the Democrat to Republican ratio for the economists in leadership positions at all regional banks is 14.67 to 1. There are sixty-seven Democrat and fifteen Republican economists in nonleadership positions at all regional Federal Reserve banks. The Democrat to Republican ratio for the economists in nonleadership positions at all regional banks is 4.47 to 1. At the regional Federal Reserve banks, economists in leadership positions are considerably more left-leaning than those in nonleadership positions. Apart from Atlanta, where the ratios are the same, the Democrat to Republican ratio is much higher for the economists in leadership positions than in nonleadership positions for every Federal Reserve bank. The Federal Reserve Banks of Dallas, Boston, Atlanta, and Cleveland do not have any Republican economists in leadership positions. At the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, there is only one Republican economist in a leadership position, whereas there are forty-five Democrat economists in leadership positions. Thus, the Democrat to Republican ratio for the economists in leadership positions at the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System is 45 to 1. Table 4 presents the political affiliations of Fed economists by age. Column (1) shows the age range of the economists for the Federal Reserve System. The Democrat to Republican ratio for the economists who are forty years old or younger is 20.33 to 1. Thus, younger economists are overwhelmingly left-leaning. The Democrat to Republican ratio for the economists over forty years but younger than fifty-one is 15 to 1. Conversely, the Democrat to Republican ratio for the economists over fifty years but younger than sixty-one is 6.5 to 1. And the Democrat to Republican ratio for economists over sixty years is 7 to 1. Although still very left-leaning, senior economists are not as uniformly left-leaning as their younger counterparts. These results suggest that younger economists who will replace senior ones in the Federal Reserve System are considerably more left-leaning. Table 5 shows the political affiliations of the Federal Reserve System by the sex of the economists. The Democrat to Republican ratio for male economists at the Federal Reserve System is 8.5 to 1, while the Democrat to Republican ratio for female economists is 27.5 to 1. Thus, the results suggest that female economists are substantially more left-leaning than male economists in the Federal Reserve System. Research and speeches by the Fed economists are increasingly focusing on climate change, gender, race, and inequality. Regional Federal Reserve banks and the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve have been conducting numerous seminars and conferences and publishing research papers on politically charged topics. The previous literature provides indirect evidence of the politization of the Fed. In this paper, I extend the literature by showing the political affiliations of the Fed economists. My results indicate that political and value judgments in publications and analysis by the Fed’s economists could be linked to their ideological backgrounds. This is concerning, as the political homogeneity of Fed economists can undermine the legitimacy of their policy recommendations and analysis in the eyes of the public. That is, the public may see the Fed as a political institution, undermining the nonpartisan and independent nature of the Fed. In addition, scholarly works often reflect the political biases of the scholars in specific fields and highlight the ideological uniformity of scholars in those fields.8 Thus, economists at the Fed who do not share the majority political view might refrain from expressing dissenting views in their research and policy recommendations, resulting in a lack of competition in new ideas on monetary and financial policies at the Fed.