Natural gas infrastructure doesn’t ensure stable energy --- can’t handle weather fluctuations
Malik, 6/27/2023 -- Energy Reporter @BloombergNews (June 27, 2023 at 5:00 AM EDT, Naureen, “America’s Biggest Power Source Wasn’t Built for Extreme Weather; Natural gas plants, now the top source of electricity in the US, are to blame for a disproportionate share of outages when the weather gets rough,” https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2023-natural-gas-biggest-us-power-source-also-most-vulnerable/, Y.H.)
In the 15 years since the American fracking boom unleashed a torrent of abundant, cheap and domestically available natural gas, the country has leaned into the fuel — and hard. Hundreds of new, state-of-the-art gas power plants have come online with tens of billions in Wall Street backing in what’s now the biggest gas-producing nation in the world. Given its reputation for low-cost, clean and stable generation, gas dethroned coal in 2016 as the US’s No. 1 source of electricity. This year, it will make up a record 41% of power production, more than solar, wind, hydro and coal combined.
The grid’s newfound reliance on natural gas was for more than a decade hailed as a breakthrough. It’s now one of its biggest vulnerabilities.
[image of chart omitted]
Although natural gas is often promoted as a “bridge fuel” to span the transition from coal power to renewable energy, the country’s vast network of gas plants, pipelines and the regulations that govern them was largely built without the realities of extreme weather in mind. Facilities aren’t uniformly winterized, and some rely on a single gas pipeline for supply. Many generators don’t have the ability to burn an alternate fuel or keep back-up gas on hand in case of emergencies. The US has the most sprawling and interconnected gas pipeline network in the world, stoking complacency that the fuel will always be there when needed. But increasingly it’s not, contributing to more than seven hours of power interruptions for US households on average in 2021, more than double the rate reported in 2013.
Because the American gas system operates with just-in-time delivery in mind, it’s hard to adapt when a climate calamity hits, especially in winter. Eventually, the country will utilize less natural gas amid the shift to renewables, but it relies heavily on the fuel in the meantime. And since even the newest gas plants are at risk of becoming obsolete once the transition to clean energy is complete, it’s hard to get the support to build more pipelines and the other key infrastructure that’s needed to shore things up.
That’s the takeaway from more than two dozen interviews with traders, regulators and power-plant operators, many of whom weren’t allowed to talk publicly because of $1.8 billion in pending fines for generators that failed this past winter on America’s biggest grid.
“If you have assets that you can’t get fuel to, it’s useless,” said Thomas Coleman, executive director of Grid Security Project and a former adviser to North American Electric Reliability Corp. “We have a broken system, and it’s threatening our national security and it’s threatening our economic viability.”
Just look at the grid operated by PJM Interconnection LLC. It’s the largest in the country with a reputation as one of its most reliable. And yet, in the days leading up to Christmas 2022, when a brutal cold snap hit much of the continental US, PJM’s system was pushed right to the edge of rolling blackouts.
And gas was largely to blame.
To be sure, every type of power plant on the grid that spans from North Carolina to Illinois had some failures in the bone-chilling storm that rolled eastward on Dec. 23 and 24, including nuclear and coal. But natural gas was the standout: Those units accounted for 63% of the failures while representing around just 44% of the total installed capacity. Generation performance during the storm “was not acceptable,” PJM spokesperson Susan Buehler said in an emailed response to questions. “What we need, and what we are working on with all of our stakeholders, regulators and policymakers, is for all of our resources to perform when called upon.”
PJM isn’t unique — in fact, by most accounts, it performed better than many neighboring grids, some of which reported widespread electricity interruptions or blackouts. But if one of the safest power networks just barely scraped by in December, experts can’t help but wonder: How will any of the country’s multiple and highly fragmented grids possibly manage to stay afloat long-term, especially as America uses more and more electricity all the time?
“That’s a crisis that’s coming,” Mark Christie, a member of the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission and one of the most powerful US energy regulators, said when asked about the state of the country’s overall power system. “It’s coming a lot closer and a lot nearer and a lot faster than even I thought a year ago when I first said we’re facing a reliability crisis.”