A Putin victory or near-loss guarantees nuclear escalation.
Bollfrass '22 - Senior Researcher at the Center for Security Studies of ETH Zurich [August-September 2022, Alexander and Stephen Herzog; "The War in Ukraine and Global Nuclear Order;" Survival Global Politics and Strategy Volume 64, 2022 - Issue 4, p. 7-32]
The odds of nuclear use have increased in recent months, but this is not the first time that has happened. It is more relevant that Russia’s behaviour has brought nearly invisible constructs into public view, exposing the scaffolding of a European security environment based on nuclear deterrence and the targeting of cities. While these revelations will certainly shape government and public views on nuclear issues, it is premature to ascribe to them the erosion of the nuclear taboo. At the same time, complacency regarding the dangers of nuclear weapons in a world where they are used as shields to enable infringements of national sovereignty and grievous war crimes against civilians is simply foolhardy. Open debates on the value of nuclear deterrence versus disarmament as tools of security are long overdue. How they will be resolved is uncertain. In the meantime, Washington will need to seize the moment to continue reassuring its allies of the ironclad nature of its nuclear guarantees. In turn, the governments of US allies and partners should encourage honest discussions with their populations about nuclear protection to attenuate the effects of Russian scaremongering.
* * *
Russian defeat in Ukraine would amount to a public-service announcement about the dangers of attempted military aggrandisement even if it is backed by nuclear weapons. Russian victory would advertise the coercive power of nuclear arms and the vulnerability of states that do not possess them. The more Russia is rewarded for its war, the greater the danger to the global infrastructure for reducing nuclear threats. That infrastructure has absorbed many instances of irresponsible NWS conduct in the past. If non-nuclear-weapons states keep their nerve and band together, they stand to benefit most from a stable global nuclear order that they can preserve. And if the re-emergence of nuclear weapons at the centre of the world stage proves shocking enough, it may even be possible to improve on nuclear governance by moving decisively towards abolition.