Rate hikes crush the clean tech transition
Howard Davis, 5/6/23, The Guardian, “Central banks raising interest rates makes it harder to fight the climate crisis,” https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2023/may/06/central-banks-interest-rate-hike-climate-crisis, mm
But relying on central bank rate rises in the current situation is folly for another reason: the reality of the climate crisis, which now greatly complicates the task of central banks and policymakers. One reason is obvious: higher interest rates considerably slow down the renewable energy transition. This happens in two ways. First, newly applied renewable energy technologies, which have relatively large front-loaded costs, are more competitive (relative to the already installed fossil fuel technologies) only when interest rates are low. Engineering studies show that the levelized cost of electricity (LCOE) of solar photovoltaics (PV) and wind onshore will increase by 11% and 25%, respectively, if interest rates are 4-4.5% (rather than around zero). Investments in new renewable energy capacity are thus only viable if market prices allow them to earn their full LCOE [levelized cost of electricity]. Estimates by the International Energy Agency suggest that the LCOE of a gas-fired power plant would increase by about 4% if interest rates were to increase from 3% to 7%, whereas that of offshore wind and solar PV (utility scale) could rise by more than 30%. Second, high interest rates shield legacy oil and gas producers from the competition of up-and-coming low-carbon energy producers. They will enable oil and gas giants to continue to maximize revenues from their decaying, sun-setting assets; oil in particular can keep charging more and more for less and less for a long time. The year 2022 already gave us a flavor of the shape of things to come: Exxon posted $56bn in net profits for the year, while all oil majors combined made close to net $200bn. These windfall profits are very good news for shareholders, as Exxon is planning to spend $30bn on share repurchases in 2023 and another $50bn in 2024. But they are bad news for the rest of us – as high interest rates de-incentivize investments in renewables, lock our economies more deeply into fossil-fuel dependence, slow down decarbonization and put us even more strongly on the road to hothouse Earth.