Higher interest rates will derail the clean tech transition
Hielke Van Doorslaer, January 2023, Ghent University, “Why raising interest rates to fight off energy inflation is counterproductive,” https://www.ugent.be/ps/politiekewetenschappen/gies/en/research/publications/gies_papers/2023-global-energy-crisis/why-raising-interest-rates-to-fight-off-energy-inflation-is-counterproductive, mm
Monetary tightening raises the cost of capital, and this hits renewable technologies excessively hard.[10] Sustainable technologies are more capital-intensive than fossil-based technologies, requiring larger upfront investments, and, as such, become comparatively more expensive when central banks use monetary policy to raise the cost of financing. The higher capital-intensity of renewables makes them more vulnerable to interest rate hikes. Raising interest rates across the board therefore risks derailing the transition by inflicting a form of ‘green collateral damage’ on the economy.[11] By making credit more costly, central banks risk delaying the necessary investments in energy efficiency by both households, businesses and governments. Because of central bank actions, private actors are now faced with a higher cost of credit for renovation loans and a higher cost of materials and services (due to supply-induced inflation).[12] Higher interest rates also raise the borrowing costs for governments, constraining the state’s fiscal capacity for long-term investments in improved mobility, green technologies and sustainable infrastructure. Hiking rates in a macroeconomic environment of rising energy prices therefore risks aggravating the economy’s carbon lock-in and prolonging its dependence on outdated and polluting carbon technologies.[13] Interest rate hikes are not only counterproductive in the long run - as they exacerbate both the climate change challenge and undermine central banks’ primary objective of securing long-term price stability -, they are also in direct conflict with the ‘REPowerEU’ plan tabled by the Commission in which it seeks to ‘fast forward the green transition’ by means of ‘an increase in energy savings, a diversification of energy supplies, and an accelerated roll-out of renewable energy’.[14] Moreover, the ECB riskshiking rates at a time when inflationary pressures are seen to be easing.[15] Inflationary tailwinds may then quickly turn into deflationary headwinds. Martin Sandbu has likened this effect to a ‘ketchup bottle’, where shortages can quickly turn into gluts.[16] This risk is especially real when a sudden ease in price pressures coincides with a zealously overtightening central bank, possibly pushing the Eurozone into a recession. In that case demand will falter just when supply capacity is picking up, driving prices down instead of up.