10. A basic income may increase women’s access to their Preferences, but that is not gender justice, because those preferences are shaped by a gender unjust society
Gheaus, 2008 – political philosopher at the Université Catholique de Lille [Anca, Dec, An International Journal of Basic Income Research Vol. 3, Issue 3 “Basic Income, Gender Justice and the Costs of Gender‐Symmetrical Lifestyles” http://www.bepress.com/bis/vol3/iss3/art8 Acc 5/18/23 TA]
2. Entrenching Gendered Preferences Advocating gender‐symmetry as a default position raises the concern that, even under the conditions of increased gender justice, some women have a constant preference for being homemakers (Hakim, 2004, estimates that this is about a fifth of the UKʹs female population). Hakimʹs normative conclusion is that the best policies would give equal support to both categories of women, to those who are home‐centred as well as to those who are career‐centred. Leaving aside the question of whether it is at all possible to have policy packages that are neutral in this respect, there are principled reasons for rejecting Hakimʹs conclusion. Responding to preferences need not be the same as promoting justice. First, many preferences are adaptive, and since womenʹs preferences are historically shaped against a background of injustice we have good reasons not to take them at face value. Second, Hakim treats womenʹs preferences as if they were independent of menʹs preferences. But they are unlikely to be so: men and women work together and raise families together. If men were more homecentred and adaptive, this would have an impact on all three categories of women discussed by Hakim. The career‐centred women would find it easier to find partners willing to participate in raising a family, adaptive women would have more support in their endeavors of combining home and work, and there is evidence that even home‐centred women would be better off as they would be more likely to remain in their marriages (Hochschild, 2003.) Most importantly, the preference‐formation for women growing up in a world where, for both men and women, the default lifestyle is that they shoulder equally the burdens (and reap equally the benefits) of both work and home would be different than it currently is. In consequence, instead of responding to womenʹs current preferences, we should aim to ensure that preferences (of all individuals) are formed under just circumstances3. One of the deeply unjust circumstances of the current world is the devaluation of care.