Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

A UBI will not challenge gender roles – too many other social institutions and stereotypes exist to challenge the division of labor in the household.

Robeyns, 2001 – Chair Ethics of Institutions at the Utrecht University, Netherlands [Ingrid. “Will a Basic Income Do Justice to Women?: A Contribution to the Symposium on P. Van Parijs ’s “Real Freedom for All” Analyse & Kritik, vol. 23, no. 1 https://doi-org.proxy.lib.umich.edu/10.1515/auk-2001-0108 AC]

4.1 What's Wrong with Gender Roles and the Gender Division of Labour? In all countries, studies show that women do more unpaid household and care labour and less paid work compared to their male partners (de Hart 1995; Okin 1989; Steil 1997; Strober/Chan 1998; Wunderink/Niehoff 1997). In contradiction to the claim that this division would be an individual free choice, part of the lit-erature gives another interpretation (Okin 1989; Ferber/Young 1997; Folbre 1994, 1995; Neumark/McLennan 1995; Phipps/Burton 1995; Steil 1997; Strober/Chan 1998). Will a Basic Income Do Justice to Women? 97 Many feminists, including liberal philosophers (e.g. Kymlicka 1990; Okin 1989) have argued that the gender division of labour is unjust. Not all liberal philoso-phers are convinced by this claim. For liberals, individual free choice is crucial, and most of them see no problem of injustice if women choose to stay at home. If feminists believe that this gender division of labour is not a natural thing, or not a simple uncomplicated matching of preferences of two partners, how can this division then be explained? The combination of (at least) seven elements, and especially their interaction and mutual intensification can explain why so many women perform so much household-and care work. Unfortunately, this attempt to explain the current gender division of labour will remain rather tentative and loose, as it would require a huge study analysing all its details. Firstly, children are from a very young age in a different way confronted with images and ideas on the desirable roles of their own gender. Small children see their mothers taking more care of household work, whereas their father is the absent person, whose position and status in society is determined by activities in the public sphere. If children are raised with these examples of their own gender, and identify themselves with it, then small boys grow up with the idea that their realisation as adults will take place outside the home, whereas girls see that for them this will (partly) take place through care labour. A second element are the role patterns following from socialisation, and the confirmation of these role patterns through the media, movies, television and so on. These representations of gender roles and gender stereotypes are weaker than some decades back, but recent research still shows their existence (Van Zoonen 1994). Thirdly, due to the different expectations boys and girls have regarding the importance of care labour in their life, they will take this into account when choosing a course of study or profession. Girls will easier choose for subjects related to the care sector, or for professions that are easier combined with care labour. This hypothesis is consistent with the empirical fact that girls do not study fewer years than boys, but they choose other subjects and professions, which are considered more 'soft' and have a lower income generating capacity. Fourth, there is a group of labour market conditions leading to the fact that ceteris paribus women earn less than their husbands. Major elements here are labour market segregation and discrimination. Although there is a general tendency to believe that gender discrimination has almost virtually disappeared, recent evi-dence shows its persistence (Darity /Mason 1998; Neumark, Bank/van Nort 1996; Neumark/McLennan 1995; Wenneras/Wold 1997). Furthermore, Neumark and McLennan (1995) showed for the US that women who report gender discrimina-tion in their workplace, will subsequently have a higher incidence of marriage and childbirth. This undermines the commonly assumed causality that marriage and children lead to a lower labour market attachment and are hence the cause of discrimination. Fifth, a husband is on average about 3 years older than his wife, which implies, through the seniority rule in the wage formation, that wives earn less than their 98 Ingrid Robeyns husbands. Phipps and Burton (1995) find a significant negative effect of this age difference on the labour market participation of wives. They argue that age differences are likely to affect attitudes and hence the bargaining position of wife and husband. Sixth, empirical studies (Steil 1997, 48-50) show that the majority of men and women, including double-career couples, continue to view the husband as primary responsible for the financial security of the family. Women's wages are seen as secondary wages, even when she earns the same or more than her husband. As a consequence, a wife is not entitled to see her career as primary, and to exempt herself from household work. Finally, many men and women find it convenient and attractive to stick to the existing gender division of labour. It is a habit and it is easier, as past generations give examples how a household balance between labour and care can be found and as many elements in the organisation of society encourage such a division of labour. Looking for more egalitarian household organisations requires much more thoughts and negotiations by the couple and is therefore a more difficult route to go.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.