A UBI cannot change social norms for women and work without broader reforms in social infrastructure.
Lombardozzi, 2020 - Senior Lecturer in Economics at The Open University, UK [Lorena. “Gender Inequality, Social Reproduction and the Universal Basic Income.” Political Quarterly, vol. 91, no. 2, Apr. EBSCOhost, https://doi-org.proxy.lib.umich.edu/10.1111/1467-923X.12844. AC]
Whilst sympathetic to the proposal of a UBI, Daniel Sage details more targeted responses to the problems it raises. These include 'expanding parental leave for both mothers and fathers', 'incentivizing people to work fewer hours', 'enabling people to take periods of leave from employment', targeted 'guarantee income schemes' aimed towards the young or over‐fifties, and 'encouraging more people—especially men—to fulfil caring responsibilities without significant economic penalties'.[21] These could work in concert with equal pay and better work conditions, which enable a more inclusive breadwinner model. In general, more specific targeted measures to deal with gendered redistribution of unpaid labour around the activities of social reproduction and care provision are needed. A differentiated system of child benefit in the UK has created significant gains for women, but is still unaffordable for the most marginal and precarious at work—both men and women. Put on a proper footing, all of these measures promise to confront the crisis of social reproduction—and the crisis of the welfare state behind which it is concealed—in a more effective and practical way than the UBI. Indeed, even were we to accept that the latter can do what it claims, UBI can only carry through on its potentially emancipatory promise when accompanied by more systematic state interventions that acknowledge the complexity of work, life and wellbeing in contemporary capitalism. UBI will not create a system able to reconstruct social norms, but a more targeted social welfare system could. From this perspective, the full‐blown implementation of UBI schemes in the near future should not appeal to those for whom gender equality is a primary goal, unless it is complemented by a comprehensive set of public social infrastructure reforms that create a social contract based on solidarity.