A UBI would not solve women’s exploitation within a capitalist society – its individualistic approach ignores the root causes of sexism, and it depoliticizes the division of labor. A Universal Basic Services solves better and avoids the market based solutions based on income.
Lombardozzi, 2020 - Senior Lecturer in Economics at The Open University, UK [Lorena. “Gender Inequality, Social Reproduction and the Universal Basic Income.” Political Quarterly, vol. 91, no. 2, Apr. EBSCOhost, https://doi-org.proxy.lib.umich.edu/10.1111/1467-923X.12844. AC]
This is not to downplay the urgency in addressing social and economic injustice, but rather to recognise the need to focus our attention on equally probable risks that the implementation of the UBI might entail in terms of de‐politicisation of the causes and consequences of everlasting poverty. Last, but not least, the implementation of a UBI will not automatically eliminate the sexist attitudes and norms that created gender conflicts in the first place.[18] In this sense, UBI could worsen the wellbeing of poorer women by making them vulnerable to new ways of financial expropriation, that is, some men could manage to divert the funds allocated to women under UBI. This has happened already in situations where women start engaging with income earning opportunities and yet do not have full control of their spending decisions. By replacing universal provision of social services with commoditised needs and services, the neoliberal state has relinquished its responsibility for the social reproduction of the family and society at large. In this context, UBI might also reinforce the political trends towards the monetisation and individualisation of the provision of such needs and services. As a result, while inequality and social injustice increase, a gendered crisis of care would remain, because women would be stuck within the same set of patriarchal inspired duties of domestic labour and care at precisely the point when they have the least time and security in which to perform them. Unemployed women who sit at home will not only struggle to pay utility bills and risk feeling disenfranchised from the potentially dignifying experience of having a job, but will also stand to suffer a rise in social exclusion. In the context of these conditions, proponents for a UBI claim that the measure will help delegitimise the inquisitorial system currently used for determining eligibility for social benefits. However, the focus should be on the structure and processes through which the eligibility criteria are assessed rather than identifying UBI as the way out. Many are studying possible policy alternatives. Barbara R. Bergmann claims that the provision of free childcare highlights the different impacts of a UBI and the welfare state on gender inequality.[19] She says that whereas a UBI expands the opportunities for leisure, free childcare increases the options for paid employment. Bergmann continues by arguing that greater employment opportunities are likely to be more important for reducing gender inequality than UBI. Many employers have come to see women as long‐term participants in the workplace and, therefore, people worth training, putting into jobs leading to promotion, and then being considered for promotion. This kind of progress would be reversed if a higher proportion of women withdrew from the labour force when their first child was born because of a lack of affordable childcare. Universal Basic Services is also an appealing scheme.[20] Proposed in 2017 as a revival of the objective of redistribution and collective responsibilities and cohesion of the 'old fashioned' welfare state, it proposes a set of public, free, basic, and quasi‐universal services to address material needs such as shelters, sustenance, healthcare, education, legal support, transport and communication. Although in its original forms it lacked the much needed publicly funded provision of care, its recent version includes childcare and adult social care, which could reduce both gendered poverty and inequality. This approach goes in the right direction in two ways: it decouples the provision of societal wellbeing from market‐oriented, individualistic and 'productivistic' mechanisms, and it avoids the blurring of the line between citizens and consumers.