Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Neoliberal work roles and fiscal austerity are the root cause of gender inequality – capitalism only sees male labor as productive

Lombardozzi, 2020 - Senior Lecturer in Economics at The Open University, UK [Lorena. “Gender Inequality, Social Reproduction and the Universal Basic Income.” Political Quarterly, vol. 91, no. 2, Apr. EBSCOhost, https://doi-org.proxy.lib.umich.edu/10.1111/1467-923X.12844. AC]

With the rise of modern capitalism, be pro‐worker legislation in the West have kept children and seniors out of the factories, centering adult male workers at the core of the labour force. This 'productivist' setting solidified progressive political projects around the working class, but also implied a gendered division of labour within and outside the household. In particular, women were expected to support the family's 'social reproduction' at home by being responsible for food preparation, cleaning, childcare, elderly care, and so on. However, in the postwar period, the feminist movements—with the support of social democratic parties—promoted and were successful in ensuring that as the welfare state developed, public services provision for childcare, elderly care, and pensions were established. As a result, women were partially relieved from reproductive work, and their increased participation in the formal labour market enabled the fulfilment of women's intellectual, economic and social aspirations. Yet, such progressive trends did not last. Tithi Bhattacharya hanged social relations in ways that eroded women's material and sociopolitical emancipation. Women's engagement in paid work soon became less of a choice and more of a necessity, because male wages were no longer sufficient to maintain decent household living standards. Yet, women are often the first to be fired, and are subject to precarious contracts and part‐time work.[ ] Also, women with low socioeconomic status, from minority backgrounds, or in non‐heteronormative relationships, are often the most exposed victims of the costs of austerity paying with less work, the worst working conditions, low incomes or, worse, no job at all.[ ] The neoliberal model also dismantled social protection and benefits in favour of privatisation of care services and means‐tested social security.[ ] The shrinking of the welfare state has contributed to the transfer of care responsibilities back into the household, or in the form of commodified services in the market. For those who can afford it, the commodification of social reproduction has changed in various ways: from the multiplication of private nursery and elderly care agencies to the proliferation in the use of ready‐meals and take‐away food. Furthermore, an increasing amount of reproductive labour is performed largely by migrants and women of colour. The inability by some to pay for such goods and services has exacerbated exclusion and social inequality. Women who cannot afford these services engage in creative forms of 'care sharing economy' such as home‐based childminders and shared nannies. Hence, yet again, the most vulnerable poor are women, who have faced increasing pressure to cope with the 'double burden' of productive labour and reproductive work. They are not only poor in a strict economic sense, but they also suffer from time poverty, which hampers their socio‐economic mobility, wellbeing and, political participation. These worsening conditions in the three areas of care, work and welfare reflect the gendered crisis of neoliberalism and it is not a coincidence that atomistic and monetised policy solutions have become popular across the whole political spectrum. One of the solutions proposed is UBI—the focus of this article, in which I examine the arguments advocating for the positive effects of UBI on women and social reproductive work. I then discuss the limitations of those arguments and reflect on the under‐investigated tensions these have missed. Finally, the conclusion will ask relevant questions which untangle the case for a deep transformation of the socio‐economic structure of the economy.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.