Prioritizing a Gendered Justice framework is necessary to ensure that a UBI is designed and implemented in a way that reduces oppression and stigma
Karcher, 2018 – winner Best Undergraduate Paper in Labor Studies from the Bridges Center for Labor Studies at the Univ of Washington [Kathryn, Mar 4, 2018-2019 “Pursuing Social Justice: How Might a Universal Basic Income or Federal Jobs Guarantee Help Women? https://digital.lib.washington.edu/researchworks/handle/1773/43803?show=full] EP
Conclusion Sexism, racism, and classism embedded within our welfare policies have privileged some Americans while stigmatizing and oppressing others. We need new policies that account for these problems and actively combat the damage that previous welfare policies have inflicted. This requires us to evaluate potential policies not just based on their economic consequences, but also on how effectively they undermine the injustices that harm their intended beneficiaries. Due to women’s unique experiences under our past welfare policies, we need different policies which undermine the oppression they experience in the form of exploitation, marginalization, powerlessness, cultural imperialism, and violence. The justice-based framework employed above to evaluate two potential policies, UBI and FJG, demonstrates how advocates and policymakers can center vulnerable groups’ needs when discussing the potential benefits and consequences of public policies. My analysis shows that UBI more effectively challenges the root causes of women’s oppression via marginalization and cultural imperialism. That said, not all UBI or FJG policies are created equal. Although theoretical analysis reveals that UBI is the best option for women in principle, the intentions behind and the particular type of UBI or FJG implemented will have varying implications for women. We should not, in the interest of theoretical purity, favor any form of UBI over a justice-oriented and woman-friendly form of FJG. Labeling a potential policy as a jobs guarantee or a basic income matters less than the intention behind the policy and whose needs are considered before it is implemented. Based on this paper, one cannot conclude that UBI or FJG is inherently preferable to the other. Instead, whether those crafting policy center or neglect vulnerable populations’ needs will determine if a policy helps these groups. Still, due to its potential to further the cause of women’s liberation, UBI should remain a long-term goal as we transition toward a more just society. Although analyzing past and possible future welfare policies does not lend itself to a black-and-white conclusion, this paper shows why it is important to prioritize justice concerns when evaluating and advocating for public policies and demonstrates how this can be done. Justice-oriented frameworks and specific heuristics like those Young offers may not clarify all issues surrounding a particular policy, but they offer guidance and raise important concerns which advocates and policymakers should not neglect when they consider how their actions will harm or help oppressed groups and women specifically. If we want to challenge the racial, economic, and gender oppression that remain pervasive in the U.S., we need to prioritize social justice consistently and unapologetically.