Framework is essential to avoid oppressive welfare policies – if you ignore race and gender when examining the plan, you cannot solve for discrimination, empirically.
Karcher, 2018 – winner Best Undergraduate Paper in Labor Studies from the Bridges Center for Labor Studies at the Univ of Washington [Kathryn, Mar 4, 2018-2019 “Pursuing Social Justice: How Might a Universal Basic Income or Federal Jobs Guarantee Help Women? https://digital.lib.washington.edu/researchworks/handle/1773/43803?show=full AC]
Racism, sexism, and classism embedded in welfare policies reinforce women’s subordination. To implement welfare policies that do not stigmatize, degrade, or generally mistreat recipients we will need to consider how race, gender, and class interact to make economically disadvantaged populations vulnerable to public policy decisions that neglect their needs. This requires that we be mindful of why and how we implement certain policies. Mothers’ pensions were designed to benefit White women at the expense of non-White women, New Deal programs and FAP aimed to benefit White men and reinforce traditional family structures, and PRWORA reformed policies in response to their increasing stigmatization once they had finally become more inclusive of those women most in need of assistance. Going forward, we need to implement public policies that do not neglect already vulnerable groups and actively reject the biases and exclusiveness that characterized these policy choices. Pursuing Social Justice: Undermining the Faces of Oppression We need a framework to evaluate UBI and a FJG that accounts for vulnerable groups’ needs and rejects their oppression. The existing frameworks which most authors use to evaluate UBI and FJG prioritize the need to combat poverty, expand freedom, or ensure equality among democratic citizens. The framework that focuses on equality among democratic citizens is most relevant to this paper. This is not because combating poverty and securing freedom are unimportant for women, but because social movements historically have relied on the rhetoric of equal rights associated with citizenship to democratize America. Feminist issues such as suffrage and For example abortion are generally discussed in terms of women’s lack of equal rights within a nation that claims to be a democracy under which all citizens are equal. Due to our particular concern with women as a group being subject to inequality on the grounds of race, class, and gender, among other factors, it makes sense to use a democratic citizenship framework to analyze UBI and FJG. Instead, however, I argue that democratic citizenship does not offer an ideal framework with which to evaluate public policy. U.S. history shows that this model does not offer a secure or inclusive basis to evaluate policies and therefore is incapable of guaranteeing democratic citizenship rights for all. Historically, the category of citizen in which a person was placed, or their exclusion from this category altogether, depended on one’s race, gender, and class. In Civic Ideals: Conflicting Visions of Citizenship in U.S. History , Rogers Smith points out that American lawmakers have “unapologetically structured U.S. citizenship in terms” of “racial, ethnic, and gendered hierarchies,” and restricted citizenship based on “passionate beliefs that America was [...] a white nation, a Protestant nation, a nation in which true americans were native-born men with Anglo-Saxon ancestors.”84 So many Americans throughout our history have lacked equal political rights that courts and executive officials have been rendered incapable of clearly deciding who was a citizen. They have divided Americans into categories that include birthright citizens, naturalized citizens, non-voting citizens, jurisdictional citizens, commercial citizens, citizens subject to incarceration or deportation without due process, U.S. nationals, and colonial subjects. These distinctions have made American citizenship “an intellectually puzzling, legally confused, and politically charged and contested status.”85